Children of Arbat
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Lombarg ether with the revolutionary p stewards and two Sparus members, including bknecht. It issued a leaflet ing for a mass demonstraand general strike, conling "Down with the Ebert¿deman government!" o Liebknecht put his name a declaration contradicting takus policy. Ironically, the iltant fighting has gone n in history as, the 'Sparas uprising' it first things went well. The monstration on January 6 enormous, and the general ke immensely successful, inving even SPD workers. ating offices and railway staIs were taken over and ister of defence Gustav ke fled to the suburbs. week later, the uprising was sated and its leaders were was true, as the Spartakus ership feared, the whole ect was premature. Berlin isolated. But once the *ement was underway, the blutionaries threw Liekknecht themselves into it. A central problem lay in the Joint Revolutionary Committee.
The Committee never acted decisively during the January events. They entered into negotiations with a government they had already declared deposed, and prevaricated helplessly. The workers out on were the leaders negotiating? To achieve what?) nor strategically (which buildings should be taken to best resist the counter-revolutionaries?)
Paul Levi, a Spartakist leader, described the scene:
"The masses were standing from nine in the morning in the cold and the fog. Somewhere their leaders were sitting and conferring. The fog lifted and the masses were still standing. Their leaders conferred. Noon came, and in addition to the cold, hunger came. And the leaders conferred...
*The fog came again and with it the dusk. The masses went home sadly, They had workers on tne streets of Berlin wanted great things, but they had done nothing. Because their leaders conferred. They sat the entire evening and the entire night and conferred. When dawn came they were still conferring or were conferring again." (Quoted in Chris Harman, "The Lost Revolution', p.80).
The initiative was lost. Many workers and soldiers were unprepared to go as far in opposing the government as the Revolutionary Committee wanted; they just wanted Eichorn reinstated. The government could play on their fears.
Social Democrat soldiers were organised in the Reichstag building as early as January 8 to 'restore order' . Then on January 11 the notorious Frei Korps began to march into Berlin, reinforced by their main force 36 hours later. They were now in a position to drown the uprising in blood. The SPD's paper called openly for the death of the Spartakist leaders.
On January 15 Liebknecht and Luxemburg were arrested. After questioning, Liebknecht was smashed in the skull with a rifle butt and later killed. *Bloody Rosa' , as she became known, was likewise smashed in the skull, then shot through the head and thrown into a canal.
So the 'Spartakus uprising' of seventy years ago was a bloody defeat. The German revolution was still not over, however. Between 1919 and 1923 other opportunities presented themselves for revolutionary action. The loss of Luxemburg must surely have cost the Communist Party dearly, and contributed to later defeats.
John f gr • carlomo "The Children of the Arbat' Anatoli Ryt-L--. (Century Hutchinson), £12.95. Aly spent some 20 years natoli Rybakov reportedwriting and attempting to get his massive novel, "Children of the Arbat', into print.
Initially it was to appear in the Soviet journal Novy Mir in 1967, but this was stopped. In 1979, the journal October announced its forthcoming serialisation, but yet again it failed to appear. Eventually it was published in 1987, to great critical acclaim in the Soviet Union. Now we have a chance to read this work and judge for ourselves.
'Children of the Arbat", like a number of recent Soviet artistic works - for example, Vadim Abdashitrov's film 'Repentance' -is an attempt to open up the hidden chapters of Soviet history, in particular the dark days of the 1930s purges.
It is 1934, a watershed year in Soviet history. Stalin, whose cronies dominated the Central Committee of the CPSU and who has complete control of the NKVD (Secret Police) is about to physically liquidate all surviving opposition.
Trotsky is in exile, Zinoviev, Kamenev and Bukharin are silenced and powerless, the whole country is on the edge of what the revolutionary writer Victor Serge, himself a victim of Stalin, but one who lived to write about it, was tc describe as "the long black night"
Unaware of the thunderclouds gathering over their heads, a mixed group of students, from the Arbat, Moscow's artist quarter, leave college and set out to build the new society under the guidance of the 'Great Leader', Comrade Stalin Most of them are Komsomol (Young Communist League) members. Some of these are careerists. But for Sasha Pankratov, the novel's main protagonist, the Party and the struggle to build a socialist society are his life.
But Sasha is also a growing human being with a sense of fun and an enjoyment of humour. He puts a few innocently mocking rhymes in the college newspaper and gets three years exile in Siberia for it. If the year had been 1935 it would have meant 10 years in a camp and almost certain death.
Sasha is the vanguard of that generation of Soviet citizens too young to have participated in the revolution. As 'Young Pioneers' or 'shock workers' they gave their sweat and blood to build the steelworks, dams and railways which became the icons of the first Five Year Plan. As a reward they perished in their thousands in the Siberian wastes.
Rybakov's vast, sprawling novel - the book itself is the size of a housebrick - details Sasha's downfall, his arrest, his interrogation, the long gruelling journey into Siberia and his fate in a remote village on the Angara river.
Through sketches of episodes and incidents from the lives of Sasha's mother, uncle and various friends it builds up a composite picture of life in the Arbat - a community of artists, intellectuals and professionals who were one of the prime targets of the first wave of purges.
Stalin feared and loathed Soviet intellectuals almost as much as he feared and loathed the Old Bolsheviks'. To consolidate and hold his power he set about their systematic destruction. Rybakov details this process quite brilliantly showing how the intellectuals failed to respond to the threat hanging over them and instead retreated into their "careers', or worse still, hoped to stay their time of execution by becoming informers for the NKVD.
Sasha himself is let down by his own friends, none of whom speak out for him: even the feeble petition they draw up in his defence is not sent because they fear to implicate themselves. Only the young woman Varya, not a Party member and interested mainly in expensive Western dresses, stands by Sasha and helps his mother in the painful and wearying task of going around the government offices to find out where he is. Standing outside of the system, she alone is able to see through it.
Rybakov's spotlight switches with ease from the Arbat, to a transit prison, to Siberia, and even into the very bowels of the Kremlin itself. Occasionally some detail is lost, but this in no way diminishes the power and sweep of his writing. The chapters devoted to Stalin are exceptionally chilling. Such is the man's power and ability to induce stark fear and terror, that one Central Committee member has a heart attack in a corridor in the Kremlin when Stalin chances on a casual conversation and asks the participants what they are talking The book ends with the assassination of Kirov (who was almost certainly murdered on the orders of Stalin himself), the popular secretary of the Leningrad Party Stalin was to use the assassination as the signal for the first of his many waves of terror, which by the late 1930s had destroyed virtually all the old Bolsheviks from the days of the 1905 and 1917 Revolutions.
While the news of the killing of Kirov reverberates even as far as the communities of exiles in Siberia, Sasha's friend and fellow exile, Soloveichik, is attempting to escape despite the onset of the freezing Siberian winter. He will almost certainly die of cold and starvation, yet Sasha admires his refusal to meekly accept his fate. As for himself, his fate is uncertain. It is unlikely, even after his exile is finished, that he will be allowed to return to Moscow, to the Arbat. On the contrary, as a fellow exile remarks in * Whoever did it the murder o the last sentence of the Kirov), Sasha,| I can tell you with utter certainty that there are dark days ahead."
----- pull-quotes -----
the streets were given no clear lead - either politically (why