Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Replace the phoenix! TREFORM 'OR REVOLUTION A SOCIALIST…]

Socialist Organiser no. 377, 27 October 1988 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 444 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Replace the phoenix!

TREFORM 'OR REVOLUTION A SOCIALIST ORGAN APHLET 80 PEN Available Box 823, SE15 4N plus 20 p Simon Pottinger argued should oppose extending pub licensing hours, or even advocate shorter hours.

I disagree. We should be for individual liberty wherever possible. And even if longer hours increase alcohol consumption, they may decrease alcohol damage. Drinking in a leisurely way, with food, is less damaging than gulping down four pints in a few minutes before the pub shuts.

Maybe it can't be long before rising alcohol problems put temperance back on the labour movement's agenda as it was in the early years of this century. But this is an area where well-intentioned policies can easily backfire.

Consider Sweden. Alcohol is available only from grim official government outlets, at high prices. Result: when people drink, they drink to get drunk. According to what I've read, Sweden suffers from a lot of public, rowdy, drunkenness.

Admittedly, the liberal, civilised alternative may not work either. In France, alcohol is regularly drunk with meals at home, and available at all hours in attractive cafes where food and non-alcoholic drinks are also served. French cafes tend to be adult male preserves, like British pubs, but potentially at least their mode of business provides for women and children, and allows for the culture of brutalised all-male heavy drinking to be broken down.

All very good; and it does éliminate the sort of regular public violent drunkenness you see in The 'phoenix' is a bad choice as a symbol of socialist renewal.

As SO 375 noted, it is a symbol currently used by fascists. It has also been variously used by anarchists, the Fenians and so on. Our using it will give rise to as much confusion and hostility as the continuing use by many on the "left' of the dreaded hammer and sickle. Why bother British pubs at closing time. But France has the highest rat e of health damage from alcohol i Western Europe.

The basic answer is to change society so that people no longer need booze. Yes, that will take many generations, and we need policies in the meantime; but if in doubt — and we have to be doubt — err on the side of liberty.

Paul Stewart Camden with a symbol thai can anything to anyone?

The workers movement and marxists do need a new culture — including new symbols - that is our own. But mythology is not the place to look. SO should ditch the 'eagle with its bum on fire' and open a competition, asking readers for their ideas for a better symbol.

Paul Woolley, Manchester

Scan page 5

LABOUR PA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 377

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →