Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Patriarchy': a static theory

Socialist Organiser no. 382, 15 December 1988 · scan p. 8 · about 1,177 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

"Women must fight as part of the labour movement" - South African workers at Checkers, on strike 1. We aim to build a mass campaign #there im-obe temen who do those fighting for rank and file conmothers, the right to wages, benefits sot ream+ ose met-ements.

StalIs 3. We aim to strengthen the position against those who hold back and sell m leci-to lake-o-macas-a government that ignores party decidefended and extended in face of the - a-wona hite 15-4* onslaught against women by awd ligote te 1x1 e anea 2. Such a mass campaign has to be - --- the to the Tory attacks. We aim to pro- He Motr-to 10m for united action by m-pare int the lam d-101 tices La wne wHo pte a iml ploits and oppres-ms. Lynn Ferguson that women's oppression is linked with class exploitation It is common currency amongst all feminists, from radical feminists to socialist feminists, to use the term 'patriarchy'. As a descriptive terms it seems very useful - throughout history men have lorded it over women, have dominated all aspects of public life.

Women have occupied a subordinate role, have been exiled to the margins of society, have been abused. beaten and raped by men. Even now, 20 years on from the women's movement, rampant sexism still exists, women still receive lower wages than men, and are concentrated in jobs modelled on their role in the home.

Throughout history there have been complex networks in society which have held women down. Surely this is 'patriarchy'?

But the trouble with patriarchy as a concept is that it obscures the real issues. We end up with a history which is defined by the oppression of women by men, in which the sex struggle is paramount.

Or, in the socialist-feminist version, we have two parallel systems linked but with their own autonomy - patriarchy and class society. The patriarchy and the class system are seen as essentially separate, each with its own history, and each requiring its own struggle to overInrow It.

Shulamith Firestone, in her book *The Dialectic of Sex' uses Engels' *The Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State' to map out a detailed theory of patriarchy. Engels said the first class division was that between men and women. Firestone interprets this as saying that the sex struggle is primary, that class divisions are built on top of the original sex-class division. Patriarchy is the thread running through human history, and which needs a revolutionary struggle to overthrow it.

The French feminist, Christine being mounted on women's rights.

such as the right to control our own Terillig childeare facilities, the right to work, the right to live in this country with the partner of our choice, the right to maternity leave and job security for the rotte ore we righis ans - -o conoca COCTICER part of a labour movement response women already organised in labour movement and in campaigns and groups of the woulen s tove elphy, sees housework as a mode of production separate to pitalism, with housewives conituting a distinct, oppressed sexass. All other women, even if orking, are defined by the susewife role, and are clawed into is distinct class who are oppressed id exploited by men.

Women's first struggle, then, ust be to throw off the chains of x-class slavery, to revolt against en. Only then will the struggle gainst capitalism be of any elevance to them.

health and we stamo (WOME THe HOWCHECHE H-04 wiarity. We will encowage and aid S8-00 1-AO O COF aw-beats-e and demands of the women's moveind for positive assis -A-H w.-04 H+-WH changes in arrecen What did Engels mean by women being the first oppressed class?

Primitive societies generally had a division of labour between women and men. But women's work was valued no lower than men's - indeed, it generally was more central to primitive economies, being a more reliable staple.

But when these economies moved from mere subsistence to producing a surplus, women were pushed into a subordinate position. The exact details of this are impossible to -H bIe Women in the unions.

We ligin against the labour movement's ro oppressive ideas about ability to fight back, and dangerously divide the movement. We ally with all TO BEHOCC and accountability. labour and the trade unions, who are lighting for these aims. reat a- 5. We are for dw ostem thal exthat this was because it was in "men's work' thạt the growth took place.

The oppression of women was a result of developments in the sphere of production, and arose out of the same dynamics which led to the formation of classes, and ultimately the state. That it was women who lost out was because of their place in production, because of the intermeshing of the beginnings of a surplus with the pre-existing sex division of labour.

There is no evidence of a biological drive in men to put women down, and there is no evidence of sexist ideology until after this point. Women's oppression and class society arose together, thoroughly intertwined, one part of the other.

Women's oppression has existed for thousands of years. In that sense it is constant. Different social formations, different modes of production have come and gone. Yet women's oppression remains.

But the forms of women's subordination and its social role have changed dramatically over time. The position of women today is radically different from the position of women in ancient Greece, or in feudal Europe. The position of women, the form women's oppression took in each of these societies, was defined, though not completely determined, by the nature of production in those societies.

In feudal Britain, women over the demotion of legally chattels. Rape was an offence not against the woman but against her father or husband - it was his property which had been violated.

But there was no rigid division between home and work. Production took place on land around the home. Women did not suffer the sense of isolation and lack of worth which is characteristic of women's experience of their oppression under capitalism.

The development of capitalism and the industrial revolution again radically altered the structures of women's oppression. Tens of thousands of families left the countryside for the towns, and work in factories. In the 1840s Marx and Engels said the family in the working class was being destroyed. Men, women and children were being drawn into capitalist production.

By the latter half of the 19th century this had changed. The family was reconstructed in the working class, on the model of the bourgeois family, but with a different function.

The bourgeois nuclear family, with its emphasis on monogamy and female chastity, was a vehicle, for the transmission of property.

The working class family looked the same. It was the same in that it was a refuge for men, a place of relative comfort, and a prison for But the working class family has particular characteristics. After a

----- pull-quotes -----

discover, but most evidence shows part belt Lee E er thal

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 382

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →