Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Back to white Australia?

Socialist Organiser no. 378, 3 November 1988 · scan p. 9 · about 1,597 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Try to all his ideals workers' state. That's why the USSR is a workers' state.

Martin Thomas of Socialist Organiser asked, how do we assess the statified and planned economies? Are they something for which workers should be prepared to make sacrifices? No.

1. Capitalist planning is for prolit. Now you may argue that the surplus in the USSR isn't profit. But for sure the economy is planned around the bureaucrats grabbing the surplus. Why is that better than planning for profit?

2. The conditions for the workers are worse. Compare West Germany and East Germany, North Korea and South Korea. It is not a matter of imperialism. Compare Eastern Europe and Ireland. Irish workers on average have higher wages and more democratic rights.

3. The statised economies do not develop the productive forces taster. Even the bureaucracy doesn't believe they do. There is nothing there to defend. You can argue there is only by reproducing Stalinist propaganda or resorting to mysticism.

Summing up, the speaker from *Socialism and Revolution' said that none of the defenders of the 'degenerated and deformed workers' states' thesis had replied to concrete questions. How far can a workers' state degenerate? How is Poland a workers' state?

Nationalisation cannot be decisive. How can you separate nationalisation and workers' management? Anyway there is more nationalisation in Iraq, Syria or Iran than in the USSR.. Lutte Ouvriere says the USSR is a workers' state because its origin was a workers' revolution. But workers lost power.

What are the programmatic conclusions! For a start, that we don't say "Defend the gains of the October revolution" . That doesn't mean we're for the restoration of capitalism. But we can't just repeat the worn-out formulas of 50 years ago.

Al Richardson said there had been too much moralising about how nasty the USSR is. You can have a ruling but oppressed class, like the colonial bourgeoisie.

John O'Mahony dismissed the Spartacist argument that SO is somehow moved by pressure from the Labour left. What we're saying is very unpopular on the left!

Nationalised property is not necessarily workers' property. Obviously it would be better to put a nationalised economy under workers' control than to restore capitalism. But the key is the working class. In any conflict between the workers and the bureaucrats we're with the workers.

Margaret Thatcher's visit to Australia hit the headlines because of the demonstrations against her in Melbourne and Sydney. However, her visit was important for another reason.

Embattled Liberal Party leader John Howard, who had only just returned from a visit to Britain and Israel, was quite open about the fact that he hoped to gain some tips on how to get an anti-Labor government elected in Australia. The core of Thatcher's message was to set the policies and stick to them regardless.

The first expression of this has been the new immigration policy of the Liberal/National coalition. Howard announced that if elected the coalition would restrict Asian immigration to ensure 'social harmony'. This policy shift ends the twenty . year old bi-partisan, non-racial immigration policy created after the abolition of the WhiteAustralia policy in 1966.

The change has split the Coalition. National Party leaders lan Sinclair and John Stone were quick to jump in and stress the need to 're-orient' (sic) Australia's migration to Europe and end Asian immigration. Five Liberal backbenchers (wets who had been sacked by Howard from the frontbench) crossed the floor to vote with the goverment while two others abstained, and alternate leader Andrew Peacock conveniently absented himself from the chamber.

None of this has fazed Howard, whose reputation now rides on successfully putting the racist policy to the electorate at the next election. But Howard faces other problems.

Some journalists and editors have declared war on Howard's leadership of the Liberals over this issue. Some of this comes from embarrassment about Australia's racist history both towards the Aborigines and towards Asia. But more crucial to sections of the ruling class is the need to integrate the Australian economy with the new industrialising countries of Asia, such as South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore and on a different level Japan, which Howard threatens.

Under Hawke, Labor has already altered immigration quotas, reducing those of refugees and family Wednesday 2 November University College London S meeting: 'Where we stand'. "wd Wednesday 2 November Middlesex Poly SO meeting: we stand. 1pm.

Saturday 5 November Socialist Conference 'Trade Union Solidarity Conference'. Leeds Trades Council Club. Starts 9am, fee E2 to J Seymour, 3 Hill St, Barnoldswick, Colne, Lancs.

Sunday 6 November SSiN Conference: 'Fight for the right to study'. PCL, Marylebone Road 12 noon.

Monday 7 November Nottingham SO meeting: "The struggle for socialism'. Int'l Comm. Ctr., Mansfield Road, 7.30 pm Monday 7 November West London SO meeting: 'Ar Jews and Socialism'. Hammer reunion, and increasing business and skills migration in a bid to appease anti-migrant sentiment. The going so far as to specifically target Asian immigration.

But the assumption is that increasing the business and skills quota of migrants will reduce the intake from Asia is extraordinary ignorant.

Figures produced by the OECD in a survey of Newly Industrialising Countries (NICs) show the fallacy of this view.

In 1980 Korea was producing twice as many university level engineering graduates as West Germany. At levels below first university degree as many engineering students were graduating from Korean institutions as in the UK, West Germany and Sweden combined. And the numbers have increased since then.

The NICs' industrial dynamism has pushed them into higher technology. In 1985 the second and third most important imports into the OECD from the NICs were electrical machinery, apparatus and appliances. The sale of capital goods is also going ahead at a fast rate.

Between 1973 and 1985, the growth of manufactured imports by OECD countries from the NICs. grew at an annual rate of 17.8%. But, within that total figure, metal working machinery grew by 37.3%, general industrial machinery by 35.6%, professional instruments by 27.4%, power-generating equipment by 28.6% and specialised machinery by 24.3%.

When 'Manufactured Value Added' (MVA) is measured the performance is more remarkable. From 1973 to 1983 MVA in the NICs grew Town Hail, 8.00 pm Thursday 10 November Northampton SO meeting: 'Stalinism' with Geoff Warg Queens Road, 7.15 pm Saturday 12 November SO AGM. Manchester Saturday 19 November 'Time to Go' conference on Ireland Camden Centre, Bidborough St, WC1. E5 to Clare Short MP (TTG), House of Commons, London SW1 Saturday 19 November Nottingham SO weekend. Discussions, walks, good food.

Hollinsclough, White Peak District. £12 waged, £6 unwaged: contact Ivan or Rosey 0602 624827 Sunday 20 November North East London SO meeting: Fighting Imperialism: Under Whose Flag?' with Clive Bradley. Lucas Arms, Grays Inn Road, 7.30 pm Thursday 24 November Northampton SO meeting: 'The Today' with Clive Bradley.

Queens Road, 7.15 pm Saturday 26 November Socialist Conference day school 'Socialism and Democracy'. Civ Centre, Newcastle. Contact Tes Gray, 4 Normanton Terrace, Elswick, Newcastle-on-Tyne Saturday 26 November CHD Foco UV PHONE DUY PHONG THỰC PHAM hel at 5.3%: (This figure includes Mexico and Brazil which brings the average down). Korea grew at 11.3%. The only OECD country to average above 2% was Japan at 5.8%. Australia declined by 0.9% while the UK went backwards at an annual rate of 2.9%.

While Australia is running an annual balance of payments deficit of $11 billion, the four NICs last year turned in a surplus of $40 billion.

All this only highlights the bind Howard has put himself in. Opinion polls are showing that up to 70% want some form of immigration controls imposed and Howard is now playing his part in whipping up hysteria.

In fact over the past twenty years only 2% of the immigration intake has come from Asia. In attempting to apppeal to the racist undercurrent that exists in Australia Howard nas put his party at odds with important sections of business who want to trade in the region.

The squabbles have not been confined to the coalition. Within the Labour Caucus one backbencher has spoken publicly in favour of the coalition's policy, and the New South Wales Labour Council's radio station has employed the most vocal anti-Asian commentator as its breakfast announcer.

Hawke also follows the polls and is treading warily on the issue, allowing the Coalition to fight in public while hoping to reap the benefit. But unless the Australian Labor Party tackles the issue head on it runs the risk of allowing Howard and the Nationals to appeal directly to many workers who equate the fall in living standards and the continuing high level of unemployment with too high a level of immigration.

Anti-Apartheid Movement Annual Conference. Sheffield Saturday 26 November London Socialist Conference day school on Imperialism. Sir William Collins School, NW1 Monday 28 November London Socialist Forum: "Labour and the Bomb' . Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, WC1, 7.30 pm Saturday 3 December CLPs conference organising meeting Merseyside TUCURC, Hardman St, Liverpool, 12 noon. Contact Lol 051 638 1338 Saturday 10 December London Socialist Organiser day school. Contact Mark 01 639 7967 Saturday 10 December Socialist Conference: conference against the Poll Tax. Newcastle Medical School. Fee £10 (delegate)/E5/E3 to Terry Conway, 10b Windsor Road, London N7 Sunday 11 December North East London SO Social, 7. pm. Contact Belinda 354 3854 Saturday 25 February Women for Socialism 2-day conference. Wesley House, WC1. Saturday 1 April Campaign for Non-Alignment: of NATO, into the world" 2-day c ference

----- pull-quotes -----

Tony Brown reports Sydney

ACTIMISTS" DIARY

Liberals are pressing to alter this balance even further, with Howard

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 378

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →