Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Is state monopoly better?

Socialist Organiser no. 375, 13 October 1988 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 664 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

No illusions in Todd! SOCIALIST DASANISES The T new none agree with Duncan Chapel (letters, SO 374) that workers in Burma should organise independently of the middle-class opposition and fight for socialism.

But should those workers ally with the middle class opposition? At present the workers are not an independent political force; the middle-class opposition is the only force in the political arena. What's our attitude? Socialist Organiser says we should side with the opposition because it fights for democracy, in however limited a way. Militant says the same thing.

But Militant is illogical. Militant says that it would be a catastrophe for the odd is right what a surprise! It is highly unlikely that anyone who had any doubts about that would be reading the pages of Socialist Organiser.

SO should have been saying what was all the fuss about? OK, Ron Todd made a challenge to the leadership's complacency - but that was only after voting for them, present statised economy in Burma to be replaced by a private-profit system. So why not oppose the mass movement which is driving towards that "catastrophe' , and support the regime which is fending it off?

In 1962-4 the military seized power in Burma, and created a totalitarian state. Burma's industrialists and merchants — mostly Indians and Pakistanis — were driven out of the country. The military took over their businesses, and ran them according to government-decreed production targets and prices. All independent clubs, parties, unions and associations were replaced by or converted into offshoots of the army commanders' 'Burmese Socialist Programme Party' "If capitalist profit has been abolished.. that's good" , writes Duncan. Here it's not so simple. What replaced private capitalist profit? Not a cooperative commonwealth, but the exploitation of the workers and peasants by a stateIt is a reflection of how rightwing the Labour Party is that Ron Todd is now the mouthpiece of the left. Socialists shouldn't add to the flag-waving, hero-worship of the man wielding the block vote. Yes, stay positive, yes, keep fighting, but don't win support by'spreading illusions.

Comradely, Helen McHale, Manchest monopoly bureaucracy.

You might argue that this new exploitation was different (in technical economic terms) from the old - but scarcely that it was better. It was worse, because it went together with the suppression of even the feeble democratic liberties that Burma had before 1962.

In Vietnam or in Nicaragua, we sided with mass movements of workers and peasants against imperialism and oligarchy, even when we calculated that their leaderships were on the road to a bureaucratic state-monopoly system. We side with the movement in such cases despite the leadership and in order to be better able at the next stage to mobilise workers and peasants against the consolidation of bureaucratic state monopoly.

None of that means that bureaucratic state monopoly us better than private capitalism. It isn't — and that is the issue in Burma. We fight for socialism - but we have no reason to defend bureaucratic state monopoly, even against private capitalism.

Alan Gilbert, Camden Socialist Forum Reassessing the Meeting with guest speakers 7.30 ednesday 26 Octob way Hall, Red Lion

Scan page 5

WMS 777 On privatisation Thatcher was cautious probably because she was sceptical. Some New Right ideologues were already demanding wholesale sell-offs of public enterprise, but most Tories were dubious. The Tory manifesto of 1979 ventured no more than the thought that "in some cases, it may be appropriate to sell back to private emierprise assets of activities where willing buyers can be found".

Only in practice did the Tories discover how privatisation could serve them, bringing cash into the state budget, bribing voters with cut-price shares and easy gains, and undercutting public-sector trade unions.

Thatcher won in 1979 more by Labour's default than by the Tories' actreme. Her position as party leader was still insecure. At the 1975 Tory Party conference, an unprecedented one-third of the conference had voted no confidence in her.

----- pull-quotes -----

Britains death exposed

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 375

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →