Workers' states against the workers?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
In Socialist Organiser No. 371 we opened a discussion on the nature of the bureaucratic statemonopoly societies of the Here Clive Bradley and Martin Thomas examine the most influential of the theories produced to underpin the idea that these societies are "degenerated and deform ed workers' states" - the theories produced by the co-thinkers of Ernest Mandel and Joseph Hansen in the USFI (United Secretariat of Fourth International).
Michel Lov y has proretical exposition of Mandelite views entitled The Politics of Combined and Uneven Development'. Lowy confronts the theoretical problem - that the old capitalist order has been overthrown by forces other than the working class led by genuine Marxist parties — in such a way as to define it out of existence rhetorically.
Did these revolutions (Yugoslavia, China. under the Lowy asks, occur leadership of the proletariat... and more precisely under the direction of a proletarian (communist) party"? (p.107). He answers yes. "Communist' equals proletarian party equals proletariat. The real problem - that the Chinese revolution, for example, was carried out by a peasant army - is thus not confronted but avoided.
*The parties" , Lowy claims, *were the political and programmatic expression of the proletariat, by virtue of their adherence to the The Sandinista revolution: is it socialist? historic interests of the working class (abolition of capitalism, etc.)...the parties' ideologies were proletarian and the membership and periphery were systematically educated to accept the values and world view of the international working class movement" (pp.214 5, emphasis in original).
For a Trotskyist to conclude that Stalinist parties, like the Vietnamese, which massacred the Trotskyists in 1946-7, or the Chinese, which suppressed all independent working-class activity on its entry into the cities, were politically, programmatically and ideologically proletarian is to retreat into mysticism. If this is how to defend 'orthodoxy' then | better be revisionist!
What this orthodoxy" amounts to is a chronic inability to deal with reality without suffering gross illusions in revolutionists of action'. But it has to be theorised. Lebanese Mandelite Salah Jaber has performed the task.
In a long article in 'Quatrieme Internationale' ', 'Proletarian Revolution and the Dictatorship of the Proletariat' , Jaber spells it out. Paraphrasing Engels, he writes:
"Of late, the philistine Eurocommunist has once more been filled with wholesome terror at the words: Dictatorship of the Proletariat. Well and good, gentlemen, do you want to know what this dictatorship looks like? Look at Nicaragua. That is the dictatorship of the proletariat" (November 1984, p.114). ENSA Jaber surveys working class history since the Paris Commune. His essential point is that the class character of the state is determined by the 'armed bodies of men' *The destruction of the armed forces of the bourgeoisie by the armed force of the workers marks the birth of a workers' state" (p.63).
Whether or not the state carries out nationalisations is, he argues, completely irrelevant. And by these criteria Nicaragua has been a workers' state from the moment that the Sandinistas took power.
Previous USFI positions are, Jaber states, absurd. The SWP's notion that China, for example, became a workers' state around 1955 — after the final wave of nacapitalist counter-revolution. tionalisations - is a l heoretical confusion. There was a workers' state in China from 1931 when the Maoists established a regional government in Kiangsi.
On Cuba, Jaber is yet thright.
"A movement of the masses as proletarian, if not more, than those of the Paris Commune, endowed with an ideology at least as radical as that of the Commune, which totally destroyed the bourgeois army, to the gain of a rebel Army, as proletarian if not more so than the Federation de la Garde nationale, what is that? A Government of it is the dictatorship of the proletariat" (p.101). Moreover, this sense...Fidel bettter understands the Marxist-Leninist theory of the state than Mandel (or) the SWP"
To square the circles of his theory, Jaber must eventually resort to the same fiction as Lowy: that the Yugoslav, Chinese, Vietnamese etc. Communist Parties were politically workers' parties.
Jaber emphatically rejects the idea that a nationalised economy, in and of itself, can define a workers' state. But his alternative is no better.
Indeed it makes no sense to see the nationalised economies as the "workers" element in the statemonopoly societies. These are nationalised economies controlled by a despotic bureaucracy, which give the workers worse conditions than a market economy and do not even develop the productive forces faster.
But "the armed forces of the workers"? This is fantasy. In China, in Vietnam, and in Yugoslavia the revolutionary armies were based on the peasantry and when they won power they established states which stifled or crushed the working class!
These are states which allow the workers no right to form their own trade unions and parties, and not even individual liberties. Even Cuba, initially more open, is now of that type.
----- pull-quotes -----
workers and peasants'? A 'dual powere sui generis"? No, comrades: