The great American emptiness
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Second edition March 1987 A Workers' Liberty pamphlet Includes a detailed analysis of Militant's view of Stalinism as well as Socialist Organiser's position on the Russian troops Available from PO Box 823, London SEIS 4NA. 80p + 30p p&p Gordon MacMill reviews 'Fast (Faber). T is as stunning and original his book of short stories as anything else Jayne Anne Phillips has written. In the vein of 'Black Tickets' and Machine Dreams', she offers a book that focuses on the people disenfranchised from the American dream and living in the nation's heart.
Her writing contrasts strongly with the consumer culture that some American writers are preoccupied with. Ms Phillips has managed superbly to encapsulate America to the degree where it becomes a tangible reality. A world, which although melancholically painted black, blue and grey, still manages to retain a distorted and manacing beauty. Ms Phillips's writing is exact and disturbing.
"Fast Lanes' is not only the title and the most impressive piece in the collection, but it is a theme, it is the thread through which the lives of Ms Phillips's characters are weaved. She writes of a world where everyone has been or is in the fast lane.
'How Mickey Made It' is one of the seven highly impressive stories, told vividly and with great colour in monologue through the eyes of a young unemployed punk, looking back and looking forward.
The title story of the collection is by far the most enjoyable piece of writing. A nameless narator rides for three weeks on a journey through the states, travelling back to see her dying father, with a stranger called Thurman. Taking turns to drive, she speeds recklessly, consumed by an addict's cold hysteria which exposes her ever more to the violence of the fast lane.
Chasing the lines on the road she is struggling not to beat the speed of the Fast Lanes, but to match it.
Fast Lanes is for a while reminiscent of Joan Didion, who still talks about a land where it is easier to Dial-A-Devotion than to buy a book. But where Ms Phillips might write about the great American emptiness, she is shrewd enough to know that the emptiness is actually filled with something.
Scan page 11
happened to the rank and file? W attic recently, the hilst clearing out the somnulent one came across a battered and dog-eared pamphlet entitled "What's Gone Wrong In Engineering -the Case for Change in the AUEW". It was published by the "Engineers Charter" and a sophisticated carbon dating process has established that it probably originated from around May 1980 AD.
It's a well-produced little document that deals in some detail with the state of the union (previously and subsequently called the AEU), the general political situation (the Tories had just got in, but memories of Labour and the Social Contract were still fresh) the shortcomings of the recently ousted Broad Left leadership (Hughie to Power — the Rot Sets In") and the nature of the newly-elected "moderate" leadership ("Boyd and Duffy - Thugs Not Mugs").
Along the way, the pamphlet looks back to the 1920s and the Minority Movement (with a whole section devoted to an extract from a Wal Hannington pamphlet) and blems and acrime sheer proe blems and arguments like members don't want to know".
It closes with a stirring call for a "rank and file organisation (that) builds inside the factories...to replace the leadership with a new one which has its sights set on the transformation of society and an end to the subjection of one class by another."
Some of the politics are a bit funny: for instance the calls for a new leadership are contradicted by bits that seem to argue against having any leadership and even against shop stewards having time off the job and access to telephones (With the 'union' always available in a office and on the end of a telephone, it becomes much easier for management to control the militancy on the shop floor").
Who produced this excellent document? Believe it or not, it was the SWP!
You wouldn't know it, though. There are no adverts for Socialist Worker, no application forms for membership, no calls to give up on the existing labour movement -just an invitation to take a regular order of "Charter" magazine for your branch or stewards committee and to attend the "Charter" conference.
How times have changed! These days the SWP would probably slag off "What's Gone Wrong" as reformist, apolitical or worse, simply because it doesn't call on people to join the revolutionary party, and concerns itself instead with arguments you hear from "moderates" on the shop floor.
In fact, the "Engineers Charter" was the lost manifestation of a very serious orientation towards the unions and the shop floor that the SWP (and before it, the IS) had carried through in the 1970s. Within a few months of the appearance of "What's Gone Wrong" the "Charter" and all the other SWPsponsored rank and file groups were disbanded and the entire organisation turned its back upon serious intervention in the unions.
From then until now, the "downturn" theory has been the SWP's holy writ. Concern with unions has been limited to preaching the futility of fighting to transform the movement and the inevitabililty of ultimate defeat...unless the "militant minority' sees the error of its ways and joins the SWP.
The 'downturn' theory has led to some bizarre results, like the denunciation of miners' support committees as "left wing Oxfam" for four or five months into the miners' strike. It has also resulted in some truly mind-boggling vacillations on the question of union leadership.
During the healthworkers' dispute earlier this year, the SWP opposed the formation of a national shop stewards committee, on the grounds that without the support of the NUPE and CoHSE leaderships nothing could be done.
When Alan Tuffin called off the postal dispute in September the SWP immediately pronounced the strike dead and began the postmortem, despite the fact that thousands of UCW members in offices like Liverpool and Coventry had rejected the deal and were still holding out. SWP rejects the idea of campaigning within the structures of the CPSA for a re-ballot for all-out action and instead have hinted at picketing out offices after 7 November.
There is, simply, no logic or consistency to any of this, beyond sheer opportunism: SWP members in the health service and Post Office tend to be fairly demoralised and defeatist while in the CPSA an ultra-left tendency prevails.
There are some signs of the SWP trying to get its act together in the unions and to rebuild its old credibility among militants. A pre-conference bulletin last year took the Glasgow comrades to task for "propagandist and syndicalist practice" around a bus strike, where the SWP's main intervention had been to denounce the strike leaders for bringing in the Labour Party!
Last month Tony Cliff wrote an article entitled *Dark Clouds with Silver Linings" that warned of a tendency to "approach every struggle that arises today as a defeat. It can lead socialists to argue about how they differ from those in struggle rather than what they have in common."
Given the lousy reputation that the SWP has won for itself (thanks tonions it seems unlikely that it whil ever regain the standing it once had among militants, or rebuild the rank and file movement.
The SWP today is a chronically unstable organisation, ultra-lett and rightist by turn, guided only by crude impressionism and cheapskate opportunism. Nowhere is this plainer than in its union work. Actually for an old IS-er like me it resembles nothing so much as those three despised initials Eye..Em.. Gee.
----- pull-quotes -----
Lanes' by Jayne Anne Phillips
NSIDE THE JINIONS By Sleeper