Outdoing the right wing
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
The right-wing would have been proud of them. After only three days, Militant supporters in the Civil and Public Servants Association (CPSA) have dropped democratically agreed Broad Left (BL) conference policy on GCHQ.
At CPSA Broad Left conference on 5-6 November, delegates passed a Socialist Caucus motion which urged BL supporters to put up branch motions calling on the National Executive Committee to call an offiçial all-out strike in defence of the sacked GCHQ trade unionists from 18 November.
If the NEC refused - as they have done - BL was mandated to argue for all-out unofficial action. The motion also condemned the BL for its failings over GCHQ.
At a London BL meeting only three days later, it became clear that both Militant and SWP BL supporters had no intention of acting on conference The Militant London BL chair refused to mail a leaflet which had nothing on it except the GCHQ motions passed at conference and a model motion to put at branches!
The chair then refused to go to the vote on whether to mail it out or not!
Militant supporters argued that a mailing was being done in Liverpool! But, surprise, surprise! — no such mailing has appeared.
They also argued that there hadn't been sufficient action on 7 November (GCHQ day) to justify mobilising around an all-out strike call from 18 November.
This is clearly ridiculous in view of the massive support on 7 November and misses the point. 18 November is the day the dismissal notices at GCHQ run out. if BL supporters had gone from BL conference and organised around BL conference policy, then we might have been able to force General Secretary John Ellis' hand and organise an all-out strike.
Various London branches had already committed themselves to strike action from the 18th and wanted to pull the BL behind an open coordinating meeting of all those branches prepared to take action.
As it is, the BL is left with doing nothing. At the London BL meeting, the SWP also argued for dropping conference policy. They arguld that BL H a year's sub to erewith cheque for a Socialist Organiser and Workers' Liberty. As I told you, when I discontinued subscribing in the Summer, I was stopping because considered that your periodic attacks on the *bureaucratic collectivist" analysis made nonsense of the rest of your arguments.
1 am indebted 1o Socialist Outlook for knowing that you are now re-opening the question, though not yet decided between the "state capitalist' and the *bureaucratic collectivist" theses. supporters should go to the planned demo at Cheltenham later this month and build an all-out strike from the mood created around that.
No-one took this seriously (prohably not even the SWP).
The unity of the BL broke down over GCHQ, it failed to act as a cohesive force inside the union. Surely the BL should be more than an electoral alliance inside the union.
The BL now needs to look for any openings it can find - and organise around them. The Militant BL leadership should be condemned for ditching BL conference policy and, in any case, they should stop behaving like the rightwing.
Trudy Saunders Bloc discussion In fact in Simone Weil's original statement of case, and in the versions associated with Rosmer, "bureaucratic collectivism' was seen as a pa ticular form of state capitalism. It was not until the later forms - Shachtman, Carter and others - that it was suggested that the extraction of surplus value was no longer a characteristic.
Laurens Utter Wellington Salop P.S. I hope, though, the tendency to reformism discernible in the Spring is ending. I have seen too many groups which, because they gave up an outmoded view of the Soviet Union, adopted an even more fallacious view of Western Democracy.
Scan page 5
NURSES 5