Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A defeat for Kinnock

Socialist Organiser no. 382, 15 December 1988 · scan p. 5 · about 835 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

The Govan by-election was a crushing personal defeat for Neil Kinnock and an overwhelming rejection by Scottish voters of Labour's 'new realism' There ETTERS learned here. With 50 MPs in Scotland, and control of virtually all councils, Labour has singularly failed to protect the Scottish working class from the evils of Toryism. It is precisely because Labour offers no resistance to Tory attacks that the Scottish working class are turning in despair and frustration to the blind alley of the SNP.

It is the duty of the Labour Party and trade unions jointly to defend the working class from the attacks of the Tory government, but they have failed to protect working people from any of these attacks, be it Tory plans to destroy the NHS, cheating the nurses, robbing the pensioners, privatisation, forcing council rents through the roof, smashing the welfare state, creating mass homelessness and mass unemployment, attacking civil liberties, forced youth labour schemes, education cuts, destroying local democracy, smashing the trade unions or digging up from the 14th century the evil poll tax. • Instead of mild acceptance, Labour should organise every coun cil in Scotland to unite and as one refuse to implement the poll tax, backing this up by firstly involving all council employees in a campaign of non implementation; secondly, involving tenants associations and linking it to a campaign against rent rises; thirdly, involving the whole trade union movement so that Tory reprisals against Labour councils are met by an immediate response of industrial action, especially targetting steel works.

And not just in Scotland.

Nurses are fighting courageously for a better deal while union leaders dither and Tory minister Kenneth Clarke tries to split the RCN from the other health unions and use them as a battering ram to smash NUPE and COHSE. After he's done that he can deal with the RCN at his leisure, treating them as badly as the rest.

Kenneth Baker's education plans hang like the sword of Damocles over teachers and threaten every child's right to a decent education, but what have either the teaching unions or the Labour Party done?.

While the Tories destroy council housing and local democracy, Labour councils, far from fighting back, implement Tory rent rises and cuts with a savagery to make Thatcher proud.

We need an all-out campaign by Labour, uniting and involving all health workers (and patients) to ensure nurses get the full 17% Thatcher is trying to cheat them out of, and a fair deal for the appallingly low paid ancillary workers and porters, with nurses' and health workers' picket lines outside factories, steel plants and mines everywhere, and linked to the battle against both hospital closures and privatisation - with a similar mass campaign against Baker and linking the two together.

Simultaneously if Labour councils throughout Britain refused to implement the Tory poll tax, rent rises and cuts, involving trade unions and council tenants, and backed it up with industrial action, linking it to the NHS and education campaigns, Thatcher would be reeling.i The key is involving the maximum number of people, both as tenants, patients, parents or consumers, and of trade unions.

Such a campaign would not only weaken the Tories, but would substantially strengthen Labour and give it that dynamism necessary to take power.

Pete Gilman London N1 b) One of your supporters argues that the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan is called for out of the interests of the Afghan masses, with the concomitant that 'defencists' must support the presence of the troops. I would argue the exact opposite: even though the continued presence of the Soviet troops may be in the interests of the Afghan masses (the alternative appears to be Khomeinite reaction), it is certainly not in the interests of the world working It was decisive in the ending of the *Vietnam syndrome' and the rightward shift in US politics. Defencists do not call for the military victory of the USSR on all occasions: the Fourth International correctly called for the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Eastern Europe after the war.

Your articles are characterised by a formalism and a 'normative" viewpoint ("if it isn't perfect it's not a workers' state") "a bureaucracy which suppresses independent workers' action inust be an alien class" — like the trade union leaderships??

This will not stand you in good stead when it comes to analysing the dynamics of these societies. (Why does Gorbachev oppose allowing workers to form their own trade unions and political parties" Why is he not introducing the market wholesale), and will be even worse in analysing world politics: no victorious revolutions since 1917? What has happened to the world balance of class forces since then?

It is interesting to note that those forces which have adopted variants of the state capitalist/bureaucratic collectivist theory have remained nationally isolated, and have made no impact in the "Third World". You are heading down a dead end.

Send letters Philip Ward

----- pull-quotes -----

Socialist Ory PO Box 823 SE15 4NA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 382

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →