Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Fat cat gets the cream

Socialist Organiser no. 379, 10 November 1988 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,545 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

numbers of Reform Jews in the United States, as well as the 70% of Israeli Jews who are not religious. Further, it is unclear if the coalition wil be able to agree on urgent economic policies. A wave of strikes is about to begin.

To what extent is the rightward shift in Israel comparable to that in South Africa? Many who see the societies as essentially similar would obviously want to identify political developments.

But in fact there are big differences. The rightward shift among South African whites is the result of alienation from a government that is seen as too moderate. In particular, the government policy to incorporate a section of the black population has caused a backlash, for example among white civil servants who are directly affected financially.

White privileges which would be lost in the event of an end to white supremacy are huge.

Jewish privilege over Arabs in Israel and the occupied territories obviously exists. But it is less substantial. Their privileges would be increased if Israel became more like South Africa. The prejudices of poor Jews against Arabs are deeply ingrained and have their roots in a number of factors, including fear of competition on the labour market.

But the objective Jewish-Arab gap is far narrower, and objectively should be easier to cross (which is not to say it is easy). In other words, Israeli Jews have far less to lose than South African whites.

So while the rightward shift in South Africa might be inevitable given the structure of the society, in Israel it is not. It is possible to win Jews from an anti-Arab, pro-Likud position, Is Labour an alternative to Likud? Politically Labour is neither radical nor socialist, nor is it a workers" party, Should socialists NSIDE THE By Sleeper come in abuse et ad ver the years the left have pleasingly abusive epithets for union leaders: they are, variously, the "labour lieutenants of capital", the "bloated bureaucrats", the "ugly faces with scabby noses" and (in the memorable words of one IS factory bulletin), "treacherous old shitbags".

My personal favourite has always been simply "fat cats", which seems to sum up the particular combination of sleekness, sloth and complacency that characterises most national union leaders. And for the living embodiment of the "fat cat" , you need look no further than Clive Jenkins, former general secretary of ASTMS.

Clive, having presided over last year's merger between ASTMS and TASS, to form MSF (which may sound like something to do with fitted kitchen units, but is in fact •Manufacturing, Science and Finance' , rumoured to be a trade union), has now announced his retirement from his positition as joint general secretary (with Ken Gill) of the new organisation.

He apparently intends to spend the autumn of his life in Tasmania working for the Wilderness Movement, an organisation devoted to the preservation of rain forests.

After many years as a union full-timer (plus some shrewd property investments), the Fat Cat is certainly not short of a bob or two: when interviewed recently he did not deny being a millionaire. Nevertheless, the MSF general purposes committee felt able to give him a golden handshake worth £213,000. This includes the salary he would have received if he'd stayed on another three years and retired at 65, plus a "top up". • When he reaches 65, Jenkins will receive a pension of two thirds his £43,000 a year salary.

There is nothing dishonest or even unconstitutional about any of this: Jenkins is quite entitled to the money. Nevertheless, quite a few people in MSF feel that someone already so wealthy might, perhaps, have voluntarily foregone just a little of his full entitlement especially as the union is in serious financial difficulty at the moment. MSF is estimated to be nearly £3 million in debt and is currently seeking voluntary redundancies in an effort levels.

It may be of significance that while Ken Gill and the old TASS component of the MSF's leadership appear quite happy with the generous pay-off to Jenkins, tormer ASIMS members at all levels of the union are up in arms.

This is because of a simmering dispute over the structure of the merged union: ASTMS was a loose, relatively democratic organisation in which branches had a lot of autonomy. TASS, in contrast, operated a much more bureaucratic "divisional" structure that gave the "Broad Left" (ie. Stalinist) leadership almost complete domination.

The two unions' respective national conferences in 1987 reflected there very different structures: the TASS conference had just 135 delegates, whilst ASTMS had almost 1,000. Delegates to the ASTMS conference, while overwhelmingly in support of the proposed merger, instructed their NEC to defend the branch-based structure and the power of regions to elect delegates to Labour Party and TUC conferences. Many ASTMS activists felt that throughout the negotiations, Jenkins was all too eager to sell out to TASS on these questions.

At the moment, the two components of MSF (now diplomatically named "Division A" and "Division 1"') operate on the basis of their old, pre-merger constitutions. The matter will be settled at the 1989 annual conference, which will be in part given over to rules revision.

In the meantime, the Fat Cat's departure for arboreal activities in the Antipodes, can only strengthen Gill's hand, making it more likely that MSF will finally emerge in the image of TASS.

Scan page 6

Is someone who has A supported Solidarity in Poland, I feel I must speak out in relation to Mrs Thatcher's visit to Poland and her declared support for Solidarity.

One thing is crystal clear. Mrs Thatcher has double standards concerning trade unions and freedom.

It is also clear that Lech Walesa and other Solidarity leaders are not fully aware (no doubt because they do not have a really free press) of Mrs Thatcher's hostile attitude to free and independent trade unions in Britain.

Perhaps they are influenced to praise her because she is a Western political leader who has declared support for Solidarity and has visited Poland to say so. In comparison to the lack of real political freedom in Poland and a system without proper democratic elections some of the Solidarity leaders believe that we must have real freedom for workers in Britain.

Unfortunately, they are wrong. Solidarity leaders either have wrong information, or they have not fully understood the nature of the Thatcherite regime.

It surely cannot be an accident that General Jarulzelski praises the economic policies and methods used by Mrs Thatcher. He praises her toughness, "Thatcher is friend of trade unionists. In going to Poland her motive was not to assist the workers, but her hostility to a system she calls socialist."

a toughness used against the trade unions in this country. The truth is that the arguments advanced by the General against Solidarity, strikers and workers' conditions, are similar to those used by the Thatcher Government against British trade Mrs Thatcher is being thoroughly hypocritical. In Britain, her Government has presided over wholesale closures of factories and shipyards. The postponement of the closure of the Sunderland shipyard is surely due to her Polish visit so as not to embarrass her.

In Britain, the trade unions have been hamstrung by the worst anti-trade union legislation in Western Europe. GCHQ workers have been sacked for being in a trade union and workers have been banned from membership of their unions.

Elected Labour councillors have been disqualified from office and surcharged for carrying out their promises to their electors, whilst Government Ministers are responsible for wholesale waste and financial incompetence and they remain in office with the full backing of Mrs Thatcher.

Mrs Thatcher is no friend of trade unionists. In going to Poland to say what she did her motive was not to assist the workers in Solidarity, but her hostility to a system that she misguidedly calls socialist, and perhaps believes is socialist.

Solidarity's programme, agreed at its conferences in 1981, does not accept the private enterprise system, but calls for workers' democracy in industry. That is the last thing Mrs Thatcher wants. Thatcher and Walesa: different classes This week, the Campaign Group of Labour MPs sent a telegram to Lech Walesa, explaining what the Thatcher Government is doing to British workers and their unions. Clearly, we have to follow that up by other representations and contact.

What is required is the unity and understanding of workers in Britain and Poland, so that they can assist each other in fighting their governments, which are both basically anti-union.

The Polish workers, because of their opposition to the regime in Poland, as a result of their living in an unfree bureaucratic country, may be swayed to praise Mrs Thatcher, but they need to realise that to get rid of Jaruzelski and the bureaucratic system he represents and to replace it with a type of Thatcherism, would in no way solve their problems. What we need to do together is to fight for real other in building a new society east and west, as envisaged by such great socialists as Rosa Luxembourg.

Abridged from a statement to constituents issued in Liverpool by Eric S Heffer MP for Walton, Liverpool on 5 Nover Iber

----- pull-quotes -----

BE Heffer

democracy, a genuine socialist democracy, and to assist each

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 379

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →