Ireland: out of the impasse
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
This weekend, on 19 November, a new attempt will be made to launch a movement in Britain to help end the war in Northern Ireland.
A conference entitled Time To Go' has been called by Clare Short MP and others. It promises a broader and more serious attempt to discuss the issues than previous such initiatives.
A new start is certainly necessary. The Anti-Internment League -launched after the introduction of internment jail without charge or trial) in August 1971 — did manage to stage some sizeable demonstrations in the early "70s, but since then the crimes and brutalities of British policy in Ireland have passed almost without reaction from the left.
Successive attempts to launch broad "Troops Out' movements have produced very limited results, despite all the polls showing a majority of public opinion in Britain for troops out. The Labour Committee on Ireland has made some progress in the Labour Party, but not much.
What's the problem? In our view the root problem is that 'troops out' is nowhere near being a sufficient policy for Ireland. On its own it has no clear progressive meaning at all.
Since 1972, despite many important twists and changes, the basic facts in Ireland have remained unchanged, in stalemate. The British Army cannot defeat the rebellious Catholics; the Catholics cannot defeat the combined forces of the British Army and the Protestants; the British Government is not sufficiently energetic, or sufficiently driven, to impose a fundamental rearrangement on the Protestants.
In the 26 Counties of southern Ireland there have been some impressive one-off waves of solidarity with the Northern Catholics - after Bloody Sunday in 1972, and during the hunger strikes in 1981. But the basic facts of the political set-up have not changed.
The two Green Tory parties, Fine Gael and Fianna Fail, remain dominant — as they were in the 1960s. The Irish Labour Party remains a tail of Fine Gael - as it was in the 1960s.
Thus the Irish national struggle remains essentially confined to 10 per cent of the Irish - the Northern Catholics. That does not detract from the justice of their fight. It does limit its prospects.
Any real solution must accommodate the justified democratic demands of both Catholics and Protestants.
The Catholics rebel against being a permanent subordinate minority in a state - Northern Ireland -they have no wish to be part of; and they have every right to do so. The Protestants rebel against the prospect of being a permanent subordinate minority in a Catholic-ruled The emancipation of the working class is also the sex or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965. date for reports: first Monday or by phone Monday evening. united Ireland; right to do so.
The Irish workers can be united only on a programme of consistent democracy - a federal united Ireland, allowing regional autonomy to the mainly-Protestant areas, and having voluntary confederal links with Britain.
As the bloody stalemate in the Northern Ireland drags on, year after year, the importance of this programme increases.
Militant has long refused to campaign in any way for British troops out of Ireland, instead using general propaganda about the need for socialism to evade the issue. That is contemptible.
But the attitude of those many on the Left who argue that troops out' and 'the defeat of British imperialism' are the crux of the Irish question, and all else is pettifogging and probably 'capitulation to imperialism', is no less empty phrasemongering.
In most national liberation struggles, we can say simply: the imperialist power should get out and hand over to the local nationalist movement. There is no all-Ireland nationalist movement. There is a nationalist movement of the Northern Catholics (10%), regarded with bitter hostility by the Northern Protestants (20%) and sporadic sympathy, but some alarm, by the Southern Catholics (70%).J If British troops quit Ireland tomorrow, there would be a sectarian civil war, leading to repartition.
Self-determination? Unify Ireland? The Provisionals are not strong enough for it. The Northern Protestants are actively hostile to it.
The Southern ruling class is certainly not ready to conquer the Protestants. violence of two working-class comThe scene would be set for the munities slaughtering each other. Protestants to re-establish their own Northern Ireland government - as should fail to support troops out. they had, under British supervision, British troops have no right to be in before March 1972. This would in- Ireland, and do no good there. That volve, at least, a big crackdown on the situation and the prospects now the Republicans, and, probably, are so bleak is in large part Britain's nass slaughter and driving-out of work. the Catholics.
The Northern Catholics would (rightly) resist violently. Dublin would give some assistance in the mainly-Catholic areas of the North.
There would be mass population movements, a repartition: Ireland phrasemongers. would be irrevocably and bitterly split into Orange and Green states.
There would be a bloodbath.
The conventional left answer to this, that "There's already a bloodbath", , is no answer. Simmering sections of the Irish people. war with hundreds of casualties is different from all-out war with thousands. Different not only in immediate human terms, but also in terms of the implications for the the Protestants. future possibilities of socialism -i.e. of uniting the Catholic and Protestant workers.
The other answer, *Revolutions always involve bloodshed" , is no better. There is no comparison between the revolutionary violence of the working class against its exploiters, or of a subject nation against a conquering army, and the Editor: John O'Mahony Republicanism. Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU), 01-358 1344.
Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link is a secondary issue.
International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. was pulled out.
LONG KESH POLITICAL PRISONER But that is not Marxism. It is not honest politics. We will not even be All this does not mean that we very reliable anti-imperialists if our 'anti-imperialism' is only as strong as our ability to use consoling myths to shield our eyes from uncomfortable facts.
Events since the Anglo-Irish Agreement of November 1985 have But it does mean that we should had some visible, if unacknowledgcouple the call for troops out with a ed, influence on the British Left. democratic proposal for a solution No group now, other than the weird within Ireland - and condemn *Revolutionary Communist Party' those who call for troops out makes "Troops Out Now' its central without such a proposal as mindless message on Ireland.
Socialist Worker has occasional The only conceivable solution bouts of "Troops Out' sloganising, given the present facts of the situa- but its main message now is similar tion or anything resembling them is to Militant's: socialism is the a federal united Ireland - i.e. an answer, and socialism means attempt to negotiate between the uniting Irish workers around breadand-butter economic issues.
Conciliation, realistically, would This approach is extremely secinvolve some repression against die- tarian towards the national and hard Protestant groups. But that is democratic concerns of the Irish different from straight conquest of people — and extremely stupid, too. Being sectarian towards issues Logically, conquest is the only will not make them go away. alternative, given the Protestants' Catholic and Protestant workers deep-rooted attitudes. But it is not in Northern Ireland unite on possible - who would conquer economic issues regularly and them? - and not desirable anyway, routinely, without that unity in the from a working-class point of view. least diminishing their ditterences It is possible to evade these issues of national allegiance and identity. by wishful thinking. It is possible to Striking will not convert Irish Proassume that at the crucial point the testant workers who consider national struggle would magically themselves British into green-Irish 'grow over' into socialism, or in any more than it can convert French some 'dialectical' leap the Pro- workers into Germans. testants would be converted to Irish Publications like Socialist Action and Socialist Outlook dilute their It is possible to remain blinkered adherence to "Troops Out' in a difin a sort of upside-down British na- ferent way, by talking about tionalism, saying that "the defeat *British withdrawal within the of British imperialism" and its ef- lifetime of a Parliament' rather fect on the "balance of world than 'Troops Out Now' forces" are the things that really The element of delay shelters the matter, and that the fate of Ireland mind from thought about the danger of sectarian civil war. But It is possible to resort to a crude what is the delay for? Five years? theory of the Protestants as pure delay is more likely to make things ›awns of Britain. that their worse than better.
ostility to Catholic Ireland woulc We need to start discussing drain away like water out of a bath seriously. The conference on 19 once the plug' of British troops November should be an opportunity.
GIAN G Daily Express THE INDEPENDEN An
----- pull-quotes -----
emancipation of all human beings without distinction of