Policy Review tries to junk Green policies LES ALABN-S
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
SCIENCE COLUMN are in Phase 2 of Labour's Policy Review where ordinary Labour Party members, branches and CLPs have a chance to look at the results of Phase 1 and put in our two penn'orth.
To help us, there is a booklet, Social Justice. and Economic Ejjiciency, with the reports of the seven Policy Review Groups, as well as seven Discussion Papers and Response Sheets.
I'm going to look at the report of the Physical and Social Environment (PSE) review group as SO's pamphlet on the policy review, Socialism for the 1990s, failed to consider this at all.
The PSE report is a perculiar thing. Claiming to support Labour's 1986 Environment Statement, it talks about the need to develop it and then almost totally ignores it.
This lip service is reminiscent of environmental "campaigning' in the last election. Having set aside an "Environment Day" , this was then submerged in an irrelevant kerfutile over whether Tebbit had said "No-one with a conscience votes Tory". (He didn't but it's true).
The report gives a sketchy account of the environmental problems facing working people in Britain and the world. The energy industry, a major source of pollution, is not mentioned, still less Labour's policy of phasing out nuclear power, passed by two conferences.
To get these problems put right, the answer is said to be a new planning system, since "market forces alone" (ie capitalism) "cannot ensure a decent environment"! You would scarcely guess from this that the profit system is one of the major causes of damage to the environment.
Polluters will be relieved to hear that "we do not propose to unnecessarily interfere with the management of private enterprises". Conference policy of setting up a Ministry of Environmental Protection is not mentioned.
Throughout the report runs a curious insistence that, for most people, noise from neighbours or dirty streets are as, if not more, important than sea pollution, acid rain, the spread of deserts, of the ozone layer etc.
On dirty streets, the report says local authorities shouldn't be blamed for not cleaning them. "Individuals must also take responsibility for the mess they help create - ana for helping to clean it up"
I find this incredible. Councils have cut back on street cleansing because of government cuts in funding. At the same time, elaborate over-packaging of goods has come in in a big way with the growth of super- and hypermarkets, where even fresh fruit and veg comes in a non-biodegradable plastic film or box or plastic foam dish made with ozone-destroying CFC gases.
There are no suggestions for how to bring environmental considerations into economic policy here or elsewhere. Neither is there any discussion of the job-creating potential of investment in environmental protection.
The "reviewers" end with a list of issues they will consider in Phase 2, all of which (air pollution, waste disposal, health and safety etc.) are quite adequately dealt with in current party policy.
The Discussion Paper asks such challenging questions as "What should we do about the problem of nuclear waste?" I don't know what sort of answers they are expecting to this. There is plenty of disagreement among experts over the alternatives which include:
* forming it into blocks of glass and burying it in stable layers of rock;
* putting it into drums in shafts dug into the sea bed;
leaving it where it is under guard until something foolproof can be thought of;
* or (my favourite) putting it into rockets and firing it into the sun.
I cannot see that ordinary Labour Party members without specialist knowledge or access to technical arguments are going to come up with anything better.
My impression of the PSE policy review group is of an elephant straining and bringing forth a gnat!
New Ground: The current issue contains a more detailed look at Labour's policy reviews as well as articles about the inner city environment. Send tl to 26 Underwood St, London N7 ITJ.