Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialism is still alive

Socialist Organiser no. 382, 15 December 1988 · scan pp. 6–7 · Eric Heffer · about 1,817 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Today there are voices - Mrs Thatcher's, but also many others - which say that Socialism is dead. It is a thing of the past, and we who continue to support it are dinosaurs and on the point of extinction.

There are, unfortunately, some in the Labour Party who echo that view. There are voices within the labour movement who, to a large extent, accept the Tory argument and argue that those of us who continue to believe in class politics are throwbacks from a previous age, We are accused of being "workerist" , we are told that *Fordism" is our political base and that we do not live in the real world.

It is they who do not live in the real world. Capitalism may have marginally changed, but not fundamentally, and it can only get worse.

Those who argue that we are old-fashioned most strongly are around the journal Marxism Today and the official Communist Party. They, however, are not alone. They have allies and friends in the Labour Party. In fact, some in the Labour Party, including some in the leadership, look to them for political guidance. Their political gurus are Eric Hobsbawm and Martin Jacques.

I do not know why this should be so, because over the years they have not won anything at all, and in Italy, where the theories they hold tend to be accepted by the Communist Party, they have lost support in the urban working class areas. In the last election they lost tremendous support in those areas where in the past they had had rock-solid support. The industrial working class deserted them in droves.

The truth is that the class struggle continues and class politics are as relevant today as they ever were. No matter what the revisionists say, as long as class society exists, politics will be about the balance of forces between the classes.

This government carries out class politics. The whole of its legislative programme since 1979 has been in favour of the class it basically represents, ie. big business interests, and for some people in the labour movement to argue that the government has raised new issues of choice, only underlines their lack of basic understanding of the nature of capitalism and proves beyond doubt how much they delude themselves.

There has always been choice for the rich, for the propertied class. The only thing is that their choice is wider than that of work ing people.

Take the argument about Fordism. The argument seems to be that "Fordism" is equated with mass production and that this evolved a working class which was socialist in orientation.

Mass production, in varying ways, began before Ford. The production of the motor car developed it further. But Henry Ford fought against trade unions in his US and British factories. The Ford Company was eventually forced to accept and recognise trade unions in the USA, not without much violence against trade unionists on the picket lines, with factory spies being employed and attempts to assassinate trade union leaders such as the Reuther brothers.

"Fordism" still exists. Large manufacturers continue to resist trade union organisation, and this is being helped in Britain today by a government which has brought in vicious legislation against the trade unions on a scale worse than anywhere else in Europe. Where large scale industry has closed down, where alternative employment has been created, it is of the small sweatshop kind, similar to Hong Kong.

The problem is that because some like those in Marxism Today and the official Communist Party talk as if the class struggle were dead, they objectively help the employers and the Tory government. They weaken the struggle and assist in undermining workers confidence in themselves. This helps to lead to the concept of "New Realism" in the unions, ie. class collaboration, and equally in Bryan Gould praises the Communist Party and decries the fact that the Labour Party still, as he puts it, has its "class war warriors". Instead of rebuilding, developing and extending public ownership, we are offered shareholdings and that mythical thing called the "controlled market economy". It is all spelt out in "Aims and Values" and the Economic Policy document carried at the Labour Party conference It would seem to me that some in the movement do not live in the same world as I do, and clearly have not experienced the same conditions of life and employment and unemployment as I have as my constituents do today.

The recent Labour Party conference was an important one. It continued, in many respects, the slide away from basic socialist concepts which we have been experiencing for some time. It was the last but one step to changing the Party into an SDP Mark II.

That process was slightly halted, and there is still time to stop it altogether.

Next year's conference will cor sider the final policy documents.

No doubt some in leading posi-tions will continue their support for the ideas outlined in the new Communist Party draft "The British Road to Socialism" and Labour could end up with a document of a similar tepid revisionist character.

It is therefore important that socialists in the Labour Party and in the movement as a whole seriously consider the way forward. I have called this lecture The Socialists' Next Step". In doing so, I'had in mind the pamphlet issued by the Reform Committee of the South Wales Miners, called "The Miners' Next Step", published in 1912 and reputedly written by Noah Ablett. That pamphlet had quite an effect on the movement in those days. The ideas in it were never really carried out or accepted by the movement, but were an important contribu-l tion.

Since 1979 we have had a Tory government which has tilted the balance of power firmly in favour of the capitalist class - the employers, the bankers, the owners of the means of production, distribution and exchange. The capitalist system is put forward as the best possible econor system. We are told that profit making is natural and must dominate, and that any form of public ownership is wrong.

This government is out to eliminate what it calls "creeping socialism". It has not yet finalised. its programme. Everything is not yet privatised. It still has the coal mines, electricity, water, the NHS, the railways and municipal services to deal with, but it's well on its way. The future under this government is bleak indeed for working people. That is why it is essential to mobilise the people to defeat them.

To carry through its programme, the government has undermined, weakened and, in some cases destroyed, our democratic rights which have been fought for and gained over generations. The full power of the state, through the police and class legislation, has been used against the workers. At the same time, press and trade union freedom has been undermined.

It is no accident that the journal Index on Censorship, which usually concentrates on the Soviet Union, Eastern Europe and dictatorships like Pinochet's Chile, recently had an issue on what was happening to our freedom in this country. It was a very revealing issue, but unfortunately it had one defect. It failed to have any articles in depth on what has happened to the trade unions.

Yet, as in Nazi Germany, Mussolini's Italy and Pinochet's Chile, the unions are among the first to be curbed, destroyed or controlled because, despite any faults they may have, they were the instruments of working peopl for the protection of their conditions of employment, their hours of work and their safety and health at work.

Because everyone in the movement rightly wants to see this government out at the next general election, there is a feeling that no-one must criticise the leadership of the Party or challenge what is happening to the Party's basic principles and policies. Instead of attacks being fully turned on our political enemies, they are too often directed against critics within the Party.

What should be our attitude to leaders? Should we keep our mouth shut, should we accept policy changes and constitutional changes even if we passiontely believe they are wrong, and that the policies being followed can hinder our fight to defeat the Tories? I think it was Hugh Dalton who said, after the debacl of 1931 when Ramsay McDonald betrayed our movement, that we should have been more concerned with keeping to principles than giving loyalty to leaders.

Political leaders can be good orators, even silver-tongued, they can have a charisma, but they can also be disastrously wrong, sometimes from the best of motives.

In the pamphlet "The Miners' Next Step" the issue is raised, *Are leaders good and necessary?" The pamphlet says: "A leader implies at the outset some men who are being led; and the term is used to describe a mar who, in a representative capacity, has acquired combined adpeople scavenge on a rubbish tip ministrative and legislative power.

As such he sees no need for any high level of intelligence in the rank and file, except to applaud his actions.

"Indeed such intelligence from his point of view, by breeding criticism and opposition, is an obstacle and causes confusion. His motto is 'Men be loyal to your leaders'. His logical basis: plenary powers. His social and economic prestige is dependent upon his being respected by the public and the employers." What was written then about leaders is as applicable today as it was then.

It is important that socialists proceed from the bottom upward and not from the top downward.

If we place all our faith in those at the top, and vote for and support them uncritically and without challenging them seriously on vital issues, then the path ahead can lead to a precipice of disaster, not necessarily to the promised land of milk and honey. It is not that our principles and policies like public ownership are wrong, it is not socialist concepts of class struggle that have to be abandoned and capitalist mores of individualism and greed that must be accepted. We need to learn from the past and look for the ele ment that has too often been miss. ing in our socialist concepts, ie. the role and place of the working people at the point of production and in the workplace.

Public ownership by the State, whether in the Soviet Union or in Britain has, in effect, been a form of State Capitalism. The missing ingredient has been the role of the workers in the industries, and services which have been publicly owned!

Public ownership is essential to create a classless society, to end class rule, but future public ownership, whatever form it whether state ownership, municipal ownership or cooperative ownership, must genuine democratic workers" management.

Scan page 7

: 'Patriarchy' discussed; struggle; campaigning WF 'Dick of the Year" nurses' against award 10 pence the poll tax; film

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 382

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →