Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why most American didn't bother to vote

Socialist Organiser no. 380, 17 November 1988 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,425 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

democracy much fuller than states against their own antithe present Westminster socialist bureaucracies. system a workers' We stand: democracy, with elected For full equality for women, bureaucrats and manager mass privileges. F women's in one country alane rregaine reismi and against workers in'avery country bale' deportations and all immigrain other countries the with D For equality fer lesbians and wide, including the struggle testant minorityworkers and oppressed na- For left unity in action; claritionalities in the 'Stalinist ty in debate and discussion.

the Palestinian national vement will be decisive over the ger term. The Palestinians need eli allies, and the closer the ince the better. A series of trials srael now are an attempt to nip such alliance in the bud. re there any openings ialist movement in these elopments? At present, very lost of the self-styled socialists the Palestinian side are those ups most hostile to the two es policy, and almost all of them very Stalinist. The Sons of the age movement within pre-'67 el is more critical of the USSR, rejects the idea that the Israeli s are a nation. in the Israeli side, 'socialism' is to be identified as oldlioned "pioneer or kibbutz Zionism.

And on neither side has the working class emerged as an independent factor. Workers' unity looks a long way off.

But undoubtedly the situation is charged in a way it never has been before. The PLO has declared a government in exile while Israel has the most right-wing government in its history. This must be an immensely unstable situation.

And the superpowers' inevitable piecemeal interventions will serve to make it more unstable (the USSR played a prominant rule in pushing the PLO to its new stand).

So if the immediate prospects look grim, the medium-term prospects are less so. The Palestinians are nearer the winning of a state of their own than they have ever been before. 3y Clive Bradley N opinion that the trouble eil Kinnock is of the with Michael Dukakis' campaign was that it did not have a wide enough appeal — it id not reach out to the 'haves' as well as the 'have-nots' In fact the opposite is the case: Dukakis did best towards the end of his campaign when he most explicit ly appealed to working class voters.

Who voted for Dukakis? 86% of blacks who voted, and 69% of Hispanics voted for Dukakis. On the whole, women voted for Dukakis (according to a CBS/NY Times poll, women's votes were about evenly divided; according to others, Dukakis had a majority among women). Dukakis got the inner city and working class vote, Bush got the suburbs and rural areas.

Bush had a majority among Prosions and among the non-religious.

As The Economist put it: "The enthusiastic Bush voter was white, male, Protestant, rich, educated, small-town, salaried or self-employed." The Democrat voters are 'ethnic' groups, women and poor people.

In fact, Dukakis did not do as badly as the head-count of states would suggest, and made serious inroads into Reagan's constituency.

The majority of Americans do not belong to Bush's constituency as The Economist describes it; but about half of those eligible to vote don't bother.

Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working-class socialism.

We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' I control. We want SUBSCRIBE Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by po Rates(UK) E8.50 for six months, E16 for a year.

Name Address Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E Te Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA The American political system is characterised by a huge amount of popular apathy. Very large numbers, especially of poor Americans, see no point in voting for one or other candidate. Although the Democrats get working class votes, they are in no sense at all a workers' party.

Both parties fundamentally represent the interests of the American ruling class: indeed, the Democrats were the traditional party of the racist establishment in the South. Dukakis' running mate, Lloyd Bentsen, is known as the foremost spokesperson in Congress on big-business interests.

Nowadays, the Democrats are seen to be more "liberal' (increasingly a swear word in the US) than the Republicans. But in real terms the differences are not great.

Socialism can never be bui more in common with Duomers tion their own capitalist orptalin.s! rulers. We support. liberation struggles workers' struggles SOCIALIST ORGANISIS Ulster cops did shuot 10. kill new homeless The Tones Jesse Jackson, of course, represents a far more radical current within the Democratic Party, but to a large extent the actual role that he plays is to secure support for the mainstream Democrats among black voters. A small 'Jacksonite" splinter attracted little support.

The apolitical razzamatazz of American elections should also be a warning for those in the British labour movement who want to see a more American-style system here.

Undoubtedly, what is needed is a radical break with the two-party system - an independent Labour party that challenges both the Democrats and the Republicans, How such a party could be built out of the mass of non-voters and Democrat supporters is obviously a large and difficult issue. But it is definitely necessary.

Pd and free Ireland, federal system to protect the rights of the ProFor a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.

We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.

Scan page 8

eastern Bloc and Trotskyism Our tendency is part of the *orthodox Trotskyist' current whose ideas were elaborated between 1948 and 1950 and codified at the Third World Congress of the Fourth International in 1951 - which we have in the past identified as the re-founding' congress.

We have never ceased formally to subscribe to the ideas about the bureaucratic state-monopoly societies codified at that Congress, considering them degenerated and deformed workers' states. Like every other Trotskyist tendency operating with the Third World Congress codifications, we have over the years established a distinctive record on the state-monopoly systems by way of our responses to We have been characterised from the very beginning of the tendency by our fierce hostility to the statemonopoly systems, and by outspoken commitment to the working class and to the need for a new workers' revolution.

The contrast with some of the This resolution, with preamble commentary, was discussed at Socialist Organiser supporters' 12-13 November bureaucracies, they have believed them to be historically progressive, and identified their interests with those of the working class.

The result has been a brokenbacked, oscillating and unstable "Trotskyism' , combining working-class hostility to the bureaucracy (usually) for the USSR with crass illusions in one or other of the nonUSSR Stalinist formations, from Tito to Mao to Castro to Ortega.

That is not our tradition, nor our history, but it is the tradition and the history of most of our political family.

That is what most orthodox Trotskyists' have made over 40 years of the ideas of post-Trotsky Trotskyism. We have swum against the stream within our own historic current.

For many years we have not really made propaganda for the workers' states position. It has *degenerated and deformed Trotskyists, in fact, i describe societies where the bureaucracy creates the nationalised property, Is not in agonising contradiction with it, and is not a usurper. This is clear in all the theories, but perhaps most so in the Militant tendency.

For the 'orthodox Trotskyists' the "degenerated and deformed workers' states' name-tag functions only to impart the idea that these societies are historically progressive. Where Trotsky's opponents in 1939-40, and later Max Shachtman, said that the bureaucratic state-monopoly systems were new exploiting societies and "barbaric', the 'orthodox Trotskyists' use the 'workers' state' name-tag to paint essentially the same picture but say that the new societies are progressive and transitional to socialism.

For ourselves, our history has HEMILITANT

----- pull-quotes -----

representatives recallable Lati Fland social provision to free any time, and an id. her women tam the burden of

testants, Dukakis had a majority among all other religious persua-

WHERE WE STAND

Britain's death squad 2 exposed

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 380

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →