Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Israel polarises at the polls

Socialist Organiser no. 378, 3 November 1988 · scan p. 5 · Clive Bradley · about 822 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

•hoever wins tne ele tion in Israel, it won't make much difference. Neither party is in favour of allowing the Palestinian people the right to their own state.

The Labour Party, led by Shimon Peres, talks more about peace and international conterences; the Likud of Yitzhak Shamir is dead set against giving an inch of "land for peace' . But they are both against recognising the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) of Yasser Arafat, despite the obvious fact that the overwhelming majority of Palestinians see the PLO as their representative.

Whoever wins will not win outright. The 1984 election produced a Knesset (parliament) split down the middle. Eventually Labour and Likud had to divide the spoils in a bizarre governmental job-share.

Both are anxious to avoid run of the la st four years, but so will need to patch up deals with the minority parties. Labour Likud will be looking for deals with far-right religious parties.

The most extreme right-wing party, Meir Kahane's Kach, has been banned for racism. But there are plenty of other parties that are bly slightly less fanatical.

The Labour Party is not similar to the Labour Party in Britain. It is not essentially a party of organised labour: in fact, it is the party of the Establishment.

European Jewish immigrants, many of whom saw themselves as socialists, occupied all the dominant positions in the state when Israel was founded in 1948. Jews from North Africa and other Arab countries ('Oriental' Jews) were recruited to the new state as its workers. Arabs, of course, were at the very bottom of the pile (and Arabs from the occupied territories in 1967 even lower).

The right owes its support to three factors. First, it appeals to Jewish workers who see Arab labour as competition by its hard *anti-Arab' stand. Second, it campaigns on social issues that affect Oriental Jews. Third, it combines this with anti-Labour (ie. antiEstablishment, anti-middle class) rhetoric.

If Labour does well in this election it will be despite factors working against it. The Israeli population is increasingly 'Oriental' (one reason for Labour's decline) and Labour has failed to break into the Likud vote. Its traditional Arab vote is naturally very dissatisfied: Labour's one Arab MP split this year to form his own party.

The issue in this election is peace - more than at any time in the past as a result of the Palestinian intifada, or uprising, which is approaching its anniversary. And although the general shift in Israel seems to be rightwards, a great soul-searching is also taking place. Top generals on the Labour side want to give the West Bank and Gaza (or both of them) to the Arabs that live there.

Some parties to the left of Labour will win seats. Mapam (left Labour Zionist) and Ratz (Citizens' Rights Movement) are radical within the framework of what is sometimes called the 'national consensus'. They may be able to act as coalition partners for Peres.

The Communist Partydominated Democratic Front for Peace and Equality and the ArabJewish Progressive List for Peace both offer a two-states solution. The PLP includes both socialists and maverick left Zionists like Uri Avnery. The DPFE is very pro-Moscow and the dominant political force in Arab towns like Nazareth.

The far-right is certainly stronger than the far-left, but whether Shamir can (or will) do wide-ranging deals with them to form a coalition remains to be seen.

Although the election itself will not result in big changes, the current crisis in Israel certainly will. Out of the deep shifts in opinion amongst Israelis, a genuinely radical alternative to Labour may emerge. The intifada will not die away: sooner or later Israel will have to find a road to peace. them in court.

The medieval monarchs used to pull down the castles of their defeated enemies to prevent these becoming future bastions of resistance to their rule. The goverment is adopting a similar policy with the institutions of the unwritten constitution of this country that have acted as a restraint on central power. After trade unions, local goverment, editorial freedom in broadcasting and the press, the artillery is now pounding at the central keep of the criminal law.

While some socialists might wonder why any part of the criminal law is worth defending the answer is that this part of the criminal law is simply a reflection of past historical struggle and the fact that there were some areas of independence from the state that the law. was not able to eliminate. Resistance to this impertinent arrogation of power has a long historical precedent, and is vital if there is to be any barrier to the encroachment of the state on the liberty of the individual.

If the state can prove your guilt by your failing to answer any questions it may pose of you, there is no logical limit to what it can and will demand of you in the future.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 378

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →