NEC whitewash defeat
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-12-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
The outcome of the Labour the Govan by-election in Glasgow on 10 November is the predictable cover-up.
The Govan by-election saw a 33% swing to the Scottish National Party. The Labour vote collapsed from 24,071 in last year's General Election to 11,123. The SNP vote jumped from 3,851 to 14,677 to give them victory.
The NEC's inquiry's explanation for this debacle? The campaign organisation was poor, more party members should have been out canvassing for Labour and the Labour candidate although "credible" could, in the inquiry implies, have been better.
The solution to avoid another such humiliation in future? You've guessed it - the NEC should have the powers to select parliamentary candidates in future by-elections! How convenient for the NEC that just at the time it is seeking such powers, its inquiry into Govan should come out in favour.
Unfortunately, but not unsurprisingly, the NEC inquiry's findings were devoid of any relationship to reality.
Govan was not a one-off incident but part of a pattern. In the 1987 General Election the SNP won 10% of the vote in Scotland. In the 1988 District Council elections they won 20% of the vote. They now stand at 30% in the opinion polls.
A number of local council by-elections held in recent months -without the glare of publicity which the Govan by-election received -have shown the SNP consistently improving their position, gaining seats from Labour.
The problem in Govan was not the number of Labour Party canvassers out on the streets, but the message which the Labour canvassers were expected to deliver to the electorate: "Vote Labour, pay the Poll Tax!" This hardly encourages Labour Party members to go canvassing. It certainly did not encourage voters to support Labour.
One explanation for Labour's defeat in Govan is that Labour lost the seat because the party has failed to pay sufficient attention to the so-called "Scottish dimension" in politics. I don't agree with this argument, but a serious inquiry into Labour's defeat would at least address it. Not so the NEC inquiry, however.
The NEC inquiry's outcome is nothing but a sham. Who - apart from the members of the inquiry -could deny that Labour paid the price in Govan for the miserable performance of Labour MPs in Parliament, the failure of Labour controlled councils to fight the poll tax, and the general bankruptcy of Neil Kinnock's no-fight leadership of the party?
CLPs should pass resolutions condemning the inquiry as a sham and rejecting its proposal to strip CLPs of their rights to select candidates in parliamentary byCLPs in Scotland should also pass resolutions demanding that the findings of the separate Scottish inquiry into Govan be circulated round CLPs for amendment and that they be presented to the 1989 Labour Party Scottish annual conference for voting upon. meeting of its leading body, the National Organising Committee (NOC) was to ban dual membership, apart from with the Labour Party. It was a measure directed against the IMG, alleged members of which soon came to be suspended (on the basis of hearsay). The Leith and Glenrothes SLP branches were shut down on the basis of an alleged IMG takeover Without prior consultation with the Glasgow membership, the SLP leadership reorganised the Glasgow branch into a series of smaller branches so as to isolate its opponents.
Illusions that the SLP would automatically support workers in struggle were quickly shattered. When the Cumbernauld SLP branch backed local refuse workers on strike against the attempts of the local SNP-controlled council to cut their wages, the NOC refused to support the branch's action, apparently fearful that to do so would alienate the SNP and give the SLP too "extreme" an image.
The SLP was more sympathetically disposed towards the SNP than towards striking workers. It announced that it would only contest Labour-held seats where the SNP was not a stronger challenger. Foreshadowing his own membership of the SNP, Sillars also favoured dual membership of the SLP and SNP engage in any political accounting for recent events - plus the loss of free publicity via the press — combined to ensure the demise of the SLP, forcing Jim Sillars to take up his natural political home in the SNP.
Jim Sillars' political authoritarianism was certainly a major factor in explaining why the SEP ended up as yet another "dream turned sour". His autocratic leanings ran counter to the SLP membership's hopes of a more democratic party.
But the focus on Sillars obscures the deeper political failure of the SLP, which was inbuilt from the outset: it was a collection of individuals lacking common political programme and devoid of a base in the labour movement. Not a single trade union or Labour Party branch, nor the majority of any branch, joined the breakaway SLP.
The ingredients for another SLP (whatever name it chooses to call itself can easily be collected: semi-charismatic figure converted the cause of Scottish nationalism, a couple of academics, and a collection of politically confused though well-meaning people to serve as the foot soldiers. And there is no reason to believe that an SLP Mark II would not meet the fate of its less than illustrious predecessor, and deservedly so.
----- pull-quotes -----
Committee's inquiry into Labour's catastrophic defeat in