The futility of the Falklands War
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
TELEVISION t is no wonder the Tories tried to stop the showing of the film Tumbledown (BBC1, last Saturday) when it was first put on TV in May. The play, by Charles Woods, shows the stark and brutal reality of how futile the Falklands war The war is shown from the point of view of Lieutenant Robert Lawrence (Colin Firth), an officer in the Scots Guards, with an impeccable military and, no doubt, class pedigree. The fact that someone with a background such as his can come to the conclusion that "it wasn't worth it" adds weight to the film's message.
Robert Lawrence is Action Man personified. Infuriated with the "bloody public duties" the Scots Guards jackets with bhass bed tons and bearskın hats, he is jealous when the Royal Marines and the Paratroop Regiments get sent to the Falklands. He trains "his boys" US-style with vigorous running and chanting route marches while his officer friend Hugh is happy to get away with ceremonies and boot cleaning.
His regiment does get sent to the Falklands and, once there, Lawrence shows himself to be a leader of men, volunteering his platoon for the most dangerous assault on the isolated rear side of Tumbledown Mountain which is held by Argentinian forces. In the ensuing battle, most of his platoon are either killed or seriously wounded and he gets shot in the head after racing up the mountain with a rifle blazing from each hand. It's the stuff heroes are made of, isn't it?
But he was kept waiting for four hours before being operated on in the field because they thought he was going to die anyway. He got sent to England without even his parents knowing until the last minute, and shuffled quietly, with the other injured soldiers, through an out-of-the-way airfield so that no-one would see the real effects of the war.
He was paralysed down one side of his body. When he was sent to a new hospital to continue his treatment, there was no bed prepared for him, no-one knew he was coming and his records could not be found. No-one told him whether he would be able to continue to serve in the army, whether he would get a pension or an award from the South Atlantic fund.
And, finally, he manages to get into a suit and goes to Westminster Abbey for the big, publicised, televised memorial service, where the Royal Family and big names came to mourn the dead heroes. He was kept right at the back, stuck in This wheelchair where he could see Yes, mate, we need a bloody Against the Tory attack Meanwhile this sheep is at cor Beating his chest, ranting agai This "leader' who won't lead i Whose bullets are misdirected Whose shouts are hollow nothing and no-one could see him.
And he was not wheeled out till everyone, including the cameramen, had gone. "As if I shouldn't have come back," he says.
The service was not to mourn those killed in a senseless war. It was propaganda for the war and an opinion-poll booster for Thatcher and the Tories; serving the same purpose that the Sun newspaper's 'Gotcha!'-type headlines served.
This isn't just alternative propaganda. The characters are real. Robert Lawrence does not suddenly become an anti-war veteran as a result of his experiences. With his background it would be unlikely. He is confused and angry about what is happening to him. "I am an officer of the Scots Guards," he screams proudly at a patient who tells him that smoking is not allowed.
Yet, when a doctor, who also happens to be a lieutenant-colonel, fails to discuss his medical condiiference inst the le us, or eve tion with him and then pulls rank on him to shut him up, Lawrence tells him he can take his rank and shove it.
Also, though, the horror of having killed Argentinian soldiers leaves an obvious scar — "Have you ever killed someone? Bits blowing off? I've done that. You stab. You keep on stabbing!" he savagely informs the nurses.
He is also proud of what he has been through and wants recognition for it. "I am going to walk. I am going to march, in uniform. Show them this," pointing to his head. "I'm proud of it"
The men under his command are not portrayed as working class heroes, either. They are shown -probably accurately — as a mixture of lumpen, skinhead thugs, punks and working class youth who joined the army to get away from unemployment and poverty.
Some of them, Pongo in particular, looked as if, had they not been getting shot at in the Falklands, would have been beating up black people in Newham or Lewisham, They never even got as far as Westminster Abbey. They watched the memorial service sately hidden from public view in their hospital ward. Lawrence was eventually getting questions asked because his father was influential enough to cause a stink. He was a wingcommander. His "boys" would have got told nothing at all. Lawrence got recommended for a military cross. They would not even have got thanks.
There was no need to dress up the characters as better or bigger than they were. Even with all his privileges, despite all his advantages, his conclusion about the war was the same. "It wasn't worth it."