The irony of GCHQ and Poland
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
In spite of the weak call over GCHQ by the TUC - lunch time demonstrations ete - I was quite pleased with the response on November 7 in Sheffield, where I went with the sacked Notts miners.
Many pits from the Yorkshire coalfield were present, and from Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire. A lot of people had actually gone on strike - but the TUC itself didn't take the lead.
But the weaker our response to these attacks, like GCHQ, the worse these attacks will get. The four individuals in GCHQ who've been denied trade union rights are in themselves an irrelevance. We need to fight to give the bosses the message that we're not prepared to back down before this sort of atchtime demonstrations.
When I went into my union branch to ask what we were doing about November 7, the first thing that was shoved under my nose was a TUC circular which had gone to all unions and eventually came down to branches - and it really played it down. With that sort of leadership we can't hope to generate the sort of response we should be getting. They should be giving a clear lead.
It's ironic that at the same time as we're on the streets demonstrating for the right to be in a trade union, Maggie Thatcher is over in Poland talking to Lech Walesa and the Polish government demanding the right of Solidarnose to be recognised. It's incomprehensible that Thatcher can be presented as representing freedom and liberty in Poland - but you can't have it here in England.
I have always had my suspicions about Solidarnosc, and those suspicions have been reinforced. I don't see Solidarnosc's Lech Walesa and the church as representatives of the workers' movement but as an anti-revolutionary movement. I suspect there are more CIA officers who are members of Solidarnosc than real workers. To see Walesa and Thatcher arm in arm! Nobody can tell me that Walesa does not know A miner's dinny about the 4000 trade unionists in Notts that are denied the right to be recognised as a trade union within the NUM. Nobody can tell me he doesn't know about GCHQ. I understand placards were shown saying "Thankyou for crushing Scargill* It's ironic that shipyard workers have told Solidarnosc that they're in the same boat. It's a load of bullshit. If it hadn't been for Thatcher having to go to Poland and to the Lenin shipyard, the shipyard in the north-east would have been shut a damned sight earlier.
We're not in the same boat. Shipyard workers will go to the wall in this country because of a crisis of capitalism. In Poland they'll be thrown out of work because of the state trying to impose its will on workers - which is an entirely different argument. They are part of a "socialist' system: there's a lot wrong in Poland, but to try to compare the two is a load of bullshit. We need to recognise the root causes. It's not a question of saying one's worse than the other. But there are different root causes and different solutions.
The NUM in Britain has a difficult period ahead, not just the problem of the Coal Board refusing to negotiate and shoring the UDM up as puppets, but also deeper into the future, the threat of privatisation.
The easiest way to minimise those attacks would be to stand up and firmly show the Coal Board where we stand. I think it's a tragedy that at the NUM delegate conference the resolution from Derbyshire, calling for all out strike action, wasn't carried.
The overtime ban may be a tactic leading to industrial action. But I was told by some of the delegates that last year when we had the arguments about the disciplinary code, South Wales and Scotland were both arguing that we were campaigning on the wrong issues: we ought to be campaigning on wages.
This year we are campagining about wages, yet South Wales and Scotland are saying that we're campaigning on the wrong isues again — we should be arguing about old age pensioners' coal.
It's remarkable that in this difficult situation such inane arguments are thrown into the pot. It's a major tragedy. What we need to do to Thatcher and the Coal Board is declare war. They've declared war on us, and we're still playing cricket. We should be declaring war on them. Sharp, hard industrial action is what is really needed.
Someone in Sheffield today quoted Mick Mc Gahey: "While we keep running, they'll keep chasing. We need to stop and give one short sharp blow into the throat of those chasing after us." The TUC itself should recognise this.
Paul Whetton is a member of ton NUM, South York
Scan page 16
SOCIALIST ORGANISER CPSA FDA PCS ADE UND NUCPS WORKERS' LIBERTY Le Pen: A Hitler for the 1990s/ No. 10 includes articles on the Stalinist roots of left antiSemitism, the Gulf War, France in 1968, Zbigniem:
Kowalawski on Poland. 90p + postage, PO Box SE15-4NA. M shown by workers agnificent solidarity across the country on 7 November, protesting against the sacking of GCHQ trade unionists, was mocked in hypocritical speeches from Neil Kinnock and Norman Willis.
The two, who have done most to stifle the GCHQ campaign, openly applauded secondary action taken by strikers at the 3,000-strong rally in Central Hall, Westminster. They denounced the hypocrisy of Thatcher's jaunt in Poland, where she defended Solidarnosc whilst denying trade union rights at GCHQ and attacking the labour movement in Britain.
Over a month has passed since sacking notices were received by GCHQ trade unionists. Only days before the strike would Kinnock give it his tacit approval. This kind of too little, too late leadership does nothing for the campaign and is an
----- pull-quotes -----
tack. The only way we can do that is massive industrial action, not lun-
WHETTON'S WEIIK
Solidarity and hypocrisy