Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Nostalgia in song

Socialist Organiser no. 376, 20 October 1988 · scan p. 10 · Edward Ellis · about 872 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Distant Voices/Still Lives"

D is really two films that depict working class life in the Liverpool of the 1940s and '50s. It is a sequence of little cameo scenes, almost all of which involve people singing the popular songs of the period. In this way, mixing music and imagery, it evokes life as it was.

It's a nostalgic mixture, even though many of the events are depressing and even violent. The film focusses on one family -parents, two daughters, and a son. It follows their childhood (white Christmases, air-raids); youth ("Can I go to the dance Dad?" "Only if you clean up the cellar" "But there's rats in the cellar"); marriage; father's death.

The father was an extremely violent man who beat his wife and his kids regularly and sulked if he thought people were disloyal to him. One daughter hated him, though the other at her wedding reception, sobs her eyes out ("I want me Dad!")

Life is an endless round of pub sing-songs, domestic trauma and memories. Memory, indeed, seems to be the community's strong point as everyone is able to remember faultlessly all the words to all the songs.

Maybe people did The family all the words in working-class Liverpool. But I doubt if they all had voices to rival Vera Lynn. These people all do (except for one, very, very marginal character, and the joke is she can't sing) - and this is one of my first complaints.

It's a film that depends for its impact upon what we at least believe to be realism. Yet there is a lot that seems implausible (or unexplained). Worse, life as it was is portrayed as somehow quaint (how quaint to be bruised up by your husband...) and determine which gang you are in: the Crips or the Bloods. Each gang has its own colour — Crips, blue; so it's not altogether convincing.

The relationships between different characters, and even the characters themselves, are little explored. Father is a loveable brute stereotype; Mother is a longsuffering-woman stereotype. Son seems quite a sweetie who cries a lot. Daughters? Not sure. Husbands of daughters are miniloveable-brute stereotypes.

I don't think the film's intention is to paint life as lifeless, given colour only by songs. Rather we are can't never get out" according to one 14 year old Crip, who described the summary way in which anyone meant to see life as a rich tapestry of love/hate relationships. But it has little real depth or shape.

Partly this is due to the format: each scene is brief, microscopic -and often unexplained. We never find out (though I suppose we can guess) why Son comes home in his army uniform and smashes the front window shouting "Come out and fight me, you bastard" before being hurled into the back of a van by army police. Other things, likewise, we never find out.

I found this frustrating. I wanted to know more about the people, to know what made them tick, why they loved each other or hated each other. Mother's answer to the question, "Why did you marry him?" is typically vague: "He was nice. He was a good dancer".

The songs and the images themselves are quite powerful, the problem I is there's too much we don't know. What jobs did they do? What struggles were they involved in?

were being made, One of them, "Colours' was a box office hit, crowds flocking to see it, actually glorifying what was going on.

'Gang Detail' does place "social problems" as a cause of the gang warfare. Excitement, money, comradeship and peer group pressure were emphasised as motivations.

But it did not investigate these social problems very deeply. The rate of unemployment was not mentioned. The question of racism was not raised: the film never attempted to explain why this was happening amongst black youth.

As an account of what is happening in Los Angeles, the film is effective and disturbing. But if it had probed deeper into the causes 1 think it would have been more frightening still. Then it would have had implications, not just for a small part of LA, but for most of the capitalist world of which Reagan's America and Thatcher's Britain are leading the way.

They are heading the way in creating a society which offers its youth no hope and no future: which nurtures it on violence, greed, individualism and materalism, and which then punishes the monster it has created with prisons and the police.

Los Angeles may be an extreme version of what happens to young people under capitalism, but its crushing, disfiguring, get rich quick and get stoned to escape the effects — "feel no pain" — result is felt in all its inner cities, everywhere.

Bigger prisons and more heavily armed and equipped police are not the answer. That is one thing the documentary did show. Changing society, from one of alienating greed and profit to one of caring for people in which everyone feels they belong and has something to offer, is. That is one thing it didn't show. But it was still worth the viewing for all that. We can expect capitalism's media to sow the seeds of its own destruction, can we?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 376

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →