Unite the left in NUS
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
SOCIALIST Socialist Outlook and Briefing seem to have left Socialist Student - again.
We suppose it's to be expected — they do it every couple of years... And then they come back.
The reason they come back is that outside Socialist Student they are left without ideas, isolated and are seen to be needlessly splitting the lett.
What have they got to say for themselves? An article by Carl Taylor in the latest Socialist Outlook and a speech from one of their comrades indicate that they are wandering away from SSiN because:
• Although they can agree with Socialist Student on many of the most basic issues in NUS NOLS, they think that Socialist Organiser's influence makes Socialist Student "soft" on imperialism;
• We are overly concerned with elections and, moreover, will make electoral pacts with right-wing Zionists and Jews (ie. the Union of Jewish Students);
• They say that SSiN is a Socialist Organiser front;
• They want to build a conference called by Manchester Poly Left Caucus on 28 November to discuss a new left vehicle in the student movement.
Now to split your small group away from the big, broad left in the student movement on issues which are less than immediate and central is stupid. The central issues for a rank and file group in the student movement are fighting voluntary membership, loans, education cuts and Poll Tax in alliance with the labour movement; and combatting the Kinnockite careerists whose control stops the NUS and NOLS from dealing with these issues.
At the Socialist Student AGM an Iranian socialist made a similar point: it would be completely wrong to split a broad alliance like SSiN over the issue of "imperialism". He added that, to him, it looked like just more sectarianism on the British left.
International issues are important and indeed Socialist Outlook could do with having more clear-cut ideas on such issues and arguing for them more vigorously. But student unionism is centrally based on its ability to fight for its members' most basic interests.
NUS is not a political party whose central plank is fight imperialism! Indeed, if a left leadership of NUS tried to make it NUS's main thing to "fight imperialism" then NUS would fall to bits.
NUS is a very broad coalition of people, from very different backgrounds. NUS should mobilise them in basic campaigns which directly affect students' pockets and students' ability to study and have a decent education system.
Because these are NUS's central issues, then they are Socialist Student's central concerns when we're building a rank and file movement. Has any trade union rank and file movement ever been built otherwise?
Even if Socialist Outlook were right on the international issues, they would be wrong to split. But they're wrong on the issues too! On Ireland, do we side with the troops? Of course not! But Socialist Outlook does applaud Sinn Fein's attempt to get a pan-Catholic electoral coalition with the SDLP.
In the Middle East, do we support the Israeli state's actions on the West Bank and Gaza? Don't be stupid! But Socialist Outlook does Outlook, noted for its blandness and vagueness rather than any great become redol on has suddenly Ireland and Palestine.
All the bluster is just cover for the fact that Socialist Outlook is running away from Socialist Student.
They have not had any answers ever on strategy inside NOLS or NUS - the best thing they have managed is to grunt in agreement with what others have said.
They have had plenty of opportunity to put forward what they think to Socialist Student. The only real differences they have raised have been on international issues. They have lost the argumentsmassively. And yet they have had plenty of space for their minority views in Socialist Student bulletins, for instance at the Christmas 1987 NUS conference when the Middle East was discussed.
Socialist Student has actually gone out of its way to invite people with different views to Socialist Student events and discuss with them on Palestine, the Labour Party and Minorities in Socialist Student are guaranteed minority rights and representation: this is still open to Briefing - or anyone else for that matter.
What have Socialist Outlook done in return? They have not built SSiN groups in the few colleges where they are central.
They lack serious intent to fight for their politics inside SSiN. They lack faith in their ability to build themselves if the students in their colleges come within a million miles