Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Feminising the economy?

Socialist Organiser no. 379, 10 November 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 996 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Should socialists support a feminist incomes policy? Lynn Ferguson thinks not Women earn on average 70% of men's hourly pay. Despite equal opportunity policies, the Sex Discrimination and Equal Pay Acts, women are still largely confined to traditionally "female" areas of work - caring and service jobs for instance — which can be badly unionised and badly paid.

Many women work part-time — over the past few years the biggest growth in jobs has been part-time jobs for women. In short, despite advances made in women's equality over the past 10-15 years the majority of working women are still an underpaid, underprivileged sector of the workforce.

We want to change this - but how? One strategy which has been mooted from time to time over the years and which is being talked about again now is the 'Feminist Incomes Policy'.

The Feminist Incomes Policy appears in many guises. For some it simply means a guaranteed real social income for women, coupled with equal pay and minimum wage legislation that really has teeth. This seems to me to be uncontentious.

A fight for decent pay in the service sector, a fight for decent child benefits, maternity benefits and for free childcare provision could not only massively improve the lot of working women but would be of benefit to the working class as a whole.

A real fight by the labour movement for full-time rights for part-time workers would be of material benefit to many women and would also remove many of the constraints - for instance, fear of losing your job — that prevents them from participating in the labour movement, from going on strike, etc.

So far so good. But for many, the Feminist Incomes Policy means something rather different. Ex-Labour minister Barbara Castle said in the 1970s "women can have equal pay tomorrow if only men will moderate their wage demands." The sort of clever comment you'd expect from a Labour minister, I suppose.

But her sentiments are echoed by some feminists. The argument goes roughly as follows: men get paid a "family wage" - their wages are determined by the assumption that WOMEN'S CONFERENCE FIGHTBACK SPECIAL IAL of cake. That might be justified if we knew for sure that revolution were just around the corner; otherwise it sounds suspiciously like an excuse for irresponsibility."

Revolution won't happen tomorrow. But if we take Bruegel's point of view we take united class action against the capitalists off the immediate agenda, let alone revolution!

If well organised, relatively well paid sections of male workers strike for and win higher wages it provides a boost to the working class as a whole - including women workers. To attack or depress male workers' wages would be an attack on the class as a whole. The bosses would be happy - more profits for them. Men would see women workers as the enemy. Sex divisions in the working class would be accentuated, the possibility of a united fightback would be set back.

The way to improve the wages and conditions of working women is to organise women in the labour movement to make the movement as a whole accessible and responsive to our demands, but also to organise the class as a whole in a fight against the bosses. In the here and now we should make demands on the state for real equal pay, etc. But centrally we should support anyone who strikes for higher pay — women or men The way forward for women lies in fighting alongside men, often fighting for our right to fight alongside men, not in demanding that they share their economic power with us. That's just ignoring the real enemy — the capitalist profiteers. The Tories have slashed childcare provision - many full-time nursery places have been cut, nurseries closed and jobs lost.

The general lack of childcare provision in society prevents women from fully participating. It is a barrier to women in employment, the labour movement, education and student unions, etc.

Inside education, the lack ot childcare provision is an issue of access. The vast majority of students with childcare responsibilities are in the public and further education sector. It is young women, mature students and working class women who are excluded because of the lack of decent childcare.

The funding of childcare provision in education should be the responsibility of the institutes and not the students' union. In many colleges ad hoc childcare provision is set up by the students' union. Whilst such provision is undoubtedly useful on a temporary basis, it is no substitute for proper childcare run by professional people. After all, childcare should meet the needs of children as well as their carers.

What we need inside the student movement is a nationally coordinated childcare campaign - a campaign that's part of the broad framework of a campaign for education for all.

The campaign should draw together students and workers on campus; it should be run in conjunction with trade unions, workplace nursery campaigns, etc. The campaign must work with and through Areas to gain the commitment of local education authorities to childcare provision.

Childcare should be the responsibility of all. For too long inside NUS there's been a consensus that childcare provision is fundamental to women's liberation and access for all in education that never moves further than glossy leaflets and an NEC speaker at the odd General Meeting.

Children must be placed high on the NUS agenda, but for childcare to be a serious campaign with demands that can be won it must be part of an integrated campaign for education for all.

Running individual and isolated campaigns on single issues is not the way to build strong campaigns that can be won. Only by involving the majority of the membership in a campaign that is democratically organised and nationally coordinated can NUS build a serious fight for childcare provision. Reprinted from SSiN broadsheet.

----- pull-quotes -----

UDENT )MEN ) cut (NUS Exec, personal capacity)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 379

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →