[D to (or what arrspaper you aprading upon…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
D to (or what arrspaper you aprading upon who you talk read), Ron Todd is a bully, • traitor, a hypozritc, a weakling, an opportunist or just plain stupid. For some people he's even a bit of a hero just at the momentThe truth is that Todd is none of these things (or, perhaps, a little bit of all of them). But what goes on inside the head of the general secretary of the TGWU is less important than what he represents. Whatever else Todd may or may not be, he certainly is a taramoral For some people, that might as well be the end of that discussion; bureaucrats are the labour eatenants of capital, enjoying a privileged lifestyle on the backs of their members, selling out strikes and policing the rank and file for the gaffers.
But the real world is a little more emplicatal than that. After all, Arthur Scargill is a burcauuat. But whatever else may be wrong with him, no-one can seriously doubt Scargill's samm to the miners' strike of '84/85, or his evident willingncas to take on the Tories.
No-one in their right mind would suggest that there is no real difference betf Scargill belongs to that rare breed of British trade union leaders who have been consciously anti-capitalist (Scargill's hero A J Cook is the other obvious example, Ron Todd comes from much more familiar stock - left of centre leaders who will defend their members' interests and stand by basic labour movement principles, within the limitations of a thoroughly reformist political framework.
Todd stands firmly in the tradition of his predecessors, Moss Evans, Jack Jones and - especially - Frank Cousins.
Until the election of Cousins in the late '50s, the T&G had been firmly in the camp of the right, under the autocratic leadership of, first, Ernest Bevin and then Arthur Deakin.
Bevin had established the union as a major force in Labour Party affairs and he played an important role in installing Clement Attlee as Labour leader in the *30s. Similarly, Deakin masterminded the succession of Hugh Gaitskell's attempt to drop Clause 4 from the Labour Party constitution and threw the union's block vote behind unilateral nuclear disarmament. Cousins was quite capable of selling out strikes, but he did shift the union decisively to the left, and established a T&G commitment to unilateralism that has lasted to this day.
Cousins was also firmly opposed to incomes policy (in 1967 he resigned as Minister of Technology in Harold Wilson's government over the issue) although his successor Jack Jones was the architect of the "Social Contract -an incomes policy by another name.
Cousins also partially democratised the union, giving more authority to the lay executive and the regional committees. He deliberately refrained from asserting the almost dictatorial power that the T&G constitution gives to the general secretary - a power that Bevin and Deakin had exercised to the full.
The parallels are obvious. Todd is no militant class warrior. His shock-horror "cordless telephones' speech was actually intended as a clarion call to 'traditional' Labour against both the social-democratic 'modernisers' and the Benn-Heffer "fundamentalists" - Had the speech not come within hours of Kinnock's big turn at Conference and if Todd had avoided one or two emotive phrases it would not have been particularly noteworthy. As it is, Todd now seems to be on a collision course with Kinnock — especially on the issue of defence.
The right wing of the T&G have already seized on Todd's "disloyal" speech to step up their campaign against Todd and his supporters. Ever since Todd won the election for general secretary in 1985, a well organised right wing group around Welsh Regional Secretary, George Wright, (the defeated candidate in 1985) and Brian Nicholson (the union's president until he was defeated in the executive elections earlier this year) and the T&G's Labour Party NEC representative, Eddie Haigh, has been waging a secretive, bureaucratic against supporters.
A particular target has been the union's unilateral nuclear disarmament policy, which the right nearly succeeded in overturning at last year's Biennial Delegate Conference.
Another favourite target has been Todd's deputy, Bill Morris, who just happens to be black. The Nicholson group which controlled the executive until this year, kept Morris off the TUC General Council and the Labour Party NEC, and conducted a vicious witch-hunting campaign denegrating Morris' character and competence.
D on the executive, the right espite losing their majority have not given up. At the last Executive Council they staged a walk-out after failing to remove left winger Steve Riley (who defeated Nicholson in the executive elections) over a technicality. Some of the more vituperative of the recent press attacks on Todd originated from the Nicholsonites, who have close contacts with various industrial correspondents.
Todd's vision of trade unionism and, indeed, in the end, of socialism, is certainly bureaucratic and reformist. But he supposed the Ails business union. sweetheart deals at Ford, Dundee and Coca-Cola. He led the attack on cheap labour Employment Training at the TUC Congress.
If he now takes up cudgels against Kinnock's attempts to ditch unilateralism and embrace pale pink Thatcherism, he deserves to be supported. Without illusions, of course!
----- pull-quotes -----
NSIDE THE UNIONIS By Sleeper