The USSR: a transitional
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
this article is intended as an T attempt to clarily the exact maaning of the concept of the "transitional regime' as it was used by Trotsky in the 1930s in his analysis of Soviet societyTo begin with we have to ascertain what were the assumptions on which Trotsky's analysis was based and then see what follows from their acceptance. More particularly, we have to ask whether the concept of the 'transitional regime' , as used by Trotsky in relation to the Soviet society in the 1930s, can still be meaningfully applied to the Soviet society of today, le. whether this is consistent or indeed compatible with the way Trotsky used the term.
Trotsky treats the Soviet social regime as 'transitional' in two different senses. The first sense places it structurally between a capitalist and socialist society. No longer wholly. capitalist and not yet socialist, a mixture of capitalist and socialist elements as well as of institutional structures peculiar to the transitional stage proper.
When using the concept of the transitional regime' in the second sense, Trotsky introduces the dimension of time. The regime is not just an amalgam of contradictory elements. For this very contradictoriness, constituting as it es the underlying dynams of t regime, also circumscribes the regime's duration. The conflict between the antagonistic elements temporarily "Contained by the state, must be resolved one way or another. The diagnosis of the regime thus also becomes its prognosis.
The Immeme reason Trotsky discuses the characteristic of the transițional regime in the first sense is to differcuate it from a socialist regime, ie. in order to counter the assertions of the official soviet ideologues and those of the Soviet regime's Western afg Soviet society is not a socialist one, nor can it become socialist until its economy becomes linked with the economies of advanced industrial countries. Trostky insists:
*There is not an ounce of pedantry in (his) concern for terminological accuracy." (The Revolution Betrayed, p.52) and he restates the classic Marxist assumptions about the conditions necessary for the existence of communism and socialism.
*Marxism sets out from the development of technique as the fundamental spring of progress and constructs the communist programme upon the dynamic of the productive forces." (Ibid, p.50) 'The material premises of communism should be so high a development of the economic powers of man that productive labour, having ceased to be a burden, will not require any goad, and the distribution of life's goods, existing in continual abundance, will not demand..any control except that of education, habit, and social opinion." (Ibid, pp.50-51) "By the lowest stage of communism socialism Marx meant ...a society which forms the very beginning stands higher in its economic development than the most advanced capitalism." (Ibid, pp.51-52)
*The lowest stage of communism, to employ the term of Mary, begins at that level towhich the most advanced capitalism has drawn near."
(Ibid, p.61)
And he quotes from Marx's German Ideology:
"A devalufmeit of the productive forces is the changely a ra, cause mith out it want is generalised, and with want the struggle for i beings again, and that means that all the old crap must revive." (Ibid, p.60; Orig. Marx and Engels, 'German Ideology" p.46, 1965 ed.)
wing defined in these broad ms the material base needed for alism. Trotsky goes on to deal th the claims of the Stalinist reaucracy and their Western hos:
"The present Soviet Union does not stand above the world economy, but is only trying to catch up to the capitalist countries. If Marx called that society which was to be formed on the basis of a socialisation of the productive forces of the most advanced capitalism of its epoch the lowest stage of communism, then this designation obviously does not apply to the Soviet Union, which is still today poorer in technique, culture, and the good things of life than the capitalist coun tries." (Ibid, p.52)
Trotsky dismisses the a gumcut that the existence in the Soviet economy of state trusts in industry, the collective forms in agriculture, the state and cooperative enterprise in commerce constitute proof that socialism has been reached.
"It is exactly for the Marxist that this question (of socialism) is not exhausted by a consideration of forms of property regardless of the achieved productivity of labour." (Ibid, p.sh) *Juridicial forms themselves have an essentially different social content in dependence upon the height of the technical level. 'Law can never For the tion trad be higher than the economic structure and cultural level conditioned by it.' (Marx). Soviet forms of property on a basis of the most modern achievements of American tate of calated ite all branches that would indeed be the first stage of serialism." (Ibid, p.64) And Trotsky concludes:
*Soviet forms with a low productivity of labour mean only a transitional regime whose destiny history has not yet finally weighed." (Ibid)
From the point of view of socialist develapment, the difference between a "transitional regime" and a socialist regime lies in the fact that the future of a socialist regime is "materially assured", whilst that of the 'transitional regime' because of the absence of the necessary material base is uncertain. As Trotsky himself says:
"The strength and stability of regimes are determined in the long run by the relative productivity of their labour. A socialist economy possessing a technique superior to that of capitalism would really be guaranteed in its socialist development for sure — so to speak automatically - a thing which unfortunately it is still quite impossible to say about the Soviet economy. " (Ibid, p.52) unlike in a socialist economy ocial develupment in a 'transial regime' must proceed in conictions. And *economic contradictions produce social antagonisms, which in turn develop their own logic, not awaiting the further growth of the productive forces, (therefore)...it is impossible at present to answer finally and irrevocably the question in what direction the economic contradictions and society nail need so vie society - 188 course of the next three, five or ten years. The outcome depends upon a struggle of living social forces — not on a national scale, either, but on ar THE 8L000Y ASSASSIN OF p.53)
With the rejection of the proposition that socialism can be built with the resources available to a single country, let alone an industrially underdeveloped one, the question of the duration of the transitional regime becomes of crucial significance. For in the absence of Micrnational help for an isolated workers' state industrial growth is possibly only by paying the same price as that which has enabled the development of productive forces in all class societies, ie. through the appropriation of the surplus product by a minority class which controls the means of production. And how long, in the event of its continued isolation, can a degenerated workers' state distribute the social product according to 'bourgeois norms' whilst at the same time retaining its "socialist' character (in so far as it defends social property in the means of production)?
Nor is the state itself here a constant factor: it is in the continuing process of degeneration. An economy which lacks the level of development of material forces of production necessary for a socialist growth, and can in consequence arising out of a pre-socialist mode of production must, of necessity, be reflected in the c-1-1 degeneration of the "workers' state'. A "workers' state' , however, cannot continue to degenerate indefinitely.
For to say that the material conditions for development towards socialism are absent, is merely another way of saying that the preconditions to the creation of a class society are present. Hence, under adverse conditions, a proletarian regime, even in degenerated form, cannot survive indefinitely. The absence of conditions favourable to a movement towards a socialist development sets definite limits to the period of duration of a proletarian regime. The impossibility of socialism in one country means by implication also the impossibility of a long life for an isolated proletarian revolution.
Hitler and Stalin Hence the ampramu, in fact if not in theory. of the existence of "degenerated workers' states for an indefinite period of time, is tantamount to the * 1 at of Marxist premises regarding the relationship between the material base and social structure, in favour of a "gradualis" Fabian view of social acapu. In effect, this means the apare of the theory of otialism in one country' by stealth, le. bringing it into a "Trotskyist' conceptual framcwork through the back door. Trotsky dealt expely with the hrst question - that of the posibility of a 'gradual' development towards socialin "A majority of the vulgar defenders of the Soviet Union as it is are inclined to reason approximately thus: Even though you concede that the present Soviet regime is not yet socialistic, a further development of the productive forces on the present foundations must sooner or later lead to the complete triumph of socialism.
Hence only the factor of time is uncertain...However triumphant such an argument seems at first glance, it is in fact extremely superficial. Time is by To means a say facto when historic proctors are i question. - It is far more - to confuse the present and the future tenses in politics than in t Evolution is far from consisting, as vulgar cl of the Webb type imagine, in a Not tha which exists...It is exactly because the Soviet Union is as yet far from having attained the first stage of socialism, as a balanced system of production and distribution, that is development does not proceed harmoniously, but in contradictions. (Ibid.)
As to the second question - that of the duration of a degenerated proletarian regime in the USSR — Trotsky was no. less emphatic. Holding on to the 'probable" perspective of a victorious pro-regime?
Scan page 9
----- pull-quotes -----
By Vladimi Derer
THE SCUM OF THE EARTH: I BELIEVE
THE WORKERS ¡ PRESUME?
develop only 'in contradictions' by increasing social antagonisine