Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Right gains in Israel

Socialist Organiser no. 379, 10 November 1988 · scan p. 5 · about 674 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Mnst Israelis will be unhappy with concessions demanded by the religious right.

Clive he new coalition government T in Israel to be based around Yitzhak Shamir's Likud Party will be very bad news indeed for Palestinians.

Likud have promised harsher measures to crush the Palestinian uprising, or intifida; and, although Shamir has refused to bow to all their demands, the far right and religious parties with whom the government is to be formed will expect still bigger steps.

Some of the far right (including the right of the Likud itself) favour what is euphamistically called "transfer" of Arabs from the occupied West Bank - that is, depor tation. And although Shamir has explicitly rejected this course of action (and the far right have accepted his rejection) the "transfer" policy is gaining respectability.

The West Bank and Gaza, occupied in 1967, are home for well over one million Arabs. They posed a big question for Israel even before the intifada began, nearly a year ago. Now they are the centrai questions for Israel.

What choices does Israel have? Shamir's policy is to maintain the status of the West Bank and Gaza as occupied territories - that is, not formally part of Israel. This is despite Likud's very clear claim that what they call Judaea and Samaria are part of the land of Israel. The effect of the policy is that the Arab inhabitants have almost no rights for example, no voting rights in this last election. (Jewish residents in the territories, meanwhile, have full citizenship rights).

It would fit with Likud's own ideology to annexe these areas. But then what would they do about the Arabs?

By the early years of the next century, Arabs will outnumber Jews in the whole area now ruled by Israel. Annexation would immediately put the number of Arab citizens of the Jewish state at around 2,000,000.

For most Zionists, even of a liberal persuasion, this is unacceptable. It could only be allowed if the "equal citizens" were formally denied equal rights.

Some right-wingers are already talking about taking the right to vote away from those Arabs who are Israeli citizens at the moment.

Moreover, which worries liberals, a formal declaration of inequality like that would have far-reaching consequences for the state's treatment of its Jewish citizens.

Driving, the Arabs out *transfer - is the preferred option of the far right. The status quo (plus crushing the uprising) is seen as too short-term a policy. Shamir insists that all he wants is what was agreed with Egypt and the US at Camp David ten years ago.

The Labour Party of Shimon Peres, which has not held power independently of the Likud since security-conscious withdrawal from 1977, does favour a partial, the West Bank, following international negotiations from which the Palestinians' representative, the PLO, would be excluded. It justifies a softer Palestinian policy (although former Defence Minister Yitzhak Rabin was hardly soft)

more on the basis of what repression does to Israeli Jewish souls than on the basis of justice.

Anyway, Labour's ambiguous stance has helped squeeze the party out.

Those advocating a democratic policy — complete withdrawal from the occupied territories, negotiations with the PLO and the creation of an independent Palestinian state - are a small but vocal minority Shamir's stitch-up with the religious parties may prove a false economy. He needs them to form a government; but the concessions they will expect will be deeply unpopular. For example, changes are expected in the Law of Return, defining only Orthodox Jews as entitled to immigrate and take up Israeli citizenship.

This will offend the huge nevertheless favour a Labour against a Likud government? Or, at least, could the far left find some way to force out Labour?

The electoral system in Israel favours small parties: it is an ultrademocratic proportional representation system that many Israelis blame for political instability and want to see changed. Maybe there is some basis for a "left united front" over the issue of granting the Palestinian Arabs' right to have their own state.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 379

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →