Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

ET: Against the boycott

Socialist Organiser no. 376, 20 October 1988 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 3,076 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

S_pp 1 10.J of SO have been f...Is 11 in ad vocating the boycott of ET, to kill this version of lor off at birth. They have stig hi suefilly in the trade on for this pruitio: they. will be amphigricg agait the TUC's latest attempt to fudge and gut the bay:111 policy part 1 a this year's Co-J=s. They have been cogicbing on the go to if 1 this BuT:

At this year's Labour Party confurine- SO supporter Mick C-1-1- p.-T -1 the c-T -it- call. ing for a ley-o11. It was caried agnint the advice of the laba cade slip and the votes of right wing min-. It was one of the most cignifinest cisteries The paper slingly supp,t this praiti:-. Bob Fine disag 333, balicing that a boy-311 will hinder: rather than help us. Here he Tallic the 50T why he sees it like this. Mick Chu will reply of the left at craft...

next week's SO.

want to question the wisdom of the boycott policy toward ET adcplad at the TUC and the Labour Party conference this year. The boycott seems to me to be based on an inadequate understanding the ET scheme and its problems and an emir cil tion of the effects of a polic boycott.

First, the boycott underestimates the extent to which ET can be turned to useful purpose on the ground, whatever the intentions of the Tory government might be.

The basic difference, as i undersand I, between ET and the ol my Frogramme is that th monies previvusly put into topping up or paying wages are now put into training. Basically the same overall budget is involved. For 16-18 year olds, a quite different scheme, YTS, is offered by the gorcrument and (Surprisingly given that it involves loss of dole and expleitation) not subject to the boycott.

Training on ET can mean almost anything. Through DETA (the Department of Employement Training Agency) the training tanager on the ET scheme receives E25 per week per individual for a - of 52 weeks toward training costs. This adds up to £1300 for the year. In adition. DETA provides a kind of 'starter pack' of up to f100 for each trainee, except when they are placed directly into work experience. These starter packs may be hammers and chisels for a trainee carpenter or paint and brushes for a trainee painter, etc.

In addition, the training manager negotiates fees with those organisations to which it sends trainees for work training. These may range from £10 a week from a big private company to nothing from a voluntary non-profit making organisation.

The trainees them res receive their dole plus f10 a week (ES of which goes towards travelling expenses). The trainee may elect to do any kind of training and a good training manager will seek to facilitate his or her choices: from training to be a farmer, organic gardener, = 4 artist, carptenter, clucian, word pre operator, phategers, etc.

The structure as well as the breadth of the training will vary from one locality to another. It may include formal training in FEs, Technical Colleges, Agricultural Training Centres, Open Learning Centres and private training organisations like those for pebliching, printing, silk screening, journalion, etc. All these institutions may be supervised by the training manager to ensure that a proper training takes place. The trainee who attends these courses will normally be able to end up with formal certification.

The training manager may set up or her own training schemes. For example the area. I know there is one in yourselors, in which the trainee learns through practice and skilled supervision skills in layout, Flate arly, design, printing, etc. In addition the trainees have day release to FEs to get Ven gusHes like City and Guilds, BTEC or RSA.

Lastly, the training manager has To send trainees for some of their time to work plaus for training on the job. How this is organised depends entirely on the local manager in question. So too does the proportion of the training time taken up in this form of training. 1 think that there is a minimum of 20%. Those training managers with a serious attitude to training closely monitor employers to ensure that training and not eagle in is taking place.

In my area the training manager seeks to ensure that the trainee is trained in a variety of different skills. by skilled workers, that the individual's abilities in these skills are assessed and his or her achieromeo listed and certified.

Both Employee and trainees are warned that the training manager will withdraw support from the scheme if it appears that training has been at = to exploitation. For example, if a woman, warned by her training manager to beware of exploitation, ot that she is only doing cleaning. a warning is given to the employer. If the situation persists, the support is withdrawn.

The use of all these facilities and their careful monitoring is how the scheme can work at its best. And in some instances it does. But how it works in practice depends heavily on local conditions. What appears as the central factor is whether training * is in the hands of the local aloney or a p rivate profit making agencyThere is the question of the training agent. He or she is the first to see a parential trainee and is meant to devise an action plan and then send the trainee on to a training manager or straight to a workplace or other forms of private training. The training agent is paid £20 for each trainee who passes through the door and another El5 for each traince sent to a training manager. If, as is often the case, the training agent is a private profit-making concern, the whole business turns into a farce. The training agent is paid £200,000 by DETA for accommodation and staffing, but in one case I know sees prem trainees in a corridor. Each trainee is given a maximum of 15 minutes to devise an action plan which may be entirely useless. Any serious attitude toward training is entirely subordinated to protit. Im other cir* the training agent may be the careers service of a local authority, in which case a very different picture emerges.

Then the training mangor who ganoes the actual training, may be a local - 1] but may be a private prefit making agency. One I know in the latter category makes no use of colleges offers no formal qualifications except its own valueless cotle and takes no measures to ensure that training is not just another word for exploitation of cheap labour.

Both training agents and training ay when they are private profit-making concerns are often a total disgrace (private, non-profit agencies Jare another matter). They

Scan page 9

which reform is made, said Kirkwood. One of the proudest boasts of Tom Johnston, himself a *Red Clydesider' MP, was. that survive because of the government's general 'enterprise' culture and through internal politicking within DETA.

Some are so bad that a concerted labour movement campaign to drive them out of business would have good chances of success. Whether local authorities or private enterprise or private non-profit agencies run the show depends at present on their tenders to DETA. I don't know the overall national picture.

Where local authorities manage Employment Training, they usually take seriously the formal Equal Opportunities directives adopted by DETA. Some schemes target black and other so-called disadvantaged adults.

The fundamental problem with making enterprise in its prait- ET is the use of ment. It is this which more than any other factor determines the training element and maximises the exploitation of trainee labour.

The fundamental task of the labour movement is to expose and drive out the malpractices of those who would make profit out of training unemployed people. This could and should be done both at local and national levels.

If the trade union boycott is im plemented - the NALGO amendment at the TUC conference gave the unions two years to phase out withdrawal - the scheme will function but will be left in the hands of the private sharks.

On the other hand, the organised labour movement has no alternative on offer to the unemployed. We should not underestimate the real attraction training offers to those on the dole. there were no pubs in Kirkintilloch, where he was a councillor (nor were there any until 1969). But whilst the socialist pioneers and the labour Many trade union members are involved in working the scheme, particularly in NALGO and NATFHE. How they will react locally to any attempt to implement the boycott is an open question. | believe that in Coventry the local NALGO region is not going along with the boycott. In Warwickshire the local NALGO is committed to the boycott in two years time.

How then members will react is one matter. Another is what sort of ET will be left for the unemployed once parts are boycotted by the unions.

When Norman Fowler said that the unions were involved in the design of the ET scheme, he appears to have been quite right. Many of its features were a result of trade union pressure. The main goal the unions failed to achieve was the rate-for-the-job for trainees while they are on workplace training.

This is an omission but apprentices have never received a rate-forthe-job and craft unions have jealously insisted on wage differentials for apprentices/trainees. The immediate issue is that training be real training and a meaningful apprenticeship into skilled labour, not just menial labour. Most of the unemployed in this country are unskilled or semi-skilled. However flawed the range of government training schemes they have provided some of these workers, particularly women 'returners' (le. returning to work) with skills.

So why did the TUC and then the Labour Party decide to go down the road of boycott? One factor was the threat of making ET compulsory but that is not the current situation and it is doubtful whether the government would take this option movement in general were hostile to the evils of alcohol, there were differences of opinion as to how the evil should be combatted. as long as training goes in inside ET.

The boycott policy seems to me to be largely unthoughtout. For some it is a substitute for conducting a labour movement campaign to drive out the profiteers anc prevent ET's abuse for exploitation. Boycott is a fairly easy option. You don't have to do anything. Whatever the unions say, I think it is very likely to be read by the unemployed in a negative light as a demonstration of unconcern. For those unions whose members are involved in the scheme, the boycott is likely to cause little more than disarray. ET will survive the boycott but it will be a lot worse. Is this what the boycott movement wants?

The difference between my position and that of the labour establishment is that the latter is not the slightest bit interested in exposing and ejecting the profiteers from ET. My own opposition to boycott is premised on a turning of the left's energies in this direction.

It is perhaps central to the argument that the TUC and the Labour Party nationally seem to be making little effort to secure the support of the unemployed through the construction of a representative voice in the labour movement - as has been done locally by, for example, the unionisation of community workers.

I can't help thinking that behind the boycott policy is a mix of good old-fashioned protectionism which has little to say on the representation of those who are marginal to the labour market and labour movement, and a syndicalism which would rather have nothing to do with Tory state institutions.

The Dundee labour movement, its efficiency and startled at the infor example, was committed to crease in its labour supply, total prohibition, as was apparent declared a General Pershing in the from resolutions from trades League's Almanac of 1920 in councils to STUC congresses. characteristically forthright manHome to the Scottish Prohibition ner.

Party, Dundee returned Edwin Other temperance organisations Scrymgeour as a 'Socialist Prohibi- began pursuing campaigns which tionist" candidate to Parliament in not even socialists who were "the the 1922 general election, unseating stuff of which reform is made" Winston Churchill in the process. could endorse. The British Scrymgeour immediately moved Women's Temperance Association, a 'Liquor Traffic Control Bill' in for example, turned its attention to Parliament, advocating the im- campaigning against the selling of mediate closure of all public houses ice-creams on Sunday. "This iceand five years imprisonment for cream pestilence has permeated anyone guilty of trafficking in li- through the country. There is now quor. But the Bill was easily no small village that has this plague defeated, with only the 'Red spot," declared the Lord Provost of Clydesider' MPs voting for it. Perth at one of its conferences.

An alternative position advanced 1920, when the shock waves of by socialists was that of the Bolshevik Revolution were still municipalisation of the drinks sweeping through the international trade. 'Socialism and the Drink working class, marked the climax of Traffic' , a pamphlet published in the struggle of the total absten1905, advocated: *It (the menace of tionists in the Scottish labour movethe drinks trade) can only be rooted ment. The STUC congress of that out by means of local control...This year voted in favour of prohibition local control can only be got by by 110 votes to 74, and the Scottish means of a Bill passed through Labour Party conference likewise Parliament which shall enact that voted in favour of prohibition by 47 on a given day the whole of the votes to 15. licences in the United Kingdom But the 'new realists' of the day, shall be vested in the hands of local claiming that prohibition would be councils" I a vote-loser among the working Between half and two thirds of all class and that it was "inspired by all licences would then be withdrawn. the claptrap of Puritanic represCouncils would impose strict quali- sim... attaching the labour movety controls on liquor on sale, until ment to the tail of the Liberal Parsuch time as all liquor was produced position. soon secured a reversal of this either by councils themselves or by the state. Profits from the 1921 executed a prompt U-turn by municipalised liquor trade would be 79 votes to 64, whilst at the Labour used for local improvements, such Party conference of the same year as free libraries, baths and gym- delegates successfully carried the nasia. 'previous question' against a proA third position, sometimes com- hibition resolution. bined with the former, was the From then on the divorce bet"local option' *local veto', ween the temperance movement whereby each district could decide and the labour movement grew ever for itself whether or not to ban the wider. The valiant struggles of the sale of liquor. Successive attempts socialist temperance and abstinence to gain Parliamentary legislation to campaigners became a forgotten this effect 1883, 1899, 1900, 1905) chapter in the history of our moveproved unsuccessful and produced ment. The epitomy of the Scottish a powerful impetus for the demand labour movement ceased to be the for Home Rule as a spin-off effect abstemious Keir Hardie, John (as English MPs outvoted a majori- Maclean and Tom Johnston but ty of Scottish MPs). A Temperance rather it became Mick McGahey (Scotland) Act was finally passed in and Bob Gillespie. By 1979 the 1913, permitting local plebiscites to alcoholism rate in Scotland was be held on the question as of 1920. quadruple that of England, and in Although the "local veto" posi- the Highlands and Islands twelve tion was adopted by the STUC, times that of England. O'Connor many socialists were hostile to it as Kessack's description of 1907 of i villadom would protect itself at ploy of the ruling classes. Glasgow Saturday evening streetlife once again held true: the expense of the slum," declared "Men and women are to be met the pamphlet *Socialism and the in all stages of drunkeness, some Drinks Trade'. An earlier pam- cursing and swearing and shouting Drink Trade had similarly argued: "The Case for a Municipal the most horrible of obscenities, others helplessly and painfully "The local veto in such places is a depositing the contents of their class measure. It permits those who stomach on the pavement...The buy their liquor from the wine mer- horrors of excessive drinking baffle chant to compel to abstinence those description. Debauchery, immoraliwho would like to buy from the ty and crime have simply run amok public house. In form it may be among the denizens of the slums. democracy, in fact it is a tyranny." After three general election In the event, such fears proved defeats in a row, the labour movejustified. In Glasgow it was the ment is rightly searching for the residential areas such as Cathcart reasons for such defeats. Equally and Kelvinside which voted for No correctly, socialists are stressing the Licence. To make matters worse, in need for the Labour Party to offer a 1890 Glasgow Town Council had bold socialist alternative to voted that no more licensed Toryism. We would do well to be allowed on Corpora- remember that the origins of our tion properties. This remained in movement are inseparable from the force until the 1960s, meaning that struggle for sobriety and the the massive post-World War elimination of the evils of drink, peripheral housing schemes had not and to recall the concluding words a pub between them: of "Socialism and the Drink Trade':

Although divided amongst *The Temperance reformer themselves as to the solution to the the old school has attempted to kill problem of drink, the Scottish the tree by lopping off the bransocialists of the early 20th century ches... But now the true were generally united in their Temperance reformer, the Socialist, hostility to organised temperance has arisen and while lopping off the societies such as the Scottish branches by removing the element Temperance League, which they of private profit from the (liquor) viewed as anti-working class trade, sets fire to the root by seekorganisations. "Close every saloon, ing to remove the conditions which every brewery, suppress drinking by make the craving for stimulants and severe punishment, and the nation the temptations to excess practically will suddenly find itself amazed at irresistible to many."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 376

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →