Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Labour and Scotland

Socialist Organiser no. 382, 15 December 1988 · scan p. 13 · about 813 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

To iS Even before Labour's debacle in the Govan by-election, the ground was being prepared for a breakaway Scottish Labour Party. Labour's humiliation and the Scottish National Party's sensational success in that by-election have given added impetus to the movement towards a breakaway.

This article outlines the history of the last attempt to form a Scottish Labour Party and concludes that the current attempt to repeat history is unlikely to be any more successful, The Scottish Labour Party (SLP)

was launched in January 1976. By October of the same year it was in its death throes.

The SLP stood for Scotland and Socialism. "We are Scottish with a capital 'S' and Socialist with a capital 'S'," declared its leader Jim Sillars, at the SLP's founding meeting. The SLP was to be more *Scottish" than the Labour Party and more socialist than either the Labour or Scottish National parties.

The SLP was also to be more democratic than the Labour Party, or at least many of those joining it hoped and believed so.

At the time of the formation of the SLP, Jim Sillars was Labour MP for South Ayrshire. Once a firm opponent of devolution, he had gradually swung round to a perspective of Scottish independence within the Common In the early 1970s Sillars had met regularly with three other MPs John Robertson, Harry Ewing and Alex Eadie, though the latter two eventually dropped out) and various journalists (especially from the Scotsman) to discuss plans for reforming the Labour Party in Scotland. After the 1974 general election, against a background of the rise of the Scottish National Party, the focus of the meetings shifted to the creation of a breakaway Scottish Labour Party. Jim Sillars, The involvement of journalists ensured good press coverage. The Economist magazine described Sillars' SLP as "the darling of the Scottish political correspondents" The 32 issues of the Scotsman which appeared between the first "leak" about the creation of a new party and the inaugural meeting of the SLP carried 28 articles about the event, 14 of them on the front page.

Some 400 people attended the SLP's inaugural meeting in Glasgow in January 1976. The new party's members included journalists Chris Baur and Neal Ascherson, and academics such as Tom Nairn (author of "The Break-Up of Britain') and Jim Young.

But the gap between the SLP's aspirations and the composition of its membership was summed up by one of the numerous post-graduates who joined the party: "Sillars' problem was that he wanted my father — who's a railwayman — to join; What he got was me."

The International Marxist Group (political forerunner of today's Socialist Action and Labour Briefing) also directed its members, somewhat haphazardly, into the new party.

The SLP's promise of an open and democratic party soon bit the dust. The first decision of the first The economic policies adopted by the SLP were less than radical.

The 'Jobs and Industry' document adopted by the NOC proposed the government agencies, «regenerate" establishment of nearly a dozen pointed boards, the Scottish economy in conjunction with multi-national corporations, whose operations in Scotland were to be welcomed. Rather than propose the wholesale takeover of all financial institutions, the document restricted itself to the possible purchase of one major banking group.

Discontent with the political direction of the new party and the increasingly autocratic nature of its leadership came to a head at the SLP conference held in October. The NOC misread the situation and believed that the unrest had been engineered by the IMG. Hence the remedy was to crackdown on the latter.

"At times of crisis, working-class organisations expel without discussion," declared Sillars. "We should get our fucking pit boots on and wade right into them,' " suggested another member of the NOC.

In fact, the IMG members were too few in number and too disorganised to pose a real threat to Sillars. Although the first session of the SLP's October conference voted to approve the suspension of the Leith branch and of alleged IMG members, this did nothing to diminish criticism of the leadership. Sillars hit back by having emergency resolution railroaded through the conference, expelling another four SLP branches.

By the end of the October conference the SLP was damaged beyond repair. The expelled branches and individual members who had left in disgust at the expulsions set up the SLP (Democratic Wing). The IMG moved quickly to take over the new organisation, which consequently went into rapid decline. By the time it declared itself in favour of affiliation to the IMG's. version of the Fourth International. it consisted of no more than the IMG's Scottish membership, plus one or two others.

Sillars' SLP was likewise in a state of terminal decline. A declining membership, a growing financial deficit, a slump in the level of activity, a still more autocratic leadership, and a strict refusal to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 382

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →