Marxism Today: New thoughts ol old rubbish?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Our world is changing, says the Communist Party's magazine Marxism Today. The Old Times of mass production, trade union solidarity and cloth caps are gone forever. New Times require New Politics. Clive Bradley looks beyond the hype. A record, the veck aded Sunday afternoon •Record,' this week added to the chorus of respectable voices proclaiming the novelty and inventiveness of the range of concepts deployed by the 'new Marxists' to analyse contemporary capitalism, with the lone voice of Eric Heffer protesting the claim of these "Marxists' to be on the Left at all.
There can be no doubt that *Marxism Today', which is to say the Communist Party of Great Britain, is very influential — for example with the Labour Party leadership. They have been very successful in portraying themselves as the innovators, and the Left as the "traditionalists', 'fundamentalists' and so on.
The Labour leadership's policy review is publicised SOI the ridiculous basis that old-fashioned socialism has been tested and failed. In fact, it has never been tried. But there is no doubt that much of the traditional Left do appear as 'dinosaurs' while the Marxism Today inspired Right seem to be intellectually stimulating, thoughtful and profound.
Have "Marxism Today' got a point? Robin Murray in October's Marxism Today spells out in detail the characteristics both of the dying "Fordist' era and of the new 'postFordist' one that should shape socialist strategy into the Nineties. Fordism was characterised by mass production: by the huge, modern factory (the model being, of course, Ford motor cars) in which production itself was broken into a series of repetitive actions. What went with this was a process often described as "deskilling" of each worker and mass-scale "collective worker' (formed into industrial unions and so on). With mass production went a market of mass-produced goods limited in variety.
Post-Fordism' has thus seen the decline both of manufacturing on the old model and of the work practices associated with it. Choice and individuality are the new key notes: production is geared to sectional markets, and is designed to change quickly according to shifts in demand.
Along with this is a new kind of worker — less 'class conscious' in the old sense, more likely to be part-time, female and temporary.
Two ideas in particular emerge from this picture: that as a result of fundamental changes in the nature of the working class, socialists can no longer look to outmoded methods of struggle (some thinkers Question the very existence of the working class, but this is not essento the argument); and that socialism itself must take account of the choice, individuality and personal freedom offered by 'postmodern' capitalism. Meting the intellectual and political challenge on these fronts is the precondition for the development of any serious alternative to Thatcherism - which is nothing less than the bourgeoisie's response to postFordism.
The precise political conclusions of this analysis fill out a spectrum, ranging from advocacy of electoral deals between Labour and the Democrats, to a more GLC-style 'rainbow coalition' idea of drawing together the 'new movements' community organisation and enterprise boards.
There can be no doubt that much of what Marxism Today describe is real. Certainly the working class today is different from the working class of the 1950s and '60s, never mind the 1930s or before. Certainly the questions of popular democracy and individual freedoms are ones the Left needs to address.
But so much of what Murray and others say is flimsy in the extreme that it is difficult to take altogether seriously. The analysis raises various central questions that you will search the pages of Marxism Today in vain to find answered.
How stable is the new culture? To what extent might economic recession disrupt it? And is not economic recession a real threat? How can a 'post-Fordist' labour movement respond to such threats?
If local councils offer something by way of a positive model, surely here are some pretty enormous questions that need to be answered. Brent council, for example, needed more that a grouping together of 'new movements' , and without a policy that depended upon mobilising workers (in an allegedly old-fashioned way), the council ended up having to make huge cuts. Other councils demonstrate sımılar lessons. = What is the precise significance of the changes in the working class? Today, one third of the workforce is "flexible' - part-time, temporary and sub-contracted. Union strength has declined from 12 million in 1979 to 9.2 million in 1987. Unions are starting to look for a new basis for recruiting workers, many of whom are women.
Manufacturing, of course, has de clined enormously; the 'white collar' sector has grown. The traditional support for Labour has correpondingly declined.
Some socialists have spoken of a rise in a 'new middle class', there has been such a rise.
But it is wrong to believe that the new groups of workers outside traditional manufacturing are any less working class than previous generations. Indeed, if you look at the nature of some jobs today, they are more "working -class, both in character and in workerconsciousness than they were a hundred years ago.
Clerical work is a good example.
A century ago, most British clerks were men working in small offices.
They needed quite high qualifications - probably some classical education. A clerk aspired to the lifestyle of the employers and certainly had no sense of identity with organised labour.
Clerical work has been "deskilled', with the growth of huge offices of (often female) labour, often unionised. Today's NALGO member is very different from the clerk described above. The same could be said for civil servants.
Or teachers. In 1926, teachers helped break the general strike. Today teachers are a highly unionised and quite militant group.
Marxism Today's stress on the 'individualisation' of class consciousness is dubious as well. In the first place, collective militant consciousness in big factories did not emerge on the day the factories were built. It was a long battle to organise classically-Fordist car ISUA plants in Britain. Such •consciousness depends as much upon traditions of struggle developed over the years as upon the organisation of production.
The decline in trade union organisation is not just a function of changing patterns of employment. It is also the result of big defeats for the labour movement since the mid-70s and consequent demoralisation.
And consider the groups of workers who have proved most militant in Britain since the defeat of the miners in 1985. We have seen major disputes by teachers, telephone engineers, health workers and postal workers. PICKET None of these are *traditional bastions' of trade unionism. Yet the methods of militant class struggle they employ are 'old fashioned' and end in defeat, or less than full victory, for 'old fashioned' reasons. too.
Those reasons have ranged from inadequate preparation to abject pusillanimous leadership. Postal workers, who account for 25% of industrial disputes over the past year, did not fail in their recent dispute because they were a social anachronism, out of tune with postFordist reality. 'hoto: Jez Coulson, IFZ "Old fashioned' ideas are highly relevant for such workers Undoubtedly, the Left has failed providing a choice of winter v to link itself in the popular mind Irobe. it does so by exploitins solidarity, rank-and-file strength, with the defence of individual workers which is to say, ideas don't work, but that the ideas trade union democracy. Their pro- blem is not that these old-fashioned freedoms, and has even allowed the Right to get away with counterpos- other capitalists, Next seeks abo all to make money. As a resu are no more than rhetoric — and as a ing "individual' and 'collective' rights. But what are Marxism To- while some people can afford shop up-market of Next, others c general rule have never been more than that. day on about? not afford more than Help the A New ideas are needed, of course. There alc three issues, here. ed second-hand shops.
Would socialism suppress the Not only does rank-and-file organisation need to be rebuilt; it needs to be linked as it never was in choice and individualism currently provided by Next or Habitat? Se- economic power out of the hands Socialism is about takit the past to political strategy. cond, is the market essential even in private money-makers and putti Nothing is more debilitating than the the long run for such freedom? t into the hands of working-cl labour movement's traditional divi- Third, what is the strategic role of people. There isno reason sion into 'political' (understood the expansion of democratic believe that will result in a los narrowly as parliamentary) and 'in- freedom in the achievement of a choice or individual liberty. dustrial' concerns. socialist society? Nor is there anv reaon whi And this raises Marxism Today's The issue that Marxism Today market is the best way to provi second theme: the question of the don't even seem to be interested in, choice. In fact, it's a very bad wa state and political democracy. is that however wonderful Next is in as it selects only what is profitab
Scan page 7
system a workers' We stand:
any time, an hend A0 women from th: burden of manager 1 i hot wan fir a mass in gainst cacisin, and against more in cofantom with orke * tion control in other countries fish- Pr equality for Tesbians and workers' truggles -worl i protect the rights of the Prowide, including the struggle of testant minority. workers and ppres FEE Far left unity in actión; clariBut it is true that socialism is not about an immediate destruction of the market. It is about gradually replacing the principle of the market-place with the principle of democratic planning.
That aspect of getting socialism is necessarily gradual. But Marxism Today advocate a more general (dare one say 'old-fashioned') gradualism - like a long list of others before them declaring revolutionary socialism to be out of date.
Rosa Luxemburg, a long time ago, commented: "people who pronounce themselves in favour of the method of legislative reform in place of and in contradistinction to the conquest of political power and social reform do not really choose a more tranquil, calmer and slower road to the same goal, but a different goal."
Socialism is necessarily about working class people taking power, in the first place state power, then economic power, out of the hands of the present ruling class. The new, workers' power will have to be fully democratic. And democracy now will help clear the road to that much richer democracy in the future. But there is no other way to achieve that future than by mass, collective action. Marxism Today has declared not only the impossiblity of the methods, but the impossibility, and even the undesirability of the objectives. Colin Foster reviews 'Office Without Power Diaries 1968-7 realised all of a sudden, writes Tony Benn, "that for three and a half or four years I have done absolutely no basic thinking about politics...
"This is how parties get ossified and out of touch...we haven't found time to think."
The date of this entry in Tony Benn's diary is 14 June 1968. The previous entries confirm his comment. The diary is all about politics, in one sense - it is the diary of the Minister of Technology in the 1964-70 Labour Government - but it is a very narrow sort of June 1968: the greatest general strike in history was still in progress in France. The Vietnam war, and the international movement against it, were at their peak. In Czechoslovakia Alexander Dubcek was pursuing his liberal experiment, soon to be snuffed out by Russian tanks. Northern Ireland was falling apart under the impact of the Catholic civil rights struggle.
All that scarcely appears in the diary. The politics that preoccupied Labour Ministers in 1968 was the politics of crisis-management, of administering a rickety capitalist system, and of personal intrigue and rivalry.
Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working-class socialism.
We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster SUBSCRIBE Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post Rates(UK) £8.50 for six months. E16 for a year, Name ..
Address Please send me 6/12 le 6/1 2 month i sub. I en niser PO Box 823. Lond Why do Labour Govenments so consistently betray even their most limited reformist promises? Here is part of the explanation. The day-to-day pressures of running the system swamp everything else. The Labour leaders just don't think about how the day-to-day stuff relates to any socialist ideas they still have in parts of their minds.
In quiet moments later, they may reflect and readjust their ideas. Most readjust their ideas to fit what they have done. What's exceptional about Tony Benn is that he did the opposite. He criticised what he had done in the light of his ideals.
In the period covered by these diaries Tony Benn was still middleof-the-road in Labour politics. He supported wage controls, and he supported the Labour Government's project for anti-strike laws, 'In Place of Strife'. A couple of years before he had suggested to Harold Wilson that Labour should present itself as "the natural ally of the managers and the people who run industry."
But he was beginning to rethink. His diary entry that "1 have done absolutely no basic thinking about politics" was prompted by a visit to a student-run 'Free University' in Bristol.
After 1970, when the Tories returned to office, he was influenced by the workers' struggles against the new government - the Upper Clyde Shipbuilders' sit-in of 1971, the miners' strike of early 1972 and the mass strike wave in July 1972 which freed five dockers jailed under the new Industrial Relations Act.
In September 1970 he published a pmaphlet calling for workers' control - "not just a respectful democracy, with elected representatives recallable privileges. Şocialan on a debo workers m el country their own capitatist Sta in st ga-s. rulers. We SAPPO! natimal liberation| strug les an tionalities in the states against their own ant socialist bureaucracies.
SOCIALIST REAMIST lose E To on SE 5 4NA. The new homele request for consultation before management promulgates its decisions. Workers are not going to be fobbed off with a few shares — whether voting or non-voting. They cannot be satisfied by having a statutory worker on the board or by a carbon copy of the German system of co-determination.
*The claim is for the same relationship between government and governed in factories, offices and shops as was finally yielded when the universal adult franchise brought about full political democracy..."
And in August 1972 he exclaimed: '*Wedgie Benn' and the Rt Honourable Anthony Wedgwood Benn' and all that stuff is impossible. I have been Tony Benn in Bristol for a long time."
Others, of course, were moving in the opposite political direction. One entry in this volume describes Benn attempting to restrain some fiery left-Labour MPs who wanted to stage a demonstration in the House of Commons against the Industrial Relations Bill in 1971. The leader of the firebrands? Neil Kinnock. There are many other such ironies.
The previous volume of these diaries recorded frequent and consistent visits to parties and receptions at Eastern Bloc embassies, and private meetings with Eastern Bloc diplomats. Benn, though not uncritical, clearly regarded those Eastern Bloc officials as authentic voices of socialism and Marxism.
Such contacts feature again in this volume. They are much more scanty, however. The book gives no clues about why.
Office Without Power: Diaries 1968-72 by Tony Benn (Hutchinson, £16.95)
For full equality. for women, and social provision to free , walked das based women's •deportations and all immigraFor a ut nited and free Ireland, with some federal system to ly in debate and discussion.
For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.
We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our poliey is democratically controlled by our supparters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Éditorial Board.
----- pull-quotes -----
leaders don't think about
WHERE WE STAND
Britains death squad 5 exposed!