A victory agains the witch hunt
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-12-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
It the Wales Labour Party A Regional Conference last May, the Regional Organiser, Anita Gale, declared: "We do not need to set up a New Model Labour Party in Wales — we already are the New Model Labour Party."
This is quite an astonishing claim in a region that is full of old-fashioned, right-wing party bosses running moribund local party organisations. There are still places where they tell you that you can't join the ward because "we're full up" While people who should know better romanticise about a "socialist heartland", the valleys reverberate with the sound of longdead militants spinning in their graves.
There is another reason why Cde. Gale's proclamation is rather premature - that is the fight against the witchhunt in Cardiff Central. One ward within the constituency, Plasnewydd, was suspended last February, ostensibly on the grounds that one Chris Peace was present at the ward AGM.
Chris was expelled in October 1987 for being a supporter of Militant and the ward's explanation that he was attending the AGM as a guest was not accepted. Anita Gale had informed the constituency officers that if the ward was not suspended, then the constituency would be.
Accordingly, the constituency executive met and obeyed the diktat, though the fact that non-executive committee members were present and voting made the decision unconstitutional. Cde. Gale judged that this was an inadvertent error and therefore didn't matter the suspension stood. Worse, the ward was to be investigated by an 'inquiry.
Plasnewydd was clearly being 'fitted-up'. Despite repeated requests, verbally and in writing, Anita Gale has never been able to quote which party rule or NEC rulWHERE WE STAND Socialist O-Janice: stands for workers' liberty East and West. We aim to help organiss the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with worki-g class socialism.
We want public ownerchip of che major enterprises and a planned economy under Burkete control. We want ESUBISICRIIBE Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post.
Rates(UK) E8.50 for six months, E16 for a year.
Name my Address Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E To:
Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. ing was broken by the ward. Even more embarrassing from her point of view, right-wingers in the constituency were spilling the beans about the witchhunt. The constituency secretary admitted it was all about "re-fashioning the constituency in the image of the leadership now that it was a key marginal."
Chief witchhunter and exParliamentary candidate, Jon Jones, spilled his guts to the press, talking about "restoring the integrity of the party in Plasnewydd."
What lay behind these shenanigans was a very crude and bungling attempt to silence a very active, campaigning and, worst of all, left-wing ward. Typically, the right-wingers in Cardiff Central run wards that have low membership, poor turn-outs, and do not actively campaign outside of election time. More generally, Plasnewyda has been a thorn in the side of local party bosses for a while now. These people control City and County Councils that enthusiastically use "new realist' attitudes to justify the implementation of Tory policies.
The crunch came over a County Council plan to re-organise tertiary education and set up sixth-form colleges. Included in this plan was a proposal to close the excellent multi-racial Howardian Comprehensive School in Cardiff Central. This was justified by using the straightforward Tory argument that falling school rolls mean school closures.
The proposed closure generated an incredible community outcry and a lively, well-supported campaign to keep the school open and for the Council to refuse to make the cuts in education demanded by the Welsh office. This campaign naturally had the support of Plasnewydd and other wards, and even the constituency party, but what really angered the party bosses was the recruitment of the chair of the Save Howardian Action Committee into membership of Plasnewydd ward. It was after this point that local rumblings about 'getting' Plasnewydd ward became audible — even on the Labour Party Wales Executive.
The real reason for the suspension then, lay here. It was an atamocracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and = privileges.
Se-i-lic- can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own crit-list or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwide, including the struggle of workers and - nationalities in the Stalinist SOCIALT BREADF Neil Kinnock. Photo: John Harris. tempt to root out opposition to the policies of the right-wing Labour councils, and also to reshape the party, minus its vocal left-wing. Here, too, were the sources of the blunders made by the witchhunters. Their lack of political judgement, revealed in unpopular policies, also led them to think the left could be suppressed if only the ward was suspended.
With the ward out of the way, the real cause of the problem would be isolated and dealt with - a small number of committed individuals could be picked off and that would be that. They were wrong on both counts.
In the first place, the reaction from members of the consituency was fury. Excluded from the constituency AGM, Plasnewydd organised a large and successful lobby. Delegates from other wards demanded the reinstatement of Plasnewydd and refused to let the business of the AGM proceed. At the second attempt to hold the seated against their own We stand:
For full equality for women, and social provicion to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass deportations and all immig tion controls.
For squality for lastiane and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clari* For a abour get or - to the most eFfi ed, acco-s to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.
We want Labour Party and trade union =-|-= who support our basic ideas to -supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contilation to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is mooretically telled b our eFforters through Annua General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board. AGM a week later, the Plasnewydd delegates occupied the meeting for 45 minutes.
Despite the presence of Anita Gale, the business was talked out once again. While the first AGM was bantering and relatively lighthearted, the second was angry and came close to violence. In a vain attempt to ram through the business, both the party rule book and local standing orders were virtually ripped up. Anita Gale appeared to be totally confused about which body had suspended the ward - whether it was the constituency executive, Labour Party Wales executive or, as she said on another occasion, "no-one really suspended the ward"!
The witchhunters had clearly not expected such strength of feeling and had begun to run for cover. A meeting of constituency officers argued that the suspension was unconstitutional, that the ward should be allowed to re-run its AGM and that, meanwhile, the constituency AGM should be adjourned. This was turned down by Cde. Gale who handed the whole matter over to Joyce Gould, the Labour Party's Director of Organisation at Walworth Road, after the second attempt to complete the AGM talled.
At this point a number of comrades in the constituency set up *Fight the Witchhunt in Cardiff Central' under the banner of Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) and consciously modelled on the 'Reinstate Khan and Scally' campaign in Birmingham. Letters asking for support, a model resolution, a background information pack and a press release were issued as widely as possible. Speakers were invited by other wards.
The Regional Conference at Tenby was leafletted and lobbied in May and a FWHCC speaker appeared on the platform of the Benn-Heffer fringe meeting. The ultimate sign of recognition came when the campaign was denounced from the conference platform by George Wright, T&GWU regional secretary and head witchhunter in these parts. The campaign was also taken to the Chesterfield Conference where fringe meetings were lobbied.
The response to all of this activity varied. Hardly surprisingly, the best came from South Wales itself, with wards, CLPs and Women's Councils expressing support. What was more surprising was the paucity of the national response. With a few honourable exceptions, the campaign received almost no support outside South Wales.
The response of the right, and, more specifically, of Joyce Gould, became clear only slowly. The constituency AGM was held for a third time without Plasnewydd and, heavily stewarded, it was completed. But then there was what appeared to be a climb down. All mention of an inquiry into the ward was dropped. Anita Gale even denied she had called for an investigation. Instead the ward was to have a new AGM after the credentials of each member had been checked. There followed the farce of the Labour Party Wales organiser "doorstepping' every member of the ward over a number of weeks. Joyce Gould was obviously punishing local witchhunters for failing to do the business.
At the new ward AGM held, appropriately enough, on Halloween night, the rump of a right-wing were hammered by the left. In the eight months of sus penniun support for the left had actually increased and the same officers were returned with larger majorities. The ward has since reaffirmed its cigin stance over the Poll Tax and over the proposed closure of Howardian school.
The lessons of all this are ob vious. In the first place, the witchhunters must be fought. Keeping our heads down will not make the bogeyman go away. Even now in Cardiff Central the right-wing are returning to the fray and stampling to witchhunt individuals. Secondly, they must be opposed with as broad and open a campaign as possible. The essential thing is to politici the fightback by pointing out the underlying isues and giving them publicity.
Thirdly, when comrades hear of an appeal for support by people being witchhunted, listen to it and act on it! Nothing boosts the morale than hearing of support from far away places — it's called solidarity. Also, nothing disheartens the rightwing more than a fightback that begins to sprcad.
Finally, it is possible to win, even if it is only one battle. If it ever comes into being, the New Model Labour Party will be built over the hopes, wishes and ideas of all kinds of people on the left. These comorganised left, stand to be abused, as well as those on the ignored and even expelled if the leadership have their way. A fight against the witchhunt can be a tremendous force for unity on the left, and that unity is essential in winning the battle for socialist ideas in the Labour Party.
----- pull-quotes -----
Britains death exposees
working-les: tooed women's Against racism, and against