Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

End of the Burmese road

Socialist Organiser no. 376, 20 October 1988 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 2,624 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

system orkers" We stand in Tea City for lf and rulers. -For@united and free Ireland, coration uggles with • federal system to Kora otr the rights of the Proworkers and oppressed па- For left unity in action; clariin the Stalinje ty in debate and istates against their own anti- For a labour c - ac icico. - to the most can dents, associated with Charles oth, who had done much to blicise poverty in London, had Fretlem uncovering the imposi1 of fines and the low rates of 5 thus exposing management's and winning public support for match girls. by now the support of London ades Council had also been gainfor the strike. Apart from raising eney for the women, the Trades uncil sent representatives to cuss the conditions for a return work with Bryant and May, ich were subsequently accepted the strikers.

The firm agreed to end the fines 1 the penny in the shilling deducn (which, by law, they had zady been obliged to do). The men were allowed the use of a om as a canteen (eating food conninated with phosphorus had en a prime cause of "phossyr"). All the women sacked were nstated.

Manapement also suggested that, future, complaints should be ought to their attention before y industrial action was taken, and at a trade union should be formed facilitate this complaints proSure.

The Fabians Sidney and Beatrice ebb wrote that "the match girls' tory turned a new leaf in Trade lion annals...lt was a new exrience for the weak to succeed...e lesson was not lost on other orkers." And Ben Tillett, a leader the following year's dock strike, scribed the strike as "the beginnof the social convulsion which educed the "new unionism' , the new Dockers" Union, the Dockers' Strike of 1889."

Besant's own contribution to the labour movement proved shortlived. By the following year she had already become immersed in Theosophy, a typically cranky form of religion of Victorian Britain. But the match girls" strike in which she had played such a prominent role made a more enduring contribution.

It heralded the emergence of the "new unionism", the spread of a more militant form of trade unionism to the "unskilied", such as women workers. And it helped break up the cosy political relationship between the leaders of the TUC and the Liberal politicians to whom the former had traditionally looked to represent the interests of (sections of workers in Parliament.

It is easy to exaggerate the differences between the "New Model Unions" of pre-1888/89 vintage and the post-1888 ""new unionism" just as it is easy to overestimate the immediate impact and extent of influence of the latter. Nonetheless, the match girls' strike of 1888 and the London dockers' strike of 1889 did mark the emergence of a more militant variety of trade unionism and a stage along the road to independent working class political representation.

It is hardly surprising, therefore, that the leaders of the Labour Party of today, so anxious to again reduce the labour movement to a tame appendage of the bourgeoisie, should have found nothing to celebrate about the centenary of the match girl's strike. Martin Thomas looks at the background to the current uprising in Burma Burma is one of the poorest countries in the world. It has one radio for every 50 people; prints one newspaper for every 100. It has one telephone, one car, one truck, half a kilometre of road and 100 metres of railway for every 1000 people. Its 38 million people live mainly in the countryside, growing rice.

Under British rule — until 1948 it was a forgotten outpost, doing little but producing rice and providing jobs in administration for the dullards of the English gentry. The administrative machine, and what industry and trade there was, were mainly run by Indians. Indians also owned most of the land.

After independence in 1948 a land reform took most of the land from Indian landlords and redistributed it. The country, however, remained poor.

In March 1962 the army took power. This army originated not from the army established in Burma by the British Empire — which was mainly made up of Indian soldiers - but from the Burmese Independence Army set up in 1941-2 with Japanese backing. At the end of the war, seeing the Japanese would lose, it changed sides and collaborated with the British. It was not only a nationalist army, but also slammed by ethnic Burmese, excluding the minorities who make up 25% of the country's population.

STAND -i 0g stands for workers liberty East and West. We aim to help sigmies the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with We want public riot the major nice and a planned economy under control. • We want the present Westminster -SUBISCRIBE Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post. Rates(UK) £8.50 for six months, E16 for a year.

Name.

Address....

Please send mı 6/12 months sub. I enclose E Socialist Organ ser, PO Box 823, London SE15 The coup passed off quietly. But soon the new government made drastic moves. The leading army officers. like their counterparts in many other countries, believed in their mission to modernise the country through energetic state action.

Between 1962 and 1964, the new government declared illegal all political opposition, took over the direct management of most educational and cultural organisations, and established the nucleus of a political party with ancillary mass organisations. The new ruling party, the Burmese Socialist Programme Party, had only twenty full members (all army officers) for its first few years, but it still laid claim to totalitarian rule.

The military rulers said they were following a course equally distant from both capitalism and communism, but their political system was a replica of Stalin's. While all opposition was declared illegal, a network of Security and Administration Councils, and also of Workers' Councils and Peasants' Councils, was set up across the country, under strict military control.

There followed the nationalisation of all internal and external trade, and of large sectors of manufacturing, together with the introduction of quantitative physical planning as the basic mechanism of economic control. What private capitalists there had been in 1962 were almost all Indian or Pakistani; they were forced out. In May 1964 all large currency notes were declared worthless.

Foreign trade was cut back. In the the 1950s Burma had exported the late "70s, it was puring only democracy. with elected representatives any time, privilege workers in sore *tin Cont their own gays wide, including the agle of SOCIALIST HISE cops did shoot to 4NA. To: The Tories sew homeless Enterprises were run by military officers, as military operations. They followed military orders rather than any criteria of profit and loss. Prices were set by the central government, not by the market.

A lot of small-scale private business remained. Indeed, since agriculture remained in private hands, only 11 per cent of the workforce was state-employed in 1984-5. Still, state control over the legal economy was total. Even the tiny private businesses that remained - the great majority of them employing ten or fewer workers — were subject to state supervision so tight as to amount to de facto nationalisation. Practically 100 per cent of all investment was by the public sector. The state was the monopoly buyer of all agricultural produce.

After big strikes and student protests in 1974, the government "liberalised' a bit. State enterprises were required to show profits, and get finance through bank loans. Foreign investment was allowed. But the major limit on state control, at all times was a big black market.

The military rulers had set out to modernise and industrialise Burma as Stalin industrialised the USSR. They failed spectacularly. Industry was only 13% of national output in 1986, exactly the same proportion as in 1965 — and that despite the development of large resources of natural gas. The main achievement of military rule was to create a black market in rice - which had formerly been fairly plentiful → and to ruin agriculture to the point where Burma had to import rice.

Now the Burmese people are rebelling against this system. They will soon learn that genuine socialism has nothing in common with what their rulers have imposed on them under that name.

For full Try for -Kand social i 7. to free - from the b.J of houser mass Pd women's ere і, нас m, and against stations and alli. igsta: ninerity• tito its rank and file, and STEERE against capitalism.

We want Labour Party and trade union I - who support our basic ideas to t supportore of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small emitatic to help meet the General M- ti-g- and an elected National Editorial Board.

Scan page 8

Stan Crooke s-g__ that the if gglragtl-1 It was - and i-I be today - a comtal part of the drive to found ar i lifci tin Britain The struggle to create a politically independent working class — in this country was Tr from the struggle against alcohol - 1 - against sir gin of it, 1 against any confi- of it. Newtoo was this more clearly the case than in Salled.

Until the opening years of the 19th century what would now be termed excessive drinking was a national characteristic, if not a national virtue, in Scotland. It was a practice C - to all social classes.

Dr Alaila Webster, a Church of galland minister, was aike ed Dr Bonum Mrg for his ability to drink five bottles of claret at a sitting and remain sober. The judge Lord Newton, dial as "one of was noted for the clarity of his j 1g in court after all night drinking sessions g: the working classes, drink was a is with all events in family life and in working and leisure hours. Craft guilds and embryomic trade unions imposed fines in drink on apprentices. Ses apprentices and • paid their entry fee into the trade society in the form of a bottle of whisky.

Im 1822 the duty on spirits was lowered from seven shillings to less than three shillings a gallon. Conanton increased from 2,079,000 gallons a year to 5,777,000 gallons by 1829. Drink now came to be recognised as a social problem.

The earliest temperance reformers were aristocratic and middle class Eastsupiots, such as John Dunlop and William Collins (founder of the p fli ly firm of the same name). The ele societies they founded in Glasgow and Greenock in 1829 marked the first attempt to build a c temperance movement. By the fig year Collins had r tirl l half a million tracts attacking drink. Most of the = societies at this time were epposed to = of spirits, with gin, rum and, above all, whisky as the princif l enemjes whilst C tion of " liquors such a beer and wine.

The more radical clemant in the temperance 1-however!

* Irl the "short pledge" (ie. the pledge not to drink spirits) as a plot by the upper classes, people, whiskey from the c and retain the malt liquor, wine, cider and perry for the ladies and gents." Collins went further, and believed that the working classes, but certainly not his own class, should drink water only.

When a Glasgow radical suggested to a p-l select * ginto "the great increase of de amongst the Et g classes" that their inquiry be sealed to all classes, he was told that the House of Commons would not tolerate an inquiry which included its own members.

Thus, the Chartist movement in Scotland in the early 1840s, #tough itself more middle-class in leadership than its English counterpart, Combined a distrust of the middle class temperance reformers, whom it saw as too subservient to the ampluyers and the church, with.

ment to total abstinence.

A Scottish Chartist paper of 1840 declared: "We are forming a sharacter for the people which they have never before /| -making them i lig by instruction, and moral by blalis the principles of total antinence," In 1841 the Chartist Central Committee issued an appeal to "dedicate this year to total E -. And many p ? Chartists, such as Robert Cranston and John Grant, went on to found coffee houses and 1c hotels as the : died away.

It T working class protemperance and pro-abstinence ig igwas often viewed with distrust and even hostility by both the Church and also by -pic The Church saw such Tr ing as a threat to the -hi- of its _ply: when working class laymen began holding their -and pI: gagainst the evils of drink. (In any case, the Church i 1 to have a drink problem of its own: in 1853 five ministers were ipad for I - the worst offende had been charged 19 times in five years.)

Employera could be equally wary, fearing that workers who see themocres - with the social problems as well. There were even cases of workers being victimised by their employers for regularly addressing temperance As the working class movement continued to evolve into a form more similar to that which it possesses today, its commitment to abstinence remained undiminished. When Glasgow Trades Council was established in 1858 it chose as a the opening years of ' the 19th centurya exceSSiV drinking national characteristic, not a national virtue, in Scotland matter of policy tO meet in temperance hotels and coffee houses. The Scottish Cap helcome Society, founded in 866, refused • to any bodies retailing alcohol (the ban remained in force until 1958). And the Scottish Labour Party, launched by Keir Hardie in 1888, -1H11 1l of liquor traffic in its 18-point 1-3 The Scottish TUC was:- biched in 1897 and was soon the scene down by 34 to 40 and 8 to 66 two resolutions from Dundee Trades Council calling respectively for a Complete ban on the sale of liquor and for as to muel owiership of traffic in liquor. After another lively debate at its 1906 congress, the STUC voted 82 to 24 in favour of mi lin and the "local option" policy, with From total he rapium coming. the The Scottish section of the In- Labour Party, see to the Scottish Labour Party, was as opposed to the traffic in alcohol as its predecessor. Its aim was "total libiti of the liquor trade", wrote James Maxton in "Forward" in 1918. As late as 1926 the Scottish section of the ILP was still passing at annual mine calling for "the total of the r and salle of meal g: liquors" grew up in or b 1 grI to various Many labour 1 - pioneers - T Keir Hardie, Willie Sligh- (the future (one of the leaders of tie Davie "Red Cly-sile" unrest) were all of the I tep I tOrder of Good T-pl Tom Ach (author of History of the Wolig Classes of 2-t 1) had been a member of a Band of Hope (the "youth wing" of the And John Me les and James Connolly, who soon left his native f| for America and Ireland, were likewise 211lr The Red Cyt l MPs, elected to P. I T in the 1922 general ciecuon. eneral elective were all committed *We were all Puntans We were all b:_ Most of us did not smoke. We were the stuff of

----- pull-quotes -----

20% of its output, mainly rice. By 1982, despite some liberalisation in

Britains death Asquad 32 exposed.

paper's defit Our poll by our suffered at Annual

social problem of drink might start to concern themse with other

of heated debates over the drink question. Its 1905 congress voted

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 376

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →