What we think
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Thank you, Mrs Thatcher, for crushing Scargill" "We love Thatcher" "Commies out", "You keep Lenin, the shipyard is ours" The slogans shouted by Polish workers when they greeted Margaret Thatcher in Gdansk last Friday have confirmed much of the hostility and suspicion towards Solidarnose which exists in the British labour movement.
We in Socialist Organiser are as sickened as anyone by the sight of workers cheering Margaret Thatcher. We think leaders and members of Solidarnosc who see Thatcher as representing a positive alternative to the system they live under are wrong.
But Solidarnosc is the Polish workers' movement. Socialists should support Solidarnosc, unequivocally and without reservations, against Poland's ruling Last Friday was not the first time workers have shouted reactionary slogans — not by far! America's trade unions have been overwhelmingly right-wing and pro-capitalist for many decades, but we still support them against the bosses and the government.
And think back to the years before 1956. Millions of the most militant workers in the West carried the portrait and hailed the name of Josef Stalin - the man who imposed a reign of terror on the USSR's workers.
Stalin stripped the workers of any rights to organise or to speak out. He drove down their wages by fifty per cent between 1928 and 1935. He decreed laws under which workers could be, and were, jailed for being late to work. He put ten million people in forced labour camps.
Yet in Italy, France, and many other countries, many of the best and most thoughtful working class fighters saw Stalin as their hero. They had read reports of terror and suffering in the USSR, but dismissed them as capitalist lies. Stalin represented an alternative to the private bosses' exploitation they suffered under, and so they supported him. _Today everyone admits that Stalin was a tyrant. But even today many left-wingers, like Arthur Scargill and Tony Benn, see the rulers of the Eastern Bloc as some sort of socialists.
The Polish workers who cheer Thatcher are a mirror-image of the workers in the West who cheered Stalin or - who cheer Gorbachev. "Communism" , to them, means not democratic workers' control but the state-monopoly tyranny which oppresses them. Thatcher seems to represent an alternative.
The Polish workers hear about exploitation and oppression in Britain - but they dismiss most of it as lies. After all, for years Poland's official media told them that workers' conditions in Britain were still the same as in Dickens' day. Why should they believe anything those media tell them?
In the West we condemn workers' illusions in Jaruzelski or Gorbachev, but we still support those workers against the bosses. The same principle should hold in the East.
If disgust at the cheers for ThatSocialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working-class socialism.
We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.
Socialism can never be built one country alone. The cher meakes us oppose Solidarnose, then we are making the same mistake as those Polish workers whose disgust at Scargill's support for Jaruzelski turns them against our miners' union. Indeed, we are making much worse mistakes than most Solidarnose activists do.
Whatever their illusions, underground Solidarnosc committees did send messages of support for the British miners in 1984 -while Jaruzelski's government was sending scab coal to help Thatcher beat the strike. And whatever Lech Walesa's words of appreciation for Thatcher, diplomatic or sincere as they may be, he has come out publicly against the Tories for the rights of the workers at GCHQ and for the shipyard workers in Sunderland fighting closure.
When we see a picket line, we don't ask what the religion of the workers on that picket line is, or which way they vote, or what they think of international politics. We see workers in dispute with their exploiters, and we support the workers. And that should hold for Polish workers too.
workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwide, including the struggle of workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.
We stand:
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working-class-based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controls.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority-
----- pull-quotes -----
WHERE WE STAND