Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Another exercise in squaring the circle

Socialist Organiser no. 379, 10 November 1988 · scan p. 12 · about 852 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

more prudent version of the A "deformed workers' state"

thesis was put forward by Josephy Hansen, a leader of the American Socialist Workers' Party who died in 1979.

From July 1960, first in relation to Cuba but then applying the same analysis retrospectively in relation to China, Yugoslavia, etc., he developed the notion that the 'workers' and peasants' government' in the sense discussed by the Fourth Congress of the Communist International (1922) was the key link in processes where petty bourgeois leaderships had overthrown capitalist states in those countries and created deformed workers' states.

"By recognising the new Cuban government (after the removal of Urrutia and Pazos) as a 'Workers' And Farmers' Government' we indicate its radical petty bourgeois background and composition and its origin in a popular mass movement, its tendency to respond to popular pressures for action against the bourgeoisie and their agents, and its capacity for whatever im mediate reasons and with whatever hesitancy, to undertake measures against bourgeois political power and against bourgeois property relations". : ('The Character of the New Cuban Government').

Hansen also described the Ben Bella government in Algeria in 1962-5 as a workers' and peasants' government, and cited its fate as:

*Proof that the establishment of a workers' and peasants' government does not automatically guarantee the subsequent establishment of a workers' state". (*The Social Transformations in Eastern Europe, China and Cuba' August 1969).

Hansen based himself on a passage in Trotsky's Transitional Programme:

"One cannot categorically deny in advance the theoretical possibility that, under the influence of completely exceptional circumstances...the petty-bourgeois parties including the Stalinists may go Jurther than they themselves wish along the road to a break with the bourgeoisie. In any case one thing is not to be doubted: even if this highly improbable variant somewhere and some time becomes a reality and the workers and farmers' goverment' in the above-mentioned sense is established, it would represent merely a short episode on the road to the actual dictatorship of the proletariat. "

The workers' and peasants' government formula had been used before for the Chinese revolution, by some writers (eg Ernest Mandel). But Hansen systematised the theory.

It was surely, a case of scissorsand-paste theorising. The Fourth Congress of the CI advanced the ideal of the workers' and peasants' government as the highest form of the united front. The Communists would fight to force the parties based on the workers and peasants to break with the bourgeoisie, and under the control of their mass base to take serious measures against tionally. And in the event of the opportunist parties going so far as to create such a government, its first clashes with the bourgeoisie would spark off huge mass struggles which could only end victoriously in the full rule of the working class.

In the cases Hansen was describing, it is rather a matter of clashes between a petty bourgeois apparatus, based on a victorious armed struggle, and the bourgeoisie. It is not inconceivable that such clashes should provide an opening for working class revolutionary action: in the actual cases they did not. The Fourth Congress reference to a workers' and peasants' government is to a condition of flux in state power where the alternatives are the workers mobilising and going over the head of the petty bourgeois leaders in the goverment, to create a workers" state, or Hansen's reference is to a state of flux where these two alternatives may exist, but so may (and crucially did) another: the victory of the petty-bourgeois revolutionaries, and the creation by their leaders of a bureaucratic state-monopoly system. Hansen implicitly equated this outcome with the outcome of workers' power, blurring the equation only with a few comments about bureaucratic deformation.

Politically , manscus theory was more prudent than the Mandelite theory. It maintained a political distance from the leaders of revolutions like the Chinese and Vietnamese, calling them Stalinist. It raised the notion of independent working class initiative in the revolutionary turmoil. In however limited a way, it recognised the bureaucratic nature of the revolutionary regimes.

As an account of reality it was nonsense. The Chinese or Vietnamese Communist Parties were not pushed by the workers to go further than they wished. Their leaders were bold, decisive - and very much in control. They overthrew the old order - and simultaneously stifled or crushed the working class.

They did lead mass movements - but those were not workers' movements, According to Hansen's theory, the workers are s apposed to have been strong enoug h to torce reluctant Stalinist leade s to overthrow capitalism - yet not strong enough to establish the most minimal trade union rights for themselves.

Hansen's theory, like the Mandelite theory, is an exercise in scholasticism. It is more evidence that to try to square the "deformed and degenerated workers' state" thesis with Marxist theory is to try to square the circle.

80p Second edition March 1987 A Workers' Liberty pamphlet Available from PO Box 82 London SE15 4NA. 80p 30p p&p

----- pull-quotes -----

capitalist power. Such agitation would in any case by useful educa-

MARXISM, STALINISM AND AFGHANISTAN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 379

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →