Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What Trotsky meant by 'workers' state'

Socialist Organiser no. 383, 5 January 1989 · scan p. 9 · about 1,857 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

evitable downfall of the degenerated workers' state were coupled with the prediction of a political revolution in the USSR Only in the event of absence or another defeat of a European proletarian revolution would continued isolation of the Russian revolution also mean the final liquidation of the 'conquests of October' Throughout the Thirties Trotsky kept returning might thought almost obsessively - to the theme that, given its continued international isolation, the proletarian regime in Russia is doomed. The danger of this happening in the not too distant future was never far from Trotsky's thoughts. The absence of the material base for socialist development meant an inevitable progression towards capitalist counter-revolution. "At the core of (Russia's) economic ditficulties,' " wrote Trotsky in 1931.

**lie a number of contradictions of diverse historical origin...(a)...the heritage of the capitalist and pre-capitalist contradictions of old Tsaristbourgeois Russia, primarily the contradiction between town and country...(b)...the contradiction between the general cultural-economic backwardness of Russia and the tasks of socialist transformation...(c) the contradiction between the workers' state and the capitalist encirclement... These contradictions are not at all of brief and episodic character; on the contrary, the significance of the most important of them will increase in the future." (Problems of the development of the USSR, 4.4.1931; Writings 1930-31, p.206)

Left to its own resources, will move steadily away from a proletarian regime towards increasingly arbitrary rule by the bureaucracy. The latter, in turn, will further undermine the proletarian foundations of the Soviet regime and thus, incidentally see own destruction as privileged and parasitic social stratum.

*The correct policies of a workers' state are not reducible solely to national economic construction. If the revolution does not expand on the international arena along the bureaucratic spiral within the national framework. If the dictatorship of the proletariat does not become European and world-wide, it must head towards its own collapse. " (The Class Nature of the Soviet State, 1.10.1933; Writings 1933-34, p.102)

"The further unhindered development of bureaucratism must lead to a terrible social crisis and to the downward plunge of the entire society...this would imply not only the collapse of the proletarian dictatorship but also pre wit Th tag of fro sidi of list base.

"Absolutely false is the official doctrine of fatalistic optimism prevailing today, according to which the continued speedy growth of industrialisation and collectivisation is assured in advance and leads automatically to the construction of socialism in a single country."

(Problems of the Development of the USSR, 4.4.1931; Writings 1930-31, p.205)

*The economic successes of the present transition period do not...liquidate the basic contradictions but prepare their deepened reproduction of a new, higher historical foundation." (Ibid, pp.207-8)

Starting from the premiss that the ability of the Soviet government :pended on an alliance of workers ith the peasantry, Trotsky saw the Iderlying trend towards the unter-revolution primarily in rms of a break in this alliance.

The petty-bourgeois counterrevolution which genuinely thinks it is revolutionary, which does not want the domination of capital but inevitably prepares it - that is Thermidor...

*In the Soviet Union only the peasantry can become a force for Thermidor..." (The Danger of Thermidor, 11.1.1933; Writings 1932-33, p.77)

Apart from such economic intutions of the transitional period collective farms, becoming agenis for capitalist restoration:

...the peasantry has acquired from the Soviet state an organisation for the resistance in the form of the kolkhoz."

(Ibid.)

"With a shortsighted leadership, declaring a priori that the collectives are socialist enteprises, capitalist-farmers can find in collectivisation the best cover for themselves, only to become more dangerous to the proletarian dictatorship...

(Problems of the Development of the USSR, op cit, p.207)

Trotsky saw the break in the lance finding its main form of exission in tensions and conflicts hin the party and the apparatus.

sharpening of class anonisms would thus take the form a crisis of the regime, a threat m within rather than from out. e. "Why do we speak precisely Thermidor?" Trotsky is asking.

"Because, historically, it is the best known and most complete example of a counterrevolution which is masked, which still retains the outer forms and the ritual of the revolution, but which changes irreversibly the class content of the state...

"One should not see the picture as if the break follows a very clear social line: on the one side the peasantry, on the other the workers...The peasant masses surround and envelop the proletariat from all sides..the obvious falsity of the leadership, the wreckage of the bureaucracy's adventurism, the complete stifling of workers' democracy - all this makes even the genuine workers susceptible to petty-bourgeois ideas...

"Nor should one imagine that the line of the break passes somewhere between the party on the one side and the peasantry and a part of the working class on the other. No, the line of Thermidor inevitably cuts through the party itself..it passes through the apparatus itself...Everything depends on the relation of forces outside the aparatus. It only needs a sufficient blow from the petty-bourgeoisie for the Thermidorian bureaucrats to recognise temselves and to jump over the wall separating them from the class enemy... (The Danger of Thermidor, 11.1.1933; Writings 1932-33, pp.76-78)

...with the weakening of the party or with its degeneration even an avoidable crisis in the economy can become the cause of the fall of the dictatorship (of the proletariat)." (Problems of the Development of the USSR, op cit, p.211) "The bourgeoisie could come to power in the USSR in no other way than with the aid of counter-revolutionary upheaval...Yet with the maintenance of the Stalinist regime, the contradictions accumulating within the framework of the official party, especially at the moment of the sharpening of the economic difficulties, must lead inevitably to a political crisis, which may raise the question of power anew in all its scope.

*For the fate of the Soviet regime, it will be of decisive sıgnıficance whether the proletarian vanguard will be in a position to stand up in time, to close its ranks, and to offer resistance to the bloc of the Thermidorian-Bonapartist forces backed by world imperialism." (Ibid. pp.230-31) continued next week 0.382 saw a contribution Eastern Bloc from a supporter of the USFI, Phillip Ward.

While accurately pointing out flaws in our discussion, Phil failed to clearly explain Trotsky's position.

For Trotsky, Marxists had a duty to defend the remaining gains of the 1917 Revolution while opposing the Stalinist bureaucracy and building a new revolution to regain workers' control. What is there left to defend? Only the post-capitalist property relations. Defended against what? Capitalist counterrevolution, imperialist aggression, Stalinist attacks on workers living and working conditions and rights.

Phil is clearly confused on the question of Afghanistan. While correctly supporting the withdrawal of Soviet troops he says "their continued presence may be in the interests of the Afghan masses"! It's hard to see why, when you consider they napalmed Villages, made millions into refugees and built thousands of mosques!

Indeed, Phil is to the right of the USFi majority who recently stated the Soviet troops were " ...contrary to the right of self-determination of the Afghan people, and also the real interests of the exploited and „ODpressed throughout the region.

The USFI condemned the use of Stalinist troops (eventually!) but quietly, rather like some tiresome chore. It used the same "Trotskyist' rhetoric when Vietnam invaded Kampuchea, even though the situation was totally different! In contrast, Socialist Organiser correctly refused to condemn the Vietnamese invasion which was welcomed by the masses as liberation from the genocide of Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge.

The USFI's chanting of "Trotskyist' slogans while ignoring their content is not Marxism. Trotskyism isn't a series of statements learnt by heart. The scientific method isn't like a heap of tinned food you store You state rightly that none of the people who pay lip service to the degenerated workers' state position hold anything that Trotsky could have recognised under that label; you do not bring out that it was in the immediate post-war years that the division came.

Une side trying to keep alive the content of Trotsky's analysis, found itself forced to discontinue using the label. The other side dogmatically insisting on the label, abandoning Trotsky's own criteria as to what it meant.

I suggest one question to illustrate this. What do you think - had Tortsky not been assassinated - would have been his reaction (and consequently that of the Fourth International majority, since it is inconcievable that had he been alive a majority of the organisation would have voted against him) to the liquidation of the Third International? Would it not have caused him to modify his previous conclusions (not his reasoning methodology), at least to the same extent that the 1933 electoral victory of the Nazis did?

If in the years that followed 1933, Trotsky abandoned his previous insistence that Russian did not need another revolution and that neither in Russia nor elsewhere could there be alternative communist parties, is it Fidel Castro: workers' leader? up in the hope you have enough. It is the method of discovery and re-evaluation used by Marx, Lenin, Trotsky. To merely repeat their words - ignoring their meaning — is to betray their spirit. For all the USFI's talk of analysing the dynamics" of the Stalinist states, they have betrayed the Trotskyist programme time after time. Most sharply by refusing to call for political revolutions when the Stalinists took power in China, Vietnam and Cuba.

For the USFI, the force for socialism is Stalinist formations like the ANC, NLF and FSLN. Against that, Socialist Organiser argues the real Trotskyism — the irreplaceable role of conscious communist activity organised in a revolutionary party that leads the working class. To militants angry at the USFI's vulgar evolutionism we say join us in building that party - sell Socialist Organiser!

Duncan Chapel Nottingham reasonable to assume that he would not have made an at least comparable modification following this futher milestone in the degeneration of Stalinism?

The victory of Hitler, or rather the marked failure of Stalinism to prevent it, made him see an Hegelian leap (Quantity/Quality) in the attainment of bureaucratic power over the workers' state. While he insisted that it remained a workers' state, and while (agreed) he rejected the previous Thermidorian analyses. This was sufficient to make him say that his old analyses were no longer valid and to break with those many Trotskyists who were not able to follow him in this new departure.

Is it really to be claimed that Stalin's action in relinquishing the last semblance of proletarian internationalism (in order to placate the western bourgeois powers) and the consequent conversion of the world Communist parties into either openly peasant (petit bourgeois) military machines, or into mere agencies within the Western working classes, to advertise the interests of the soviet bureaucracy would not have caused an at least comparable reworking of Trotsky's theories? That is not of course to say that he would have necessarily adopted the theories of the previous bureaucratic collectivists; any more than he previously adopted the earlier Thermidorian Laurens

----- pull-quotes -----

letarian revolution in the West, Trotsky's predictions of the in-

What would T said in 1943?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 383

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →