Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Thatcher's fragile success

Socialist Organiser no. 375, 13 October 1988 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,750 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

After nine years in

power, 'Thatcherism seems triumphant.

Some people argue that Thatcher has made a revolution in British politics and opened a new era.

Martin Thomas argue that the Tories' success is less solid than it appears.

cheap-labour producA tion site within Europe for the callinionals, free of strong trade unions — that's the Tory vision of Britain's future.

They also count on gains from two other sources - the City's business as an international finance centre, and British overseas investments.

The Tories have some reason to be pleased with themselves. Trade union membership has been cut by 25% since 1979. Anti-strike laws have been effectively imposed. Speed-up, and the axing of vast chunks of less profitable industry, has raised productivity fairly fast since 1981. Britain has got more than any other European country of the swelling flow of Japanese foreign investment.

Britain's own net overseas assets are now bigger than any other contry's except Japan's. British capitalists have bought out large sections of American business. And the City has maintained its role as an international finance centre.

But all this adds up to a lot less than reversing the long-term relative decline of British capitalism. For all the talk of Thatcherism and Reaganism as the ideologies of a new capitalist era, they have in fact been the policies of capitalist states in relative decline, and which continue to be in relative decline.

Formulas

The Tories' formulas make British capitalism more dependent than ever on the ups and downs of the world economy. The British economy's recovery since 1982 owes more to the international expansion

powered by the US budget and

trade deficits than to anything the Tories have done. The stock market crash of October last year gave warning of how fragile it is.

A new book on "The Politics of Thatcherism' concludes that the Tories have *not so far demonstrated that (they) can reverse the decline (of British capitalism. What (they have)

discovered is a formula for managing the decline. and its consequences."

The continuing feebleness of British manufacturing — which has only just got back to the level of output it had before the terrible slump of the early Thatcher years, 1979-81, makes British capitalism very shaky. The boost provided by North Sea Oil income is now on the Culture For all the talk about changing Britain's culture, "remarkably large majorities remain opposed to many of the policy shifts in welfare and social policy most sought by the Thatcher Government...a majority against privatisation...Only five per cent supported reductions in (public) services, even when they were linked to tax cuts..." There is no distinctively Thatcherite electorate, concludes author Andrew Gamble, and no Thatcherite consensus. Not even the Tory party is solidly Thatcherite.

Trade unions remain strong in many areas and able to win wage rises outstripping inflation. The Tories' triumph is fragile.

Even that fragile triumph only became possible after many missed opportunities by the labour movement and a fair amount of luck. To trace the origins of Thatcherism, we must go back to the early 1960s.

The British capitalist class was becoming acutely aware of their decline relative to other powers and of the need to seek new directions after the collapse of the British Empire. In 1960-1 the Tory Government and the leading bosses' organisation, the Federation of British Industry (now CBI), were converted to national economie planning.

In July 1961 the Government decided to start five year plans for public spending, linked to targets for national income. In August a new agency was set up for national planning - the National Economic Development Council, a joint body of government, employers and trade union leaders. It still exists in

a shadowy way.

Also in July, a freeze on wage rises was decreed; in February 1962 it was followed by a 2-2% guiding light' and in July 1962 by a National Incomes Commission.

In August 1961 the Tory Government applied for Britain to join the BEC. This application was vetoed by France in 1963.

Harold Wilson and the Labour Party leadership took up the Tories ideas — all except joining the EEC — with enthusiasm. After thirteen wasted years of Tory misrule, they promised Labour would introduce 'the white heat of the technological revolution'. Labour won the 1964 election with support from important sectors of capitalist opinion who thought that Labour could carry through the new policies better than the fuddy-duddy Tories.

They also calculated that Labour would be better able to deal with the increasingly confident and militant trade unions.

Wilson tried. A National Plan was published in 1965. New ministries of Economic Affairs and of Technology were set up.

But these were the years - the late '60s - in which the long postwar period of relatively smooth capitalist expansion was coming to an end. By 1969-70 the Labour Government was mired in crisis, desperately and unsuccessfully trying to impose anti-strike laws on the trade unions. The National Plan had long since become waste paper.

The rank and file protested against the Labour Government's policies. But most of the Marxist left had quit the Labour Party. The protest was scattered in a flurry of different movements, rather than being focused on a fight to transform the labour movement. Labour and the left had missed one opportunity.

Selsdon

The Tories returned to office in 1970 with new ideas, worked out at a policy conference at Selsdon. State intervention would be cut, moted. Sweeping anti-union laws were legislated. Under Heath, it was Thatcherism before Thatcher.

The Tories were knocked back by a victorious miners' strike in early 1972 and a mass strike wave to free five dockers jailed under antipicketing laws in July 1972. The Government did a U-turn. It increased public spending, intervened in industry, and legislated a series of wage controls. Battered by a new world slump and a new miners strike, it finally collapsed in early 1974.

The industrial militancy of the working class had won great victeries. But these were negative victories. The Tories had been knocked back. The workers' morement had not pushed through any positive solutions of its own.

Could it do so? That depended on politics; and the tragedy in 1974 is that the victorious working class had nothing better to replace the Tories with than the same Harold Wilson who had ruled so disastrously in 1964-70.

Wilson started by undoing some Tory legislation and making some gestures towards the 1964 policies of state-promoted industrial expansion. By August 1975 all that had been abandoned, and the Labour Government was back to crisismanagement and wage controls. The fiasco of a much more concerted effort at such state-promoted industrial expension by the French Socialist Party govenment in 1981-3 would prove that such policies are powerless against the pressures of the increasingly open and fastmoving system of international finance and trade.

Replacing

This new failure by Labour opened the way for the Tories to return. In opposition the Tories had become more hard-nosed, with Thatcher replacing Heath as leader in 1975. The New Right within the Tory Party had become more vocal.

Just as Labour had picked up the theme of planned expansion from the Tories in 1964, now the Tories were the bold advocates of the policies of 'monetarism' (cash squeezes, supposedly to stop inflation) and drastic cuts in public spending being shamefacedly pioneeréd by the Labour Government.

Thatcher's other main theme was Britain's military strength. Her first notable speech as Tory leader was against detente. It won her the name 'the Iron Lady' Thatcher was more cautious on two other fronts. On the trade unions presumably she kept quiet because she had a worked-out policy of proceeding step-by-step, cautiously but ruthlessly. In 1978 Nicholas Ridley prepared a secret report for the Tory leadership on how to deal with strikes — a plan that was followed through fairly closely up to and through the miners' strike of 1984-85.

The Tories" first measures were to cut public =-ling and restrict supplies of cash and credit. At the same time the capitells world was going into a slump, triggered by a new round of oil price rises. The result was derstaling. Within 2½ years one-quarter of the jobs in British manufacturing were lost.

Unemployment rose to three million.

By the end of 1981, Thatcher was the most impopular Prime Minister since 1945. The Tories' opinion poll score was the lowest ever recorded by a governing party.

Saved

Again, the Tories were saved by the failures of the labour movement and the left. The TUC let the steel workers go down to defeat in 1980, and after a couple of days of action abandoned all attempts at a general campaign against the government.

A sizeable new left had emerged in the Labour Party; and it was in a position to lead a fight back even despite the TUC. Leftists like Ted Knight and Ken Livingstone led local councils. They talked about confronting the Government. In practice they chose to manage the Tory cuts through rate rises. Capitulation followed capitulation.

The Tory Government had quietmonetarism, but it had held lim through the storm. Its Falklands War victory in summer 1982 gave it a tremendous boost. The world economy recovered slightly. The Tories found successful policies, like privatisation and selling off council houses. The great healthworkers' struggle of 1982 was allowed by the trade union leaders to dissipate in scattered actions. The Tories gradually tightened their legal grip on the trade unions, scoring a decisive victory in the print unions' battle against Eddie Shah in Warrington in late 1983.

For years Arthur Scargill had been arguing that the miners must launch a decisive fight against pit closures. But the fight had been put off. Now the Tories chose their time for their showdown with the vanguard of the British trade unionim. The 1984-5 strike was longer and more costly than the Tories bargained for, but they won it. And that laid the basis for their present confidence.

it serves no purpose to ignore or minimise our defeats. But it serves no good purpose, either, to overestimate the Tories' strength or the coherence of their policies. The Tories have got where they are through avoidable failures by the labour movement and the left. They can still be defeated. *The Free. Economy and the Strong State: The Polities of Thatcherism" , by Andrew Gamble. Macmillan. £7.95.

Scan page 6

6 SOUTH AFRIC

----- pull-quotes -----

"lame ducks' sacrificed, free enter- prise and ruthless competition pro-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 375

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →