[other tendencies with the same formulas of post-1951…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
other tendencies with the same formulas of post-1951 Trotskyism is stark. The Pablo-Mandel tendency did not come out for a workers' revolution against Mao's bureaucracy until 18 years after it conquered mainland China! The USFI could not bring itself to a wholehearted support of the call by the outlawed Solidarnosc in 1981 for workers in Western Europe to boycott Polish goods, and strands in the USFI opposed the boycott.
All the orthodox Trotskyists', with the exception of a sizeable minority in the West European Mandelite groups, either welcomed the Russian invasion of Afghanistan or refused to call on the Russians to leave.
To this day sections of the 'orthodox Trotskyist' movement do not believe a workers' revolution to be necessary in Cuba or Vietnam. That is, they see the bureaucratic state-monopoly system as historically progressive, or even a working-class answer, for certain parts of the world today - just as they long saw it as such for China.
On these and other questions we have been at odds with the 'officia!' Trotskyist movement and its various splinters.
Our interpretation of the *degenerated and deformed workers' state' framework has, we believe, been strictly in line with Trotsky's interpretation of the meaning of his •degenerated workers' state' analysis of the USSR. Most of the other Trotskyists have in fact — at various times and for different countries — been in the tradition not of Trotsky but of the Right Opposition of the '30s (Brandler/Lovestone). While criticising the policies of the ruling Saturday 19 November 'Time To Go' conference on Ireland. Camden Centre, Bidborough St, London WC1. E5 to Clare Short MP (TTG), House of Commons, London SW1.
Saturday 19 November Nottingham SO weekend in the country, Hollinsclough, White Peak District. Discussions, walks, good food. £12 waged, £6 unwaged: contact Ivan or Rosey 0602 624827, Sunday 20 November North East London SO meeting, Fighting Imperialism: Under Whi Flag?', Speaker: Clive Bradley. 7 been something we took for granted and within which we hammered out our positions on current events — from our attitude to 'right-wing' dissidents in the USSR to the invasion of Afghanistan and Solidarnosc. We have more and more relegated the formal framework to the outer perimeter of our concerns.
Where we have used its descriptive terms - "bureaucracy, for example, for the ruling group - we have given them our own meanings, effectively describing those bureaycracies as fully-fledged class enemies of the working class.
Many years ago we formally declared 'defence of the Soviet Union' — in a world dominated by the two nuclear superpowers - as a matter of "tenth-rate importance'. Since 1980 we have insisted that, "workers' state' or no 'workers' state', it is an abuse of language to deny that the USSR is an imperialist We have diverged from the orthodox Trotskyist' current, too. For it is characteristic of all the adherents of the 'degenerated and deformed workers' states' theory that that theory is a more or less translucent sheath within which exists a radically different theory.
For us, terms like 'bureaucracy' were in fact used to describe classes hostile to the workers: and all the ' degenerated and deformed workers' state theorists in fact describe the societies they tag with Trotsky's label as a new form of society.
For Trotsky the USSR's bureaucracy was in agonising contradiction with the nationalised means of production because it was in agonising contradiction with the working class; all the post-1951 pm, Lucas Arms, Grays Inn Road. Monday 21 November Oxford SO meeting, 'The Politics of Marxism Today'. 8.00 pm, Wadham College, Lecture Room.
Tuesday 22 November Northampton SO meeting, "The Left Today' '. Speaker: Jim Denham. 7.15 pm, 25 Queens Road.
Thursday 24 November Stoke SO meeting, 'Arabs, Jews and Socialism'. • Speaker: Clive Bradley.
Saturday 26 November London Socialist Conference dayschool on Imperialism. Sir Collins School, London NW1 Saturdy 26 November Anti-Apartheid Movement Annual Conference. Sheffield.
Saturday 26 November Socialist Conference dayschool oi 'Socialism and Democracy'. • Civic Centre, Newcastle. Contact Tessi been one of conflict and tension between the implication we inherited from 'orthodox Trotskyism', that these state-monopoly systems, as 'workers' states' , were historically progressive and halfway between capitalism and socialism — and our response to all the living issues throughout the history of the tendency, from the invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968 onwards.
There does not now exist any coherent 'degenerated and deformed workers' state' theory - that is. any "degenerated and deformed workers' state' theory which does not in fact amount to a radically different theory, a theory (in one form or another) of 'progressive bureaucratic collectivism'.
That is the source of the decades of illusions and disillusion of various groups of orthodox Trotskyists' with a series of Stalinist formations. It is the source of the prolonged ideological crisis of the Trotskyist movement. The movement's formula on this question - the formula used for the USSR by Trotsky before 1940 — has simply worn We must conclude:
A. The ruling state-monopoly bureaucracies are distinct ruling classes. They have many peculiarities and differences from other ruling classes, but nevertheless they are self-reproducing ruling classes with a distinct relation to the means of production and to the working class.
B. Nationalised property alone cannot define a social formation as a workers' state. The vast experience of different sorts of bourgeois states since Trotsky's time makes this clear, even if the use of nationalised property against Gray, 4 Normanton Terrace, Elswick, Newcastle-upon-Tyne. Monday 28 November London Socialist Forum meeting, "Labour and the Bomb'. Speakers clude Pat Arrowsmith. 7.30 pm, Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, WC1.
Saturdy 10 December Socialist Conference 'Conference Against the Poll Tax'. Newcastle Medical School. £10 (delegate)/E5/E3 to Terry Conway, 10b Windsor Road, London N7 Sunday 11 December North East London SO Social. 7.30 pm. Contact Belinda, 354 3854 Saturday 25 February Women for Socialism two-day conference.
Saturdy 1 April Campaign for Non-Alignment two-day conference, 'Out of NATO, inte the World'
1A1%
the working class in the Stalinist state-monopoly societies had not already done so.
Nationalisation is a means to an end - working class liberation. It cannot bring progress towards that end under the rule of bureaucratic state-monopoly class system.
C. The working class and its allies in the bureaucratic state-monopoly societies must make a new revolution which will, in fact, be as thorough-going as the revolution that the workers in a country like Britain will have to make.
D. The bureaucratic statemonopoly systems cannot be considered in any sense transitional from capitalism to socialism. In many fundamental respects they are further from socialism than advanced capitalist countries are - most importantly, in their uniform and systematic suppression of the working class, without those activity socialism is impossible and will never be achieved anywhere.
The state-monopoly societies emerge in various ways as parallels to capitalism, not as its successor. They have many of the unmistakeable features of historical blind alleys.
E. Socialists in the West must support the working class in the state-monopoly systems in its attempts to organise a free labour movement — support it irrespective of the ideas of such a movement which may, as Solidarnose shows, develop pro-market-capitalist views in response to the horrors of the state-monopoly system.
F. Socialists in the West must support the right to national self-determination in the statemonopoly systems.
G. We are opening a discussion. Many questions about the nature of the Eastern Bloc remain unanswered. We will continue the discussion in an open and undogmatic way.
These conclusions in no way demand a change in our attitudes to the living political questions. Sloughing off the worn-out 'degenerated and deformed workers' state' formula merely gets rid of an empty form of words in contradiction with the militant anti-bureaucratic and pro-working class
Scan page 9
allons
----- pull-quotes -----
ACTIVISTS" DIARY