Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Britain's gulag

Socialist Organiser no. 379, 10 November 1988 · scan p. 13 · about 1,145 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

of convicts to Australians have a collectIve loss of memory about the convict origins of our country. For a century after transportation ended, the topic was barely discussed. Now Australians have a mythologised, sanitised version of those convict beginnings.

Robert Hughes sets out to contradict some of the myths about modern Australian society, which he says are attributed to the convict experience.

One myth is that the convict experience left a legacy of egalitarianism and antiauthoritarianism, based on the common experience of the convicts who had come into conflict with authority. Hughes argues that only a small percentage of the convicts were transported for political offences, explicitly rejecting authority. And even the political convicts generally became conformers, and dropped their political activities when they reached Australia.

There was only one attempt at mutiny in New South Wales, at Vinegar Hill in 1804, by a group of Irish Catholic convicts. He points out that the Emancipists (former convicts, who completed their sentences and remained in Australia), far from identifying with the convicts, were eager to cast off their convict past to become respectable citizens and law-abiding people.

Hughes also examines the myth of spontaneous solidarity among the oppressed, particularly the relationship between convicts and Aboriginals. He claims that racist attitudes developed as a sort of comfort to convicts, who felt elevated by being able to kick somone lower in the social heap than themselves.

The authorities soon found that they could win the help of Aborigines in tracking escaped convicts. Convicts attempting escape, or just personal gain, were ready to steal from Aboriginal people and to kill. them. Antagonism developed rather than bonds of solidarity against the colonial master.

Hughes says little about the meaning of the myths of egalitarianism and antiauthoritarianism in Australia today. The Australian ruling class certainly likes to sell the myth of mateship and egalitarianism. Antiauthoritarianism has been translated by some Ocker businessmen, such as John Elliot of Elders IXL, into policies for deregulation. He's as 'antiauthoritarian' as Margaret Thatcher.

More compelling than Hughes' view of Australians' conception of their history, is his exposition of 18th and 19th century English views on crime and punishment, and their implementation in Australia. Much is of modern relevance, when we see those who want a reduced role for government in the economy simultaneously tub-thumping about law and order, deterrence, punishtered the worst brutality, but Hughes argues that tear of such treatment was used to enforce the rules of the system on the majority. He describes the brutalisation of convicts by floggings, chain gang labour, isolation, solitary confinement and the arbitrary sadism of many superintendents in sickening detail. This treatment drove convicts to greater depths of self-hatred and desperation, and did nothing to make them more cooperative with authority.

Hughes also tells the story of Alexander Maconochie, who was commandant of Norfolk Island for a short time. He espoused reform rather than punishment of convicts, and caused an outrage by providing books for the education of the convicts. Modern jails seem to have at least as much in common with 18th century ideas of punishment and deterrence, as they do with Maconochie's ideas of treating prisoners as human beings so that they may act as human beings.

Convict labour was essential to establishing the infrastructure of the young settlement - the construction of buildings and roads -Saturday 12 November SO AGM. Manchester Saturday 19 November 'Time to Go' conference on Ireland. Camden Centre, Bidborough St, WC1. E5 to Clare Short MP (TTG), House of Commons, London SW1 Saturday 19 November Nottingham SO weekend. Discussions, walks, good food.

Hollinsclough, White Peak District. £12 waged, £6 unwaged: contact Ivan or Rosey 0602 624827 Sunday 20 November North East London SO meeting: 'Fighting Imperialism: Under Whose Flag?" with Clive Bradley. Lucas and increasingly to the growth of sheep farming. The Emancipists and convicts were the only source of many vital skills and professions, as free immigrants were few. The shortage of labour and skills forced the Governors and employers to concede some conditions to labour, free and convict.

Early Governors often had to resist pressure from the sheepfarmers who favoured the harshest treatment of convicts and the exclusion of Emancipists from professions, administration and political considerations.

As the economy grew, and more free migrants arrived, the deterrent value of transportation diminished. During the 1850s goldrushes fortune seekers would pay to get to Australia. The growing free population demanded an end to transportation because of the shame of the convict 'Stain' And so the British Government did end transportaion, because of the sheer cost. Mainly trasportation to NSW ended in 1840, though it trickled onto Van Diemen's Land till 1853 and to Western Australia till 1868.

Arms, Grays Inn Road, Thursday 24 November Northampton SO meeting: 'The Today' with Clive Bradley.

Queens Road, 7.15 pm Saturday 26 November Socialist Conference day school on "Socialism and Democracy'. Civic Centre, Newcastle. Contact Tessa Gray, 4 Normanton Terrace, Elswick, Newcastle-on-Tyne Saturday 26 November Anti-Apartheid Movement Annual Conference. Sheffield Saturday 26 November London Socialist Conference day school on Imperialism. Sir William Collins School, NW1 Monday 28 November London Socialist Forum: "Labour a the Bomb'. Conway Hall, Red Lior Square, WC1, 7.30 pm Saturday 3 December The Fatal Shore is full of painstakingly assembled extracts from convict letters, government records and other original documents which provide a vivid picture of convict experience. Hughes also presents an argument which stimulates the thought processes, even it you don't always agree with his point of view.

The book has been criticised as sensationalising history, and some may consider it a thinly disguised opportunity to appear intellectual while indulging a ghoulish fascination with human pain and suffering. Flogging and brutality do not dominate every chapter, but they were institutionalised in a colonial, penal system, and we should try to understand that.

Hughes is determined to imprint the minds of Australian readers, at least, with an image that will make historical loss of memory impossible from now on.

The Fatal Shore is a gripping, and thought provoking read, for all its 600 pages. You don't need to know much about Australian history to enjoy it, and it has much broader relevance than that.

CLPs conference organising meeting. Merseyside TUCURC, Hardman St, Liverpool, 12 noon. Contact Lol 051 638 1338 Saturday 10 December London Socialist Organiser day school. Contact Mark 01 639 796 Saturday 10 December Socialist Conference: conference against the Poll Tax. Newcastle Medical School. Fee £10 (delegate)/E5/E3 to Terry Conway. 10b Windsor Road, London N7 Sunday 11 December North East London SO Social, 7. pm. Contact Belinda 354 3854 Saturday 25 February Women for Socialism 2-day conference. Wesley House, WC1. Saturday 1 April Campaign for Non-Alignment: 'O of NATO, into the world' 2-day c ference

----- pull-quotes -----

reviews 'The Fatal Shore: a history of the transportation

Australia, 1787-1868' by Robert Hughes (London, Collin Harvill, 1987)

ACTIVISTS DIARY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 379

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →