The State against the workers
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
In Secialist Organiser no.371 we spened a discussion on the nature of the bureaucratic statemonopoly societies of the Eastern Bloc.
We never thought these societies were socialist. In the past we have subscribed to the thesis - which has been "orthodox" Trotskyism since 1951 - that their nationalised economies define them as "degenerated and deformed workers' states". But that thesis looked increasingly unviable; we need to examine the idea that these state-monopoly societies are new exploiting class societies, not superior to capitalism but essentially parallel to it the development of the forces of production.
How did these statised economies develop? What different forms can they take? This discussion article by Martin Thomas reviews some of the factual Troops try to hold back a protest in Yugoslavia evidence.
Since. Th met capitalit ince 1945 the role of the where. In most capitalist countries, however, state spending is mostly on the military and on public services. The state usually plays a secondary role in investment, having only a 15%-30% share in the total. *The public sector in most developing countries," however, "accounts for...some 50-60% of total investment."(1) The role of the state in Third World economies varies. Some countries have strong private capitalist classes: Mexico and India are examples. In India, public sector investment rose to 60% of the total under the Third Five-Year Plan (1961-66) and is still more than 50% now.(2) An Indian Marxist comments:
*The trend towards state capitalism, true in general for the advanced capitalist countries in the 20th century, manifested itself with particular keenness in the underdeveloped countries after they became formally independent in the post-Second World War period....The government just could not leave the matter in the hands of individual capitalists because, first, they were ill-equipped for those investments that were essential but least paying, particularly in the short run and, secondly, they lacked, in general, funds, initiative and experience.
*In other words, those segments of the economy that needed huge investment, modern and sophisticated technology and a long gestation period before being able to provide a strong base for massive industrialisation were brought under the direct of the state. Hence in almost all underdeveloped countries the government, irrespective of the particular ideology' it professed, took a significant part in the functioning and controlling of the economy."(3)
India remains relatively pluralist; but the pattern of a one-party state: mass organisations controlled by that party; Five-Year Plans; and a heavy state role in the economy applies to Third World governments which are vocally pro-capitalist. Two examples are Tunisia and the Ivory Coast.
In Tunisia state-owned enterprises account for 60% of value added in manufacturing.(4) In the Ivory Coast 61% of investment is by the public sector.(5) The state controls marketing of agricultural produce. It owns the biggest plantations and ancillary factories. Its share of total industrial capital rose from 10% in 1976 to 53% in 1980. Almost all the rest of industry is foreien capital operating under detailed conditions imposed by the state. Researchers could find only Five Ivorians who could be described as private industrial capitalists.
The state plays a qualitatively bigger role in countries where the present regime was established through a revolution sweeping out the old rulers.
In Algeria the FLN (National Liberation Front) took power in 1962 after a long and bloody war for independence from France. Most of industry and large-scale agriculture had been owned by the French state, or by European settlers, who quit. Workers took over many enterprises and estates. The new regime moved in to nationalise and establish state control.
By 1968-9 the government controlled foreign trade, banking, and most major industry. The takeover of oil and gas — now the country's major earners — was completed by 1971. FLN political control was also made complete. The previously independent though sympathetic trade union federation, the UGTA, was brought under government In 1967-9 the public sector made 92% of industrial investment. In 1986 its share was estimated at 95%; another estimate, for 1978-81, gave state-owned enterprises (that is, not including the government's own projects) 68% of investment in 1978-81(7)
The private sector continued to include a lot of small-scale enteprise. In 1983 it employed 33% of the workforce, including agriculture.(8)
A tremendous drive was launched to build up heavy industries and "In the USSR major industry was nationalised in 1918 - not by a middle-class group seek ing national economic development but by the worker's government put into power by the workers' revolution of October 1917."
modern technology.' "The landscape looked like a vast building yard."(9) 60% of agriculture is in state farms, and the state has a monopoly on buying agricultural produce; the prices are set low by decree so as to siphon surplus value into industry.(10)
Until the early '80s, all state company profits went direct to the government, and all investment was financed by state credits. Since then state enterprises have been allowed to keep some of their profits. All their investment projects are controlled by the state banks and the supervising ministries. All prices are theoretically subject to state control, though - apart from agricultural and food prices - not all in fact are controlled.
Despite strict controls on paper, in practice, it is said, "The central political power's control over the (state) corporations is very loose." Foreign capital is quite active in Algeria, under deals arranged with the state.(11)
An Algerian Marxist comments on the regime: "The omnipotence of the state, the overwhelming weight of the superstructure in relation to the infrastructure, is itself a fundamental class fact, quite apart from the goals of the state's actions... When the simplest of problems, at whatever level of social life, needs in order to deal with it a formal procedure, haggling, an administrative decision; when the press, publishing and cinema are only state monopolies run by officials concerned above all to consondate their privileges; when the unions are only transmission belts of the single party, which itself is only an annexe of the State, all questions are overshadowed by the basic one: the total domination of society by the Here the State is more than a powerful agency and partner of the private profiteers.
*The State domination which here precedes, protects and accompanies the development of capitalist exploitation cannot be considered as an episode of that development, leading at the next stage to a liberalisation, or 'Sadatisation' to take the example of Egypt, but is the basic characteristic of this development...
"Here is no longer a question of a State which provisionally administers the interests of the dominant classes, but of a structure which partially substitutes itself for them...There is no point looking behind this State for a dominant class which is using it, as...in France.... A fraction of that dominant class, to be precise the state bureaucratic fraction which is also the hegemonic fraction, only exists through and thanks to the As well as the countries where there was a foreign bourgeoisie, or virtually no bourgeoisie, before the state took control of the economy, there are also ones where bourgeoisie existed and was ousted by revolution: Yugoslavia, China, Cuba, and others. China between 1958 and 1978, Yugoslavia in 1948-50 and partially to 1955, and Cuba from the early '60s to now, all followed the economic model of Stalin's USSR, whether closely or less so. What is that model?
In the USSR major industry was nationalised in 1918 - not by a middle-class group seeking national economic development but by the workers' government put into power by the workers' revolution of October 1917. From 1918 to 1921 the economy was run on a makeshift basis of 'war communism' , without planning but without normally functioning markets either. Goods were requisitioned and allocated according to immediate availability and immediate need.
From 1921 to 1928 the market was the chief regulator. A state planning organisation, Gosplan, was set up in April 1921, but outside key sectors of heavy industry the nationalised enterprises generally guided themselves by the market. Private enterprise was given wide scope in trade.
In the 1930s a centralised command economy was imposed by the Stalinist bureaucracy which had usurped power from the workers. Peasants were herded into statecontrolled farms. Private traders were banned. All trade union independence was crushed, and total domination of society by the state bureaucracy established.
Enterprises now received detailed instructions from central government about how many workers they would have, what wages they would pay, what inputs they would receive, and what outputs they must produce. Prices were also decreed by central government. It was like a war economy, only more detailed and permanent.
The command system never quite snuffed out money and market forces. Workers were paid wages and had to buy what they needed on the market, free markets in food and various black and grey markets played a big role. The command system did, however, make the USSR's economy operate differently from a market system in many ways. It grew very fast in the '30s and '50s, but in a lopsided way. In the 1980s it has grown very slowly.
This is the system which Gorbachev is trying to reform by shifting enterprises towards making profits on a market where prices move fairly freely and investing out of their profits or money borrowed at interest. Some attempted reforms along Gorbachev's lines were introduced in the early 1960s but did not get very far. Gorbachev's programme is still at an early stage.
Other 'command economies" have, however, changed substan"As well as the countries where there was a foreign bourgeoisie, or virtually no bourgeoisie, before the state took control of the economy, there are also ones where a bourgeoisie existed and was ousted by revolution." tially. Yugoslavia scrapped all detailed plan directives for enterprises in 1955, and has decentralised more and more since then. Central government there now spends only 6% of national income.
Yugoslavia is still a nationalised economy. In 1983, 83% of all output and 95% of industrial output came from state-owned enteprises. But each of those enterprises is run by a management committee elected by the workers and more or less free to pursue maximum profit for the enterprise and maximum income for the workers.
Surveying the price structures of 31 underdeveloped countries, the World Bank found that Yugoslavia's was one of the least "distorted' by subsidies, controls and decrees.
Some features of the command economy' remain. A loss-making
Scan page 9
enterprise does not generally close down; it just gets more in debt and it may have a temporary manager appointed from above. Conversely, a successful enterprise cannot take over and asset-strip other enterprises.
The hallmarks of a market economy are there too. "The ability to grapple with factors external to the success of the individual enterprise and small region has disappeared," comments Granick. "The Yugoslav economy is run along Adam Smith (free market) lines to a degree that is quite unusual for Europe as a whole." Yugoslavia has roaring inflation and high unemployment made higher because it is in the interest of each enterprise to keep its workforce small.
Yugoslavia is extremely open to the world economy, exporting 30% of its production, and 54% of that outside Eastern Europe. In 1985 it had 187 joint ventures with Western capitalists, and seven Free Trade Zones in which multinationals can do business free of usual tariffs and formalities.(14)
China has moved towards a market economy almost as far as Yugoslavia.
Some other East European economies also show paths away from the Stalinist model.
In Hungary, plan directives to enterprises from central government were scrapped in 1968. The economy has been made much more open to the world market. Exports increased from 19% of output in 1966 to 40% in 1986; the proportion going outside Eastern Europe increased from 34% to 51% (1983). Hungary, like some other Eastern European states, has joined the IMF (in 1982) and borrowed heavily from Western banks.
On paper, Hungary is almost as market-orientated as Yugoslavia. Most prices have been freed. Enterprises are supposed to aim for profits and to find money for investment from profits and bank loans at interest.
In tact, bureaucratic stringpulling still plays a big role. Bargaining with central government over taxes and subsidies is as important for enterprise bosses as commercial profit. A study in 1982 found that loss-making firms engineered subsidies to cover their losses; firms making big profits got them taken in tax - so that there was almost no relation between profits after tax and profits before tax.
Market mechanisms have flourished in Hungary not so much in the official economy as in the semi-legal or illegal second economy'. . Officially only 7% of industrial output comes from private enterprise. In fact maybe 70% of Hungarian workers have second jobs in the 'second economy'. . Two-thirds of all dwellings are built by the second economy'. As in Poland, the visibly rich of Hungarian society, with their BMWs and Mercedes, are private capitalists.(15)
In a recent article in the New York Review of Books, Timothy Garton Ash raises the idea that the main benefit of economic reform' for Hungary's rulers may be to create a private capitalist class which will back them against workers' revolt. "Capitalists and Communists united against the workers" — is that what the future holds? (1) World Bank World Development Report (WB WDR) 1983, p.48 (2) P Chattopadhyay, State Capitalism in India, Monthly Review March 1970; Financial Times 18.2.85 (3) Chattopadhyay (4) In 1978-81. WB WDR 1983, p.51* (5) In 1980-5. WB WDR 1988, p.47 (6) H S Marcussen & J E Torp, Internationalisation of Capital (7) T Benhouria, L'economie de l' Algerie, pp. 256-8; J P Entelis, Algeria: the revolution institutionalised, p. 128; WB WDR 1983, p.49 (8) R Tlemcani, State and Revolution in Algeria, p.119 (9) Tiemcani, p. 114 (10) ! nialis, p.142; Benhouria, pp.69, 117 (11) Entelis, p. 126; M E Benissad, Economie du development de lAlgerie 1962-82, pp.200, 220; Tlemcani, p. 161; Benhouria, p.228 (12) Benhouria, p.330 (13) Benhouria, p.430 (14) F Singleton & B Carter, The Economy of Yugoslavia; WB WDR 1983, 1985, 1988; D Granick, Enterprise Guidance in Eastern Europe; A Nove, The Soviet Economy, pp.310-314; Wall Street Journal 4.8.83; Yugoslav Economic Review: Yugosiav National Bank Quarterly Bulletin (15) Financial Times 10.5.83; J Kornai, in G Tidrick and Chen Teform; PHare, H Radice iN Swain, Hungary: China's Industrial A Decade of Economic Reform; L'Alternative, May August 1982.
Last week Bob Fine week Bob queried Socialist Organiser's support for a labour movem boycott of the gover ment's ET scheme.
Mick Cashman replies.
The first half of Bob Fine's article *ET, against the boycott in SO 376 reads like a Department of Employment PR job for the scheme.
The Employment Training Scheme was created as part of the Tory government's strategy to create a low wage economy and to fiddle the unemployment register. It is clearly an attempt to introduce Workfare into Britain.
It is also part of the government's campaign to absolve themselves of any blame for unemployment. It strengthens the myth that the reason people are unemployed is not because there are no jobs but because the unemployed are not trained.
Bob Fine believes that the basic difference between ET and CP is that the money used tor wages on CP is all put into training on ET. Tremendous! Except that he leaves the most important point out.
The CP scheme employed roughly 230,000 people for 12 months each, and formally paid the rate for the job. In fact the overwhelming majority of workers were only part-time working 3 days a week and earning a gross weekly wage of ET on the other hand will employ 600,000 people for 6-12 months, supposedly giving training. It's nearly 3 times as many people as on CP, with the same budget. Where is the money coming from for the training?
The real training element on ET is training a generation of people to expect poverty wages. A single person on supplementary benefit who is under 25 will receive a princely sum of £36 for a 5 day week on ET, £20 less than they would have received for 3 days on CP. It's 16 Tuesday 25 October Leeds SO meeting 'The New Realism Assessed': Leeds University Student Union.
Wednesday 26 October 'Sisters of the Long March': Sheffield Trades & Labour Club. Wednesday 26 October London Socialist Forum, 'Reassessing the Eastern Bloc': Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq 7.30 Thursday 27 October Northampton SO meeting 'the ABC of Marxism' with Ray Ferris: 25 Queens Rd, 7.15 pm.
Thursday 27 October 'Sisters of the Long March': Halifax St Marys Community Centre. Thursday 27 October Merseyside SO 'Ireland - what' the answer?' with Pat Murphy. Friday 28 October 'Sisters of the Long March': Barnsley. Northern College. Saturday 29 October 'Sisters of the Long March: College of Higer Education. Saturday 29 October Sheffield SO day school, Discussions on Eastern Euro ycott ET!
extra hours for a t20 pay cut.
People who are forced onto ET, earning £36 a week are going to be much more likely to take scabby low-paid jobs in non-union sweatshops for £40 or £50 per week. That is the whole idea of ET.
Bob Fine waxes lyrical about the possibilities for training on ET. They could all become beauticians and organic farmers! The reality of course is that 'trainees' will be used 3 days a week for 6 months as farm labourers or sweeping up in hairdressing salons.
Bob urges us to organise a labour movement campaign to kick out the cowboys involved in ET in favour of local authorities and non-profit making agencies. The record of these people with CP does not recommend them too highly as employers responsible for training.
Under CP many local authorities substituted CP workers for real jobs, whether it was DLO work fencing council estates or social services doing the jobs of home helps etc.
The non-profit making charities involved in CP like NACRO and the APEX trust never impressed many of the workers with their caring approach or their formal equal opportunities position - and the fact that they are willing to take part in the repugnant ET scheme does not recommend them as trainers.
Bob also tells us that the unemployed will blame the movement if we don't take part in ET. Where have we heard that one before? On the contrary most unemployed people are completely opposed to ET, as are most CP workers who have experienced the "benefits' of community schemes. A survey done by the Merseyside Unemployed Centre of 1,000 unemployed people showed that 91% of them opposed ET.
On the Wirral, where we have suceeded in unionising CP workers, we could tind only 2 workers who opposed the boycott. The unemployed would have nothing but contempt for a labour and trade union movement who supported ET or allowed it to go ahead without a fight.
Bob tells us that the scheme is unlikely to be made compulsory as long as real training goes on in ET. Tell that to YTS trainees! In fact although the scheme is not yet forWhich way forward for the Labs Left; What is socialism; Debate Workers' Power. All welcome. £2.50 waged £1.25 unwaged. Cheap food available. Sheffield University SU.
Sunday 30 October 'Sisters of the Long March': Huddersfield, St Paul's Poly Monday 31 October West London SO meeting Arabs, Jews and Socialism': Hammersmith Town Hall 8 pm Wednesday 2nd November Lobby of Parliament in support of an Early Day Motion submitted by Chris Mullin calling for an independent review of the Birmingham Six's case. 7.30pm.
Saturday 5 November Socialist Conference, 'Trade Union Solidarity Conference': Leeds Trad Council Club 9 pm. Fee £2 to J Seymour, 3 Hill St, Barnoldswick, Colne, Lancs.
Sunday 6 November SSiN AGM: PCL, Marylebone 12 pm.
Monday 7 November Nottingham SO meeting, 'The Struggle for Socialism': Int'l Comm. Centre 7.30 pm, Mansfield Road. Thursday 10 November Northampton SO meeting 'Stalinism with Geoff Ward. 25 Queens Rd., 7.15 pm.
Saturday mally compulsory, Restart interviews are used to threaten and coerce people onto the scheme.
The availability-for-work' test is available, as Thatcher pointed out, to remove benefit from anybody who objects to working for £10 per week.
Bob also tells us that the boycott was taken as an easy option and that what will happen is that ET will survive in a worse form. The fact is that rank and file trade unionists fought hard within their organisations to make their unions adopt this policy.
It was not the easy option of a bureaucrat, it was achieved by the struggle of CP workers. In my own union, the TGWU, it was only achieved after a hectic campaign.
Is the boycott an easy option?
Can we defeat ET? The boycott will only succeed if it is organised on a grass roots level. We've already started this on the Wirral.
Although our council is controlled by a Tory-SLD coalition, which is supporting the scheme, the three main council unions, the GWU, NALGO and NUPE, have made it clear that they will not allow it to take place on council property. We're organising regular leafletting of retail shops such as Mothercare, and Burtons who plan to use ET labour, asking people not to shop there.
The boycott can work, but it is no easy option. It means forming boycott committees in the localities to make it effective.
JTS was the government's first attempt to bring in Workfare, and it was defeated. The unemployed would not go on the scheme and the trade unionists made sure that JTS was not allowed in their workplaces. JTS was an embarassing flop for the government..
As for the 'good old fashioned protectionism' , am sure that Bob Fine, NATHE and the AUT would welcome ET doing their lecturing jobs in colleges and universities, 3 days a week for their dole money.
ET is a major threat to the wages and conditions of trade unionists.
Occasionally we may find a good scheme here and there. But the aim of the scheme is to lower wages and conditions and destroy the self-respect of the unemployed. It can be defeated, it can't be reformed.
Socialist Organiser AGM. For details contact SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Saturday 19 November 'Time to Go' Conference on Ireland: Camden Centre, Bidborough St, WC1. £5 to Clare Short MP (TTG), House of Commons, London SW1. Saturday 19 November Socialist Organiser: two-day at Hollinsclough: White Peak District. Phone 0602 624827. Sunday 20 November South London SO meeting 'Chile an end to the repression?': The Station Pub, Camberwell New Rd. 7.30 pm Thursday 24 November Northampton SO, The Left Today, Clive Bradley: 25 Queens Rd., 7.1 pm.
Saturday 26 November London Socialist Conference, day school on Imperialism: Sir William Collins School, NW1.
Saturday 26 November Socialist Conference, dayschool on 'Socialism and Democracy': Civic Centre, Newcastle. Details: Tessa Gray, 4 Normanton Terace, Elswich Newcastle-on-Tyne.
Saturday 10 December Socialist Conference - Conference on the Poll Tax Newcastle Medical School: Fee £10 (delegate) £5/E3. to Terry Conway. 10b Windsor Rd, London N7
----- pull-quotes -----
ACTIVISTS" DIARY