PR, democracy, and socialism
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Labour front-bencher Robin Cook welcomes the sponsors of Charter 88, a democratic reform manifesto including Democracy is one of the tuted words in the political dictionary.
Mrs Thatcher is a great "democrat' in her speeches and demagogy - the self same Mrs Thatcher who has done more in the last decade to increase the element of autocratic state control in our lives than any prime minister since the end of World War 2. The same Mrs Thatcher who works as the relentless agent of the economic tyrants who control British finance and industry, and therefore rule our lives, completely outside any democratic control or accountability.
People like Mrs Thatcher give democracy a bad name. And there is far worse, in a world where even the totalitarian states of the Eastern Bloc call themselves 'People's Democracies' Nevertheless, the socialist who is not a democrat is not a socialist. There can be no socialism unless people democratically control their own society, at every level, from overall governmental administration down to the affairs of their own factory or office.
True, the Thatchers of this world have helped the Stalinists to convince lots of good socialists that democracy is and always must be a lie and a sham. Working-class socialists look around them in Britain, and see that whatever about the legal equality of all citizens when it comes to voting, in fact people like Rupert Murdoch and Robert Maxwell are a very great deal more equal than others.
Whatever about formal equality, formal free speech, and so on -and even those formal rights are very important in themselves, and worth defending until we can do better - in reality the wealth and power of the bosses, in industry and in the media, give them massive advantages. They can manipulate and dominate the lives of millions under the cloak of a formal democracy which is thereby neutralised and emptied of content.
The programme of democracy which the early British labour movement, the Chartists, fought for as long ago as the 1830s and '40s - annual parliaments, for example - has not yet been realised. The limited democracy and comparative liberty we have now is better than any form of police-state dictatorship. But it is, nevertheless, very much of a sham.
The socialist who concludes that democracy must always be a sham is not only giving up on democracy, but on socialism itself. Without democracy 'socialism' becomes a lying label for one or another form of dictatorship by a new ruling class elite.
The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965. date for reports: first Monday or by phone Monday evening.
Socialists must be consistent democrats. That does not mean that we make a religion of the forms, methods and institutions of the half-sham bourgeois democracy we have now. It does not mean believing that we can get socialism peacefully and legally by way of the existing institutions: the whole of history teaches us otherwise.
No ruling class gives up its power and wealth peacefully; a ruling class. threatened by real socialism will smash up its own legality and its own democracy and use violence to crush the socialists. Look at what happened in Chile - with the active support of the US government - in 1973.
The army smashed what had been one of the oldest democracies in the world, in order to overthrow a legally-elected Socialist government. They would try to do the same thing in Britain if socialism threatened.
But socialism must include a fight for consistent democracy. Consistent democracy throughout society - the original idea expressed in the name the workers' parties of Europe chose for themselves 100 years ago, Social Democracy - can only be achieved when private ownership of the means of production is replaced by a democraticallycontrolled collectivist system. fight for socialism is to fight for democracy - every inch and every millimetre of the way.
The discussion on proportional representation now getting under way in the labour movement can Proportional Representation only be taken to sensible concluRoy Hattersley. In any case, how sions if these considerations are ful- can PR be argued against outside ly taken into account. the quite narrow circles of the left Proportional representation is normally far more sensitive itself? measure of registering electors' opi- lemocracy because we think it wil We are against etterin! nion than the system we now have be bad for our party? Isn't that in Britain. It allows each vote to what Thatcher and her labour have roughly the same weight, while movement understudies say about many votes no weight at all. In a the first-past-the-post system gives us anyway, that we are against democracy? Isn't that, also, just word, PR is more democratic. another way of saying what the On the level of principle, faint-hearts and coalitionists say: socialists cannot be opposed to im- that Labour can't win? Tne left verproving and extending bourgeois sion is that we can win - but only democracy, however small the ex- with the rigged electoral system that tension may be. Therefore on principle we must declare ourselves for the ruling class set up long ago..
proportional representation. an overall democratic majority! We The arguments against this are can win with socialist politics and a weighty but short-term and narrowcrusading labour movement.
ly empirical. Yes, proportional representation is being argued for nock and the other fainthearts and by Labour's right wing. Yes, it is trimmers. Or should we amend it to used by those who think it will en- say: Yes, we can win - provided sure that there will never again by a the ruling class doesn't marginally majority Labour government. Yes, extend democracy?
it is now linked to the half-hidden programme of that section of the what we would have to say in Labour Party leadership who want honesty, and if we don't say that all to go for a Democrat-SDP-Labour we are left with is mumblings and coalition. private intra-Labour arguments But to come out in principle about which system is most advansystem is not the best way to fight against a bettering of the electoral tageous to us arguments we the right wing and the coalitionists. could not possibly use generally.
It is more likely to discredit the left. one - is perhaps useful here. In the In fact there are some prominent early years of this century, there lett-wing advocates of PR - like was quite strong resistance among Arthur Scargill - and some promi- socialists in countries like Belgium nent right-wing opponents of it, like and France to votes for women.
Women got the vote in France as late as 1945.
Editor: John O'Mahony socialists calculated that women out the Tories as soon as possible.
Any Labour government would be better, if only because it would be weaker (whatever its leaders might want) under pressure from the labour movement.
But if we argue in principle against an extension of democracy because we believe the less democratic system is the only one under which we can win, then we put ourselves in an invidious position.
That, in our opinion, is the position in principle. There is more to it, of course.
As we have argued above, what Yes, we can win! Yes, we can get we have in Britain and similar countries is a feeble and in many ways sham democracy, in which the ruling class has massively unfair adThat's what we say now to Kin- vantages: That democracy needs more than tinkering with before it will be anything like real democracy. It will take a socialist revolution to make the qualitative leap from what we have to the The idea is absurd. Yet that is democracy the working class needs.
Socialists cannot in principle oppose PR; but here and now there is nothing that compels us to make a religion of it — nothing that compels us to support the Labour right wing's campaign for this small improvement in a grossly deficient A parallel - a limited and partial system and say to hell with the conSocialist E unilaterall sm Why? Because some of the LEAVE THI Kinnock rats 75p plus PO Box i SE15 4N sequences.
PR is now the cry of the coalitionists in the labour movement. The coalitionists must be opposed and defeated. They must be told: yes, PR is good, but there are more pressing things before the labour movement - the battle to kick out the Tories and to ensure that the labour movement has real alternative policies and is not dominated by pink Thatcherism.
They must be told that their campaign for PR not only detracts from the main question of fighting for a working class alternative to Thatcherism, but gives immediate advantages to the ruling class and its parties.
That - rather than untenable and (from the point of view of consistent democracy) unprincipled opposition to PR as such — is the way to answer the coalitionists.
On that basis the left should say to the right-wingers who want to distract us now with a campaign for a little bit of democratic tinkering - no, not now, not this campaign. Right now, the labour movement must fight to get rid of the Tories and to put in a government based on the working class and committed to secure its needs. Labour must contest every parliamentary constituency.
postage from