Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Renationalise with workers' control!

Socialist Organiser no. 377, 27 October 1988 · scan p. 3 · about 525 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The Royal Ordnance sites at Enfield and Waltham Abbey were sold to British Aerospace for £3.5 million. Their estimated value now is €450 million. The land alone is worth £90 million.

Through this and other huge ripoffs British Aerospace could reap enormous profits by closing plants bought for a pittance as a result of privatisation. That's Tory Britain for you.

Yet increasingly large numbers of socialists see the traditional alternative to the private sector - nationalisation - as both old hat and irrelevant. Other forms of "social ownership' are to be examined. The Labour Party Policy Review is full of such notions, and they don't stop there.

Nationalisation has not been a good experience in Britain or elsewhere. State ownership by a capitalist state is not working class ownership. Bureaucratic and sometimes inefficient, the nationalised industries seem to many to be like ugly old buidings in need of demolition.

But it's not just the buildings get demolished.

Privatisation means deunionisation and worse conditions for workers. And some services can be better controlled when publiclyowned, even by the present state, than they ever could be in private hands. Privatised buses, for example, are bad news for people living on loss-making routes. Privatised water doesn't bear thinking about. Privatised hospitals....

The left does need a positive alternative to privatisation. If old-fashioned nationalisation isn't very attractive, we need a new view of nationalisation. Such a view must contain two elements.

(1) Nationalisation isolated unprofitable industries is useful more to capitalism than to the working class. Nationalisation should be linked to the idea of socialist planning: organising the dominant sectors of the economy on a new basis. Instead of profit, people's needs should rule.

(2) As a precondition for this, democracy must be at the heart of nationalisation. Of course this means democracy within industry. But it also means democracy at the level of the state. The state itself must be a democratic, socialist state, we must replace the bureaucracy and powers-that-be that run our lives at the moment.

Democratic, socialist planning, liberating humanity from the tyranny of the market place. That should be our alternative both to Tory privatisation and old-style Labourite nationalisation. union leaders; 6 out of 10 people believed that the tabloids make up stories; 7 out of 10 favoured legislation to prevent press intrusion into people's private lives.

The Digger's papers have T lately become vigorous champions of the virtues of deregulated, satellite television.

Today recently took TVS to task for running a newspaper ad suggesting that broadcasting standards were at risk and a British equivalent of the Italian programme where housewives strip on the air could be on the way. What an outrageous suggestion, fulminated Today: everyone knows that there is no porn on Italian TV.

Now, the Sunday Times has joined in, with a self-righteous tirade by Dr Jonathan Miller against Melvyn Bragg, David Puttnam, Muriel Gray, LWT, Channel 4, the BBC and anyone else with the temerity to question the merits of a broadcasting free for all.

None of this, of course, has anything to do with the Digger's plans to beam four channels of satellite TV from February next year...

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 377

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →