USA: the Thatcherite future that doesn't work
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Whoever wins the US the same people will figures. Those who have a home are crammed into desperate, desolate slums, bleaker by far than the poorest city areas in Britain. In the city of El Paso — a major city, not a remote rural area — 25,000 people have no running water, and 53,000 no sewers.
In the rich, booming city of Los Angeles, the rent for the cheapest housing in the cheapest areas is about 70% of the income of a minimum-wage worker. So two, three or four families have to share a single flat.
Shift workers share beds, one sleeping while the other works. At least 200,000 people live in garages, usually without any plumbing or heat.
Average real wages in the US have been stagnating or declinin since the early 1970s. Even in Thatcher's Britain, trade unions have been able to keep wage rises ahead of inflation. But in the US, only about 15% of workers are now in trade unions.
All other things being equal, unionised workers' wages are about 30% higher than non-union workers'; but most workers are not in trade unions.
The steady shift of industry from the North-East to the South and West has weakened the unions. On top of that, many employers have broken unions with a ruthlessness which makes Rupert Murdoch look genteel by comparison.
In Los Angeles in recent years, for example, the union which organised janitors in the city centre has been smashed - and wages cut from $13 to $3.50 an hour.
Texas Air, the world's biggest airline, started off by putting its subsidiary Continental Airlines into bankruptcy to clear out the unions, and then went on to halve the pay of workers in the Eastern Airlines subsidiary.
Inequality! The top 20% of American households get nearly ten times the average income of the bottom 20%. The top 20% are on around $100,000 a year; the bottom 20% on $10,000.
Even in Thatcher's Britain the gap is much smaller — the top 20% getting about six times as much as the bottom 20%. In the Netherlands, for example, the ratio is four-and-a-half to one.
Insecurity! In the US, as nowhere else in the advanced capitalit world, almost any worker can be sacked at a moment's notice. A recent Bill in Congress requiring companies to give workers a few weeks' notice if they closed a factory was vetoed by President Reagan as an intolerable interference with free enterprise.
Even comparatively well-off American workers can suddenly be thrown into an abyss. And unemployment in America is an abyss. Only about a third of the unemployed get any benefit; it's not very much, and after six months most unemployed workers get nothing at all.
If they can't find a new job -and when unemployment for young Blacks in big cities is around 50%, that's hard - they have to beg, steal...or die. No wonder crime rate in the US are so high.
Deaths through violence in the US's big cities run at 5, 10 or 20 times the rate in Northern Ireland On the mainly Black Southside of Los Angeles, the drug dealing gangs kill an average of one person a day. Many people in US cities are afraid to walk on the streets or use the underground railway.
Another abyss threatens US workers, too: illness. Thirty one million people in the US have no health insurance at all. Many millions of others have insurance Racism! Some apologists capitalism tell us that because money is colour-blind, SO capitalism is, too. The best sort of racial equality is equality in the market, and do-gooding socialist reform and legislation can only be counterproductive meddling. That's what they say.
In fact capitalism always seizes on divisions in the working class to create pools of low-wage labour — women, black people, immigrants.
Capitalists have to Jay their qualified, experienced 'core' workers more than a miserable minimum; but then they want low-paid labour for temporary, casual, part-time or ancillary work. Divisions in the working class help them get what they want.
And SO it is in the US's free-market economy. 337 of Blacks live in poverty as against 11% of whites. 46% of Black children live n poverty. The average income o hite families is $32,000: of Blac families, $18,000Where Blacks have made some limited gains in the US, it has been thanks to political action winning legislation, not to the wonders of the market economy. The civil rights movement of the 1960s did break down segregation and open the way for more Black people to professional jobs, and that was a gain.
Some Blacks have gained - but only a few. While a few Blacks have prospered, the great majority have been beaten down by America's gradual decay. The proportion of black men with an income of over $25,000 and the proportion below $5,000 have both increased.
Between 1970 and 1987, the number of Black mayors in US cities rose from 48 to 303. But the poverty and the misery of Black workers in those cities has increased too.
Repression! "Greed is all right. I want you to know that. I think greed is healthy. You can be greedy and still feel good about it. Ivan Boesky, author of these famous words, got caught out with his stock-market swindles. But his creed lives on.
Freedom, in capitalist America, means above all free scope for the greed of the rich - and short shrift for anyone who gets in their way.
The US has six times as many people in prison, in proportion to population, as the Netherlands. Half the people in prison are Black, though Blacks are only 12% of America's population. Alone among advanced capitalist countries, the US uses the death penalty regularly.
Unequal
The US's system of punishment is brutal - and grossly unequal. No rich people ever face the death penalty there; if you're rich enough to pay the legal fees, your lawyer will get you off.
In Los Angeles a privately-owned jail offers itself as an alternative to the public jail for rich convicts; if they jib at the prices, the jail owners explain in their advertisements that going to the public jail means almost certainly getting raped by another prisoner.
In its vindictive brutality towards the poor, the US today is more like 18th century England than a modern democracy. The rulers of 18th century England saw the poor in their cities as a "criminal class" and tried to deal with it by deporting as many as it could to Australia.
Likewise, in cities like Los Angeles today, the powers that be see the people who live on the streets, and the jobless Black youth, as a criminal class — and many ot them have demanded, publicly and seriously, that this "criminal class" should be deported en masse to remote rural areas of the US.
This proposal for deportation has even been backed by the left wing of official US politics - the *Democratic Socialists of America" , a grouping within the Democratic Party. A former leader of the Black Panther Party, now a university professor, chimes in: there is nothing to be done about Black youth caught up in drugdealing except to lock them away. *They're just not going to make it."
The terrible strain and insecurity of life in capitalist America - and the utter hopelessness of it for so many millions - leads people to seek consolation in religion or drugs. In New York State alone, there are 97,000 children under 16 who are "heavy drug abusers" -and fewer than 150 spaces for them in publicly-financed residential drug treatment projects.
Drugs like cocaine are killing thousands of people - though not nearly as many as alcohol does. Feuding and violence in the vast illegal drugs trade kills many more. No politician, bar a few mavericks, has any answer except to bellow for stricter enforcement of anti-drugs laws.
Liberal
The most damning thing that George Bush can find to say about Michael Dukakis is that Dukakis is "a liberal" — and it's an accusation that Dukakis finds damaging. Where else in the world apart from the US is "liberal" a dirty word? The one-party states, South Africa, and nowhere else much.
Where else could a presidential candidate boost himself by appearing on a platform surrounded by uniformed police, as Bush has done? Where else, apart from the USSR, would a previous job as head of the secret police by a qualification for top office? In Bush's 1980 campaign for the Republican nomination, his supporters used to chant enthusiastical-