Why is Thatcher against Europe?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-11-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
The aim of workers' democracy and liberty was replaced with the drive to industrialise and to consolidate a privileged elite.
Gorbachev is not Stalin. His reforms are important and we should welcome them. But his project is a million miles away from the Bolsheviks'.
Stalin's command economy could modernise up to a point. Now the economy stagnant. The parody of planning has ceased to work. Bureaucratic corruption and empire building has taken the Russian economy into a cul-de-sac.
Gorbachev wants to change this. He wants to bring in the yardsticks of competitiveness, of profit and loss - the criteria of the West.
This means shaking up the old bureaucratic structures. It means sacking managers and crusades against corruption. It also means some openness for debate and criticism - so that incompetence can be weeded out.
It also means imposing stricter labour discipline on workers. It means job losses, wage cuts, and reducing price subsidies on basic goods. And the 'openness' does not extend to allowing workers to form their own trade unions and political parties.
Gorbachev's reforms should be welcomed in so far as they open up a space for workers to organise. But Gorbachev's is a bureaucrats' programme, not a workers' programme.
To revive the ideals of 1917 workers need al new revolution in Editor: John O'Mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU), 01-358 1344.
Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser.
Child benefit and family allowances in France are about three times as high as in Britain.
Unemployment benefit in Denmark is much higher than in Britain, and is paid for much longer. Italy has many more public holidays, more trade union rights, and more nurseries.
These are the facts which explain Mrs Thatcher's opposition to closer European unity.
Many Euro-capitalists are ready to run the risk of workers demanding a "Social Europe" through levelling-up for the sake of the benefits of a wider market and greater mobility of capital. Mrs Thatcher thinks differently.
She sees Britain's future as an off-shore economy, with decidedly lower wages and social provision than continental Europe and attractive to multinational investors for that reason. She also relies on Britain's links to the US, where British capitalists have much bigger investments than the capitalists of other EEC countries.
So Thatcher is against a "Social Europe", and against any moves for closer EEC unity which could lead to a "Social Europe". And the political debate on the EEC 1s swinging round through 180 degrees.
In the 1970s the EEC was, or appeared to be, a left/right issue. When Britain entered the EEC in 1972, the left was against it; when a referendum was held on it in 1975, the left was for withdrawal. The champions of the EEC were the Tories and the Labour rightwingers who were later to form the SDP.
Now Thatcher's is the loudest voice in British politics against closer EEC unity; and almost the whole of the labour movement and the left has dropped the idea of pulling Britain out of the EEC.
At the left-Labour conference called by Tribune two weeks ago, for example, scarcely a single voice was raised against the idea that we muct accept the EEC as an arena within which to fight, and that we must fight for the best possible "Social Europe" for the workers.
It is a left/right issue again - but now the left is "for Europe" anc the right is "against"
The EEC is one of those questions where going by left-wing conventional wisdom and common sense is no good at all. In truth it was never a clear left/right issues. There was always a strong strand of right-wing Tory nationalism, of the Daily Express type, in the anti-EEC lobby.
When the Tories first proposed Britain should enter the EEC, in 1961, the Marxist left saw the matter clearly enough. "In or out, the fight goes on" , they said.
Capitalism "in one country" is not viable in the modern world. Europe's capitalists need to try to create a larger economic unit. It is no business of socialists to help them do that; but is is equally none of our business to champion an "independent" capitalist Britain. Our alternative to the capitalist EEC is not little Britain but a Socialist United Europe.
Every tendency on the Marxist left saw it that way. But then nationalist and insular feeling against the EEC increased - not so much among capitalists, who care very little for nationalism when there are profits to be made, as in the working class.
And, one by one, every tendency on the Marxist left, with the sole exception of the tendency continued today by Socialist Organiser, capitulated to that nationalist feeling and started finding "Marxist " reasons for preferring "independent" capitalist Britain to the capitalist EEC Insularity and cost the working class dear. The labour movement has been in nationalist blinkers while the capitalists are already planning and scheming on a European and international level.
In the 1980s, steel industries have been run down drastically all across Europe, in line with a commonlyagreed EEC line. Steelworkers fought back. But they fought back in a scattered way, one country after another - first British steelworkers, then French steel workers, then German steelworkers.
There was no Europeán steelworkers' strategy. Striking French steelworkers blocked railway lines to keep out German steel. The capitalists were united; the workers were divided.
Now the EEC Commission and the Council of Ministers are working out their plans for 1992, when all customs barriers within the EEC are supposed to be abolished and a "single market" created. The elected European Parliament has little control over the EEC Commission and none at all over the Council of Ministers.
Yet instead of campaigning for the European Parliament to have real powers, and for the workers" parties from all over Europe to unite on working class demands, many socialists in Britain have made it a left-wing badge of honour to abstain from anything to do with the Euro-Parliament! It is as if they believe that ignoring international capitalism will make it go away.
Every evening now on the television, business people tell us that they are preparing for 1992. It's time the labour movement started preparing seriously, too - to win a "Social Europe" by way of leveling-up, to demand that the best conditions won anywhere in the EEC are extended everywicas Lore in the EEC, and to fight for a Socialist United Europe.