DAILY Say end
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Last week's public bust-up between Nigel Lawson and gentlemen of the press was as much about the so-called "lobby system" as it was about means-testing pensioners.
After all, everyone knows that this government wants to phase out universal benefits and step up means-testing (or "privating" as it is euphemistically known these days): the question is, did 10 senior political correspondents accurately report the words of the Chancellor, or did they all get it wrong?
On the face of it, this should be a fairly simple matter to sort out: all the journalists took verbatim notes and, there was that now famous tape recorder. Unfortunately, the tape recorder's pause button was left on... or the machine broke down... or the tape was lost... or something like that. Anyway, it turned out that no tape recording was available once Lawson started accusing the journalists of being, in effect, liars and they replied by saying much the same about him.
The shorthand notes were then dug out and published in the Daily Telegraph and the Independent. Suddenly Lawson's charge that the reports had seen "a farrago of invention' was dropped. The Treasury accepted that the notes were "broadly accurate". The argument now revolved around what inupon Mir Lawson's weasel words (PA tiny minority of pensioners having difficulty making ends meet...Evolution of the social security system...Better targetting...Non-pledged benefits", etc.)
It seems fairly obvious to me what Lawson was hinting at and the Sunday papers certainly had no doubts: "Means-test threat to pensioners" was the headline in the Sunday Telegraph and the Observer; "Pensioners face cuts in benefits" said the Sunday Times.
The difficulty in actually proving what the fat bounder really said lies in the lobby system itself: these are nonattributable meetings between groups of journalists and government representatives (usually the Prime Minister's Press Secretary, Bernard Ingham, but sometimes Mrs Thatcher or one of her ministers) in which kites can be flown and ground tested. But no names, no pack drill. It is a thoroughly corrupt system that, In effect, allows the ministers to use the press as a sounding. board for their ideas and opinions, without having to take any form of personal responsibility. Lawson's words this time were attributed to "a senior government source" in the first reports though the Observer gave a rather broad hint by printing a photo of Lawson alongside their story.
The lobby system has been extensively used by the present administration (to whose style of operating it is ideally suited) but is unpopular with honest journalists. The Independent and the most of the "quali»,,Participate and Guardian no longer creasingly impatient with it. That was, ironically, the main reason that Lawson chose the Sunday papers for his little kite flying exercise. The Sundays are now. understandably, outraged.
Hopefully the whole farcical episode will prove to be the final nail in the coffin of the lobby system. If it does, Nigel Lawson will have made a remarkable (if inadvertent) contribution to openness and honesty in both politics and journalism.
Scan page 4
ionalist agend Tenants from the Waterlow Estate, East London, protest at the selling-off of their estate. The Tories want to push through many more such sell-offs. Photo: Phil Maxwell 3y Dion D'Silva Black Sections have been seeking official recognition in the Labour Party for tive years. In response to the charge that they are over-concerned about constitutional arguments they have produced the pamphlet Black Agenda' to explain the policies of Black Sections on a wide range of Black people are systematically discriminated against in all walks of life, from education to housing, to employment and the provision of services. Blacks are only 5% of the national population, yet 23% of all prisoners are black. Immigration controls and policing see blacks as the problem rather than racism.
In Birmingham, a survey found that black students are four times more likely to be suspended than white students, and for fewer and less serious offences. Black Sections, however, correctly Tory, local councils?
Linda Bellos is a prominent Black Sections supporter. She was also leader of Lambeth Council as it pushed through a cuts package. She had the nerve to justify them on the grounds that this was Black politics - being honest with the black communityrather than white left politics!
Black Sections were paralysed. They did not organise a fightback - on the contrary.
They have no such inhibitions on international issues. They call for understanding of the Irish question, but offer no discussion of the divide between the two communities in Ireland. The issue is simply described as an anti-imperialist, anti-colonial struggle by a 'Third World' liberation movement.
Black Sections recognise that the PLO accepts a two-state solution in the responsibility for white racism.
This is pure and naked nationalism and has nothing to do with working class socialism. While Black Sections are right to point out the role of the Pan African Congress in the liberation struggle and the wav it is ignored by the Anti-Apartheid movement, their political identification with the PAC is another matter.
Black Sections praise the PAC on the grounds that its leadership is solely black. ANC and SWAPO are tainted because they field white speakers. The principal national task is said to be to regain Azania for its rightful indigenous owners — the African people. At the same time the whites are said to be an oppressing nation!
Totally ignored is the recent powerful growth of non-racial trade unions with militant socialist leaders such as Moses The Black Agenda claims that it aims to link the issue of race to class. Many people on the left welcomed Black Sections as a vehicle to organise black working class people and bring them into the Labour Party.
On cold assessment it has to be said that it has failed. The struggle of the
----- pull-quotes -----
to the lobby system
RACE AND CLASS