Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Is the USSR better?

Socialist Organiser no. 378, 3 November 1988 · scan p. 8 · about 1,607 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Eastern Europe todav - Lenin made into an pe today - Lenin made into an icon for a society col public meeting in London with the Iranian group 'Socialism and Revolution' and Socialist Platform' to discuss Reassesing the Eastern Bloc'. It was probably the first time since the 1940s that this question has been discussed seriously among Trotskyists at a level higher than set-piece debates between different factions.

The speaker from Socialism and Revolution' opened the discussion by saying that Trotsky's position -that the USSR was a 'degenerated workers' state' - has three faults.

It is out of date. It is incomplete.

And it is ambiguous.

Marxists have to make our ideas more precise through successive approximations. The USSR is not an open and shut question. Socialist Organiser's contribution could be useful. It is remarkable how on many issues SO and "Socialism and Revolution' have come to similar conclusions independently and from quite different experiences.

Why is Trotsky's formula out of date? 'Degenerated workers' state' leaves a lot out. What degree of degeneration? How much more has the USSR degenerated since Trotsky's death nearly 50 years ago?

How far is it still a workers' state? A concrete analysis is needed.

Trotsky couldn't follow and analyse the degeneration since his death. We must do that. Today you couldn't write about the USSR as Trotsky did in Revolution Betrayed' talking about the progressiveness of the plan and how the USSR has achieved great advances while capitalism has stagnated.

Why is Trotsky's formula incomplete? It did not contain an adequate analysis of the transition to socialism. We need to reformulate our understanding of this transition.

Why is Trotsky's formula ambiguous? The term 'political revolution' has been interpreted by some Trotskyists to mean that there is no exploitation in the USSR. But there is exploitation! Some Trotskyists are opposed to overthrowing the state in the USSR, and say they want to revive the soviets - ie the revolution should be limited. But Poland shows that the workers' stritical resution. struggle beyond merely Is the USSR more advanced than capitalism, and closer to socialism than for example the USA? No! These societies are not more advanced' than Western capitalism.

Is 'the plan' progressive? What about the needs of the producers? Whose needs does the plan serve?

These notions allow for anti-working class interpretations. We should clean our house.

What did Trotsky mean by saying the USSR is transitional? The working class had been defeated in USSR and on a world scale. But capitalism was in its epoch of decline, and so the fate of the USSR was not decided yet. Thus it was a 'transitional society Now maybe we can still speak of a transitional epoch. But we can't equate a society with that. A society in transition to socialism requires the working class in power - otherwise there is no movement towards socialism. Nationalisation alone is not a measure of movement towards socialism.

So the USSR is not a workers"

What is it? We need concrete collective thinking, debate. We shouldn't jump to dogmatic new positions. As an algebraic formula, suggest "bureaucratised state'.

Some say it must be either a workers' state or a bourgeois state. That's a simplification. You can have peculiar, not fully-fledged, temporary states.

Al Richardson spoke from 'Socialist Platform'. He found the term *bureaucratised state' tautological and unhistorical. But we should reassess the USSR. Can a crisis go on for 70 years? Can a counter-revolutionary workers' state spread as the USSR has done? Can workers' states result from peasant guerrilla warfare?

Nationalisation can't be the criteria. If it was a question of degree of state ownership then ancient Egypt was a workers' state.

Engels and Lenin explained that a workers' state is a 'bourgeois state without a bourgeoisie'. A workers state defends public property but still property. That's a dialectical formulation.

John O'Mahony spoke from Socialist Organiser. We're talking here about what socialism is. We're against wage slavery, we're against the tyranny of the British state. We're for liberating the workers. Yet many socialists think that the USSR is nearer to socialism than Britain - the USSR where workers are exploited and state tyranny is much worse than in Britain.

They believe that a nationalised economy - even ruled by a bureaucracy - is an advance on capitalism and is in some sense working class.

For socialists, nationalisation is a means to an end. If you have a totalitarian state, you don't achieve the end.

What was Trotsky's position? In 1928 Trotsky said that the USSR was a workers' state because a reformable workers' party ruled it. Later, he analysed an evolving social organism. The USSR was no longer reformable, but it had a fully nationalised economy which depended on the workers' revolution. A political revolution was needed - something profound and thorough - but, with capitalism in decay, the USSR represented the future (said Trotsky) because of its economic expansion, made possible by statisation.

In 1939, Trotsky accepted the theoretical possibility that the USSR might be a new class society. But he said, as it might well be on the eve of its overthrow, it would be ridiculous to call it a stable new society.

Trotsky was killed. By 1945, the USSR had created an empire with 80 million people in it. Instead of analysing this situation, Trotskyists hung onto a dogma.

Then in Yugoslavia, China, Vietnam, Cuba, etc, Stalinists overthrew the bourgeoisie and created also totalitarian regimes (varying in degree). In China for example, the Maoists were conquerors of the workers. They suppressed all liberty.

By the mid-50s there was a nationalised economy in China. They'd created as much as remained of the Russian revolution. But it makes no sense to say this was a workers' state.

Look at the themes of the modern Trotskyists. Many recognise that the Stalinist bureaucracies create their own societies. This is a fact. We have had an epoch of Stalinism. The bureaucracy creates the nationalised economies, not the working class. Even if you use the workers' state label, a new society is being described.

According to Trotsky ruling bureaucracy was in agonising contradiction to the nationalised economy. To talk of a 'workers' state' where the bureaucracy creates the nationalised economy is to make 'workers' state' just a 'tag' for a new-class society — and to say that new society is progressive.

We should slough off the workers' state label, adopt a clear programme for workers's liberty, and open a serious discussion.

Several tendencies contributed to the discussion from the floor.

Kate Ford from Workers' Power argued that we should defend statification and planning in the USSR. If capitalists plan, they do it for profit, but the USSR's planning is different. Nothing basic has changed since Trotsky's time.

Defend SO says to workers in the Stalinist states that there's nothing to defend - the west has higher living standards and free trade unions.

But in fact higher living standards in Britain are due to our imperialism. Our bourgeoisie superexploits workers in imperialised nations. Imperialism is a form of monopoly capitalism. It holds no real benefits for the international proletariat and must be smashed.

Ray Ferris from Socialist Organiser said that our •basic criterion, our compass must be the working class. Are they free to organise? Can they have political independence? Nationalisation is only a means to an end.

Trotsky said it would be foolish and premature to dub the bureaucracy a new class in 1939. But it's foolish after 48 years to say nothing has changed!

Tom Cashman said he was a supporter of Socialist Organiser who still held to the 'degenerated and deformed workers' states thesis. But he rejected the versions of 'defence of the USSR' argued by most Trotskyists.

We cannot say: defend the Soviet Union by nuking western workers. That sort of 'defencism' is rubbish. No to the bureaucrats' bomb!

We are for Solidarnosc. We are always with the workers, however backward, against the bureaucracy.

Clive Bradley said that he used to think the main alternatives to the •degenerated and deformed workers' states' formula created more problems than they solved. But is fact the problem entailed in saying that the USSR, China etc are workers' states is much bigger than the problem of calling them bureaucratic collectivist or state capitalist. Look at Workers' Power on Afghanistan for example. Their opposition to Russian withdrawal is based not on an assessment of the enciatu interests of Afghan masses but on a view of the world divided into progressive and reactionary 'camps' Independent working class politics disappears.

Shachtmanites - or Hefferites.

In the USSR there is full employment and cheap housing. There is something to defend in the USSR - distorted, hampered, hindered and wrecked though it is. SO makes a lot of the industrial development of South Korea, Taiwan, etc. but these are semi-colonies of USA and Japan. They are not independent.

Calcutta SO's is an Anglo-American standpoint. Look at the workers' gains in the USSR from the standpoint of the poor of Calcutta, and you appreciate them more.

François from Lutte Ouvriere said that he welcomed a lot of the arguments. His tendency had been raising the problems since 1945.

But some comrades are going too far. Trotsky never justified the term 'workers' state' , he explained it. Trotsky was addressing those who had supported the Russian revolution and saying this workers' state was not what it should be. If the working class makes a revolution, the state that comes from that is a

----- pull-quotes -----

ast Wednesday. 26 L October. Socialist Organiser co-sponsored a

Alistair Greene from the Spar- tacist League said that SO were

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 378

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →