More on Palestine
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
"communists"?
The patriotic wave makes sitting on the fence very uncomfortable. The Zionist "Socialist" parties soon "corrected" their anti-imperialist phrases and stubborn "resistance" against "cutting up the country to pieces" and gave way to full and enthusiastic support of the imperialist partition policy. That was a trifling matter, a question of merely changing Zionist tactics.
Yet the Communist Party of Palestine might have been expected to take up a different position. Have they not repeatedly warned against the fatal results bound to come with the establishment of a Jewish state? "Partition must needs broken off. The gap that still separated them from Zionism was finally bridged. Instead of being the vanguard of the anti-imperialist struggle of the Arab and Jewish masses, the Palestine Communist Party became the "Communist tail of the "left" Zionists. Precisely in an hour when Zionism shows to everyone its counter-revolutionary face, its blatant servility to imperialism. Thus the Communist Party itself held up all its former exposure of imperialist and Zionist deceptions to ridicule.
Why have they gone bankrupt?
The policy of the Palestine Communist Party lacks any continuous line. The policy of the PCP reflects both the needs deriving from the class war of the Jewish worker in Democracy, Revenge': availabl 20p plus 14p post sO, P.O.Box 823, don SE15 4NA. Not for rom LonSUCCEST LEATSOE The way to ArabSIDE helps to bring about partition and helps only the feudalists and imperialists, while it is fought on his back and paid for by his blood; so that the Jewish worker récognises at last the illusion of Zionism and understands that he will not be free and safe as long as he has not done away with national discrimination, isolationism and imperialist loyalty.
We have to keep up contact between the workers of both peoples at whatever place of work that this can still be done in order to prevent provocative acts and to safeguard the lives of the workers and on the roads. Let us form revolutionary cadres. In this burning hell of chauvinism we have to hold up the banner of international brotherhood.
Scan page 10
prettied up CINEM Belinda Weaver G may be the first movie ood Morning, Vietnam to look back on Vietnam with affectionate nostalgia. This is Vietnam-as-comedy, a rich source of satire and black humour. The tone isn't quite as nonchalant as "M*A*S*H" but it's in a similar vein.
The film is a showcase for Robin Williams, as Adrian Cronauer, a US Forces DJ who broke ground in Vietnam by playing rock and roll, sending up the war, and reporting censored news. It's a one-man show. The other characters exist for Williams to bounce off and to give him a cheerleading audience for his studio shows.
Cronauer banished Mantovani and Percy Faith from the airwaves, swore on air, and satirised US politicians and army top brass. He was tolerated as a licensed turn because he was good for morale; the troops loved him. He also didn't go too far. He pushed back the boundaries, but not that much. He had too much to protect. One more slip might send him out into jungle combat, which could only end in "coming home in a box'. NOT for Adrian Cronauer, thank you very much.
Williams is so diverting and endearing in the role that it takes a while to realise that Cronauer isn't all that nice. His comedy is based on all the standard Army prejudices against, gays, foreigners, the authorities. When he takes up some Vietnamese as a class to teach, it's to woo the Vietnamese girl he wants. And friend or not, he sends up the Vietnamese too, mimicking their stumbling English. They're just another audience for his compulsive comic turns. He doesn't learn any of their language or try to adapt to their ways, even when he's wooing his girl.
The war itself is fairly distant. The US Forces we see are shown in pristine choppers and patrol boats, photographed against romantic dawns and sunsets. Vietnam looks like some lush tropical paradise, full of cheerful extended peasant families. A few shots of burning villages, a few Vietcong kids with rifles, and a bomb is about the extent of it. Cronauer's studio is a cosy little nest, very sate and secure.
Cronauer isn't opposed to the war, though he doesn't want to fight it himself. He's romantic and misty-eyed about the "boys' who are fighting it. When he tells uncensored stories on air, it's not because he's against the war, but against the way it's being fought. He thinks 'our boys' should know that the 'enemy' isn't just 'out there' but all around, in the south as well as the north, in even the demilitarised zones. He wants the boys to have all the information they need to save their skins; the army top brass want to keep up morale.
Time has lent the proper irony to some of Cronauer's statements, such as when he yells at his friend Tuan, "We're here to help you people!" But these ironies are largely implicit in the story and in the characters, rather than spelled out. Robin Williams as the dissident DJ It is left to Tuan to scream out the real truth about Vietnam.
Williams is certainly an extraordinary performer, talking at incredible speeds in a sometimes bewildering array of accents. His brain seems to be working at a furious pace, yet he's smiling and fooling as if it's no effort at all. He could make almost any character he played likeable. Let's just hope he never signs up to play Stalin.
----- pull-quotes -----
Democracy, not revenge!