Taming politi
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Tory Macmillan triumphant - with a little help from civil Save ben a rough, with Dame Edna' For those of you too stuffed on turkey or tipsy on sherry to have watched, the show took place before an audience of 'celebrities' who were invited to question Dam Edna, or to make witty comments.
One of those present was everyone's favourite champaign socialist, Derek Hatton, complete with ill-fitting Italian suit and overbrylcreemed hair.
His comment to Edna? "I've always wondered why I fancy you so much Dame Edna. I used to think it was because you remind me of Mary Whitehouse. I was wrong. It's because you remind me of Margaret Thatcher.' Suffice to quote Dame response: "That explains boy.
The humour of TV's 'Yes, Prime Minister', reputedly one of Margaret Thatcher's favourite programmes, is surely that there's more than just a grain of truth in it.
The revelations contained in the latest batch of Cabinet papers released under the 30 year rule does nothing to diminish the idea that the civil service, far from being a neutral institution, has a distinct political interest.
The Cabinet papers from 1958 contain clear evidence that Whitehall was involved in the reelection of the Conservative Party in the election of 1959. This assistance consisted of the evaluation by senior civil servants of manifesto options as well as a request by Sir Norman Brook, then secretary to the Cabinet, that senior ministers should have their workloads eased, thus freeing them for other work in the run-up to the The present discussion in the Labour Party on constitutional matters, bills of rights, and electoral reform has not as yet touched on the power of the unelected civil servants, but it must do so as a matter of urgency.
We asked Tony Benn and Eric Heffer, who are both ex-Ministers, to comment.
*Nothing in the official papers now released under the 30 year rule should surprise anyone who knows anything about the way Whitehall works.
*When a Labour government is in power the Cabinet secretary and senior civil servants stand aloof from all their election preparations:
Heard the one about the man who offered to sell his daugher for £500? In the tabloids' Christmas silly season this was one of their star 'strange but true'-type stories.
The man was in debt and was offering to marry his 18 year old daughter off to the first bloke to cough up the readies. Apparently (well, according to the loving father) he'd discussed it with her and she 'understood".
Bizarre. But, really, the only reason the story strikes us as parservice bosses but it is obvious that Sir Norman Brook saw it as his function to assist Macmillan to secure the third consecutive Conservative victory.
*This process is also believed to have taken place in 1974 when Sir William Armstrong worked in double-harness with Ted Heath.
"It is significant that Sir Norman Brook was later appointed Chairman of the BBC and was therefore in a position of great power when Wilson came to power in 1964, and at that time he retained very close links with the Cabinet Office on matters of broadcasting policy which I had to deal with as Postmaster General."
Tony Benn *When Tony Benn and myself were in the Department of Industry, the first argument you had every morning when you went in was with my senior civil servant. We would met another Filipino woman and, surprise, surprise, rapidly transferred his affections.
Just a silly inconsequential story? Well, from the amazingly uninformative Mirror article it wasn't possible to tell how pensioner Stan, 66, had got hold of this unfortunate young woman's name and address. What is certain, though, is that the Philippines are the centre of a squalid 'Mail Order Brides' industry.
Young teenage women are put on the books of 'dating agencies' (nice euphemism) by their impoverished parents. The girls' photos, together with a few personal details, are published in a mail order-type catalogue, generally available in the small ads column of Western European newspapers.
Essentially young women end up sold as toys-cum-domestic servants LAN say certain things had to be done: when you asked what was happening, there was always a million reasons why they couldn't be done.
"I remember, when we were first put in the positions, they had a party of the civil servants and we were invited along. One woman civil servant said to me: "Of course, we either tame the ministers or they leave."
*With us, their attitude was that they did their best to stop us doing things. With the Tories, a lot of them would see it as their duty, because they are basically Tories themselves and defenders of the Establishment, to help them and advise them in a much more positive way. It's not true of all civil servants, but there is a good body of high-ranking civil servants who believe that they are really there to assist the Tories."
Heffer to men often old enough to be their grandfathers. Such women have very little chance of escape - they are alone, in a foreign country, knowing no-one except their 'husband' Meanwhile, back in the Philippines, the woman's family have rid themselves of a mouth to feed, and earned a bit of cash in the process.
But, of course, the real winners are the men who organise the trade, who take their rake oft, who turn poverty and deprivation into profits for themselves via a trade in women. It's woman as commodity. In prostitution a woman will sell her sexual services for an amount of time. Here women themselves are bought and sold. Of course, the Filipino women who arrive in Britain like this aren't legally the man's property. But I don't suppose that makes much difference to them.
----- pull-quotes -----
WOMEINES EYE