Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Labol lost Govan

Socialist Organiser no. 380, 17 November 1988 · scan p. 2 · about 1,343 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Stan Crooke analyses Labour to Scottish nationalism would be a wrong response to the defeat the Govan by-election last Thursday, 10 November Labour paid the price for the party leaders' policies of New Realism:

In a 33% swing to the Scottish National Party (SNP), Labour's vote of 24,071 in last year's General Election collapsed to 11,123. The SNP vote jumped from 3,851 to 14,677. A Labour majority of 19,509 was transformed into a SNP majority of 3,554.

The Labour leaders cannot blame anyone except themselves for this defeat.

The Labour Party Scottish Organiser who was the election agent; Kinnock-loyalist MPs who acted as 'minders' for the Labour candidate; Kinnock and Hattersley who came up to Govan to 'help' Labour win; and Walworth Road full-timers who were drafted in to "help' run the campaign.

The Labour leadership has promised a full enquiry. A measure of how searching the post mortem will be can be gained from the comment of Brian Wilson, the Scottish Labour MP whose attacks on anti-poll tax campaigning did so much to help the SNP to victory: People in Govan are deeply hostile to everything Mrs Thatcher stands Jor, and they were offered two ways of turning that into a political statement...By-elections offer that sort of opportunity and we have no grounds for complaint about the On Tuesday 25 October, a meeting was held on the South side of Glasgow, convened at the request of Sinn Fein and attended by prominent Sinn Fein activist Joe Austin, to discuss whether or not Sinn Fein should stand a candidate in the Govan by-election.

The meeting agreed that a Sinn Fein intervention into the by-election would be counter-productive and would inflame sectarian tensions. The Catholic/Protestant confilct which dogs Northern Ireland exists also in the Glasgow working class, and without any element of justified nationalist rebellion such as there is: in Ireland.

Members of the outcome."

None of the excuses which the Kinnockites will have on offer in an attempt to explain away this crushing defeat merit serious consideration. First and foremost they will attribute the humiliation for Govan to the miserable performance of the Labour candidate, Bob Gillespie.

Miserable it indeed was, but that hardly explains the debacle. Gillespie is not more ignorant of politics than many other Clydeside Labour candidates who were elected in 1987. In any case Gillespie was so closely 'minded' by the likes of Brian Wilson and Donald Dewar that he was scarcely ever exposed to the electorate.

The right wing will also claim that Gillespie's personal pledge not to pay the poll tax (whilst supporting official policy of opposing non-payment campaigning) cost Labour votes. What this leaves unexplained, however is why the votes deserted Labour for - a party which supports non-payment!

The by-election was part of a pattern of growing disenchantment with Labour in Scotland.

In the 1988 Scottish District Council elections the SNP improved significantly their General Election performance. In Govan itself the SNP vote doubled from 10% to 20%. In local council by-elections the SNP has also notched up a series of successes at Labour's expense. The night of the Govan disaster itself, for example, the SNP won a 'safe' Labour seat in a council by-election in West Lothian.

Aided by confused left-wingers (such as "Scottish Labour Action') sections of the right wing will attribute Labour's defeat to the failure of the party to pursue "the Scottish question" energetically enough.

And the so-called "Scottish Bands Alliance present at the meeting were especially wary of deepening divisions.

Most of the far left present at the meeting, however, were rather more nonchalant about heightened sectarian tensions. In particular the position advanced by the Socialist Workers Party representatives at the meeting is well worth remembering: the SWP urged Sinn Fein to stand and stressed that, if Sinn Fein were to stand, then SWP members would be only too keen to go out canvass. ing for it!

Maybe when Labour's position on abortion gets to be as bad as Sinn Fein's then the SWP will go out canvassing for Labour as well. SNP candidate, Jim Sillars tion" was not initially a major issue in the by-election. A poll conducted for the "Scotland on Sunday" paper found the most important issues to be: jobs (42% of those asked), poll tax (41%), welfare benefits (27%), NHS (24%), housing (19%) and Child Benefit (12%).

other topics mentioned rated less than 10%.

oc angage n to no anili *Fot the campaign — to no avail. Govan, for Scotland" proclaimed the headline of one of its leaflets. Having cut its own throat by advocating payment of the poll tax, Labour then handed its own electors over to the SNP on a plate who better. "for Scotland" than the Scottish Nationalists?

An exit poll conducted at the polling stations on election day reflected the extent to which Labour had helped shift the focus of the by-election campaign: those rating the poll tax as the major issue "representing Scotland's interests! fell to and 32% cited as primary.

The Labour Party was the party (along with the Tories and the SLD) which was telling the electorate of Govan: pay the poll tax. Less than two months before the disaster Govan was the scene of the Labour Party Scottish special conference on the poll tax which voted to oppose any campaign for non-payment.

Instead of campaigning against the poll tax. the leaders of Labour's misnamed "Stop It" campaign such as Brian Wilson - spent their time campaigning against those who supported non-payment. Wilson denounced those who supported non-payment as "Nats or Trots'. On 10 November many people in Govan voted accordingly.

The Labour Party won 50 seats in Scotland in the General Election. The SNP justifiably nicknamed them the "feeble fifty".

The Labour Party controls Strathclyde Regional Council. The council has been a Kinnockite model council: no fight against the Tories, no fight against the poll tax, no fight against cuts in local government spending. In Govan last week the electorate decided that no fight meant no vote.

The Labour Party also has total control of Glasgow District Coun cil. The council's appalling record on housing, its abandonment of election commitments in order to virtually give away council land to the private sector, and its mediahype about Glasgow being "miles better" has long been an affront to Nationalist lan McCalman that the Left in Scotland must now seize the initiative on poll tax and devolution.

The result of the Govan by-election is a major defeat for the Labour Party in Scotland and a boost to the fortunes of the Scottish National Party (SNP).

Jim Sillars reinforced the victory the working class and to simple common sense. The Govan by-election was seized upon as an opportunity to tell the labour leaders: enough is enough!

It remains for the Labour left to pick up the pieces. It wasn't so much Sillars and the SNP which beat Labour in Govan as Kinnock and the Walworth Road yuppies. They are quite prepared to sit back and accept Toryism until the next General Election (and beyond). The Govan by-election result showed up the complete bankruptcy of their Any inquiry conducted by Kinnock, Dewar and their lieutenants into the debacle will be a cover-up. CLPs must demand that the conclusions reached by such an inquiry are circulated round CLPs for discussion and amendment, and a docu ment analysing the causes of the defeat be presented to the 1989 Labour Party conference. evival ment in Scotland must call these people to account. Whatever their sharp talk and bluster, the reality is that they are the architects of this defeat and others which will likely follow:

The other major issue in the campaign was Scottish self-government. Whilst the majority of the Govan electorate may not necessarily want a separate Scotland, they obviously favour a greater degree of independence within the UK.

But that is also a fluid situation and a recent poll in the Grampian area showed over 40% of those questioned favouring a separate

----- pull-quotes -----

the Govan by-election arguing that a turn by

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 380

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →