Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Labour: stay in and fight!

Socialist Organiser no. 375, 13 October 1988 · scan p. 3 · about 1,619 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Labour Party conference delegates signal defiance To attempt to avoid the existing popular institutions of the State. parliamentary politics of the work- The quality of the political act ing class is to turn your backs on the varies. The syndicalists worked outworking class as it actually exists. side of reality, and hence their The Italian Marxist Antonio politics were fundamentally Gramsci made a similar point when mistaken. On the other hand, the he explained why the supporters of parliamentary socialists worked in self-sufficient militant direct action close contact with events, and while of his day - the syndicalists - fail- they could make mistakes (and ined to provide an alternative in the deed they committed many working class movement to the mistakes, and grievous ones too), "The workers and peasants felt tion their activity took and so they N from a strange quarter eil Kinnock got help last week.

The Socialist Workers' Party (SWP) made yet another of their boringly familiar calls for left-wing activists to quit the fight inside the According to Socialist Worker, staying inside the mass political wing of the British labour movement is a waste of time for socialists because the action is to be found elsewhere:

*Demoralisation is unjustified. The right in the Labour Party may have triumphed but there is still plenty that socialists can do outside the Party. The crisis in the NHS is just one example of the Tories unpopularity. The Poll Tax is another and the Housing Bill yet another... "Together these issues have mobilised more working people than at any time since the miners' strike... they will not be won to socialism by activists who spend half their time working to build a Labour Party dominated by the Kinnock-Hattersley machine."

This is inaccurate and stupid and it is a counsel of despair.

Many of the activists in the NHS and in the Poll Tax and Housing campaigns are members of the Labour Party already and look to the Labour Party for political answers and a political lead. So how are the SWP going to win these people to socialism by telling them to quit activity inside the Labour Party, the political wing of the multimillions labour movement?

We need to beat back the Tories attacks, yes! But we also need something to replace the Tories with. We need an alternative government, a government based on and accountable to the labour movement and prepared to decisively take on the power of the bosses.

Right now, the official labour movement is a long way from being able to provide such an alternative. But an alternative government is needed nonetheless and the workers involved in the various direct action campaigns against the Tories know this Workers know that being angry with the Tories isn't enough, they understand the need for a political alternative and therefore turn to the only alternative that is available, the Labour Party. They turn to parliamentary politics.

For a while, everything Boyo. The lefties' leadership challenge had been brushed aside and his big speech seemed to go down pretty well. Even the press had to admit things were going smoothly.

The worst the Daily Express had been able to come up with was Tuesday's headline, "Kinnochio" , above a story suggesting that the Dream Ticket had put itself in thrall to the union barons in order to get re-elected; hardly very original, that. reformist socialists.

that, so long as the propertied class and the democratic-parliamentary State are dictating the laws of history, any attempt to remove oneself from the sphere of operation of - these laws is inane and ridiculous. There is no denying the fact that within the general configuration of an industrial society, each man can actively participate in affairs and modify his surroundings only to the extent that he operates as an individual and citizen, as a member of the democraticparliamentary State. The liberal experience is not worthless and can only be transcended after it has been experienced. The apoliticism of the apoliticals was merely a degeneration of politics: to reject the State and fight against it is just as much a political act as to take part in the general historical activity that is channelled into Parliament and the municipal councils, the page, complete with full-colour photo (the smiles say it all as jublilant Neil Kinnock shares his triumph with wife Glenys yesterday"), while inside political editor Julia Langdon gave readers edited highlights of the "powerful and passionate statement"

The Financial Times leader,called it "the best social democratic speech of the season" and went on to note approving that it took account of the market, it accepted the need for competition. It recognised that a mixed, albeit regulated, economy was necessary if wealth was to be created." The FT's only reservation was the lack of a "credible defence policy" but, that aside, not a bad write-up. Of course, the FT's John Lloyd had written most of they made no mistake in the direc"The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race"

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965.

Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU), 01-358 1344.

blished by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser.

Daily Express triumphed in the 'competition'; the broad masses, the people who objectively modify social relations through their intervention, Favoured favoured the Socialist Party. Notwithstanding all its mistakes and shortcomings, the Party did succeed, in the final analysis, in accomplishing its mission: namely, to transform the proletariat into The Phoenix Last week we superimposed a drawing of a mythical bird, the Phoenix. in red over the 'Where we Stand" box.

The Phoenix in myth was an immortal beast which could rise reborn out of its own ashes. Thus it seemed to us an appropriate image for what we are doing: working to make socialism rise from the ashes of reformism and Stalinism.

Forced to say so many something whereas before it had been nothing, to give it an awareness, to point the liberation movement firmly and enthusiastically in the direction corresponding in its general lines to the process of historical development of human society.

The gravest error of the socialist movement was akin to that of the within the State, the socialists forgot that their role had to be essentially one of criticism, of antithesis. Instead of mastering reality, they allowed themselves to be absorbed by it."

The SWP are just making the same mistake as the Italian syndicalists, except that they do it 70 years later - 70 years of bitter experience.

According to Lindsey German:

*But the left has not recognised the real issues. Every attempt to reform the Labour Party has failed — not because of lack of effort, but because of the fundamental nature of the Party.

The block vote goes to the roots gains that vote is used against them."

The argument can only possibly make sense if Socialist Worker believes it is impossible and pointless to fight to try and transform the unions. If we don't manage to change the way the block vote is used then we're not going to get very far in the unions.

Logically they should say that socialists shouldn't work in the unions either!

things about the would-be Marxist left, we felt the need for some symbolic way of asserting our unshakeable belief that socialism and Marxism will renew themselves.

Thus the ancient symbol of the Phoenix.

Some readers have protested that this is a fascist symbol.

It is certainly a symbol used by some fascists. But symbols like this have been put to many different uses over the ages. Right now, for example, there is an anarchist publisher called Phoenix Press.

Presumably they chose it for reasons like our own.

Some of the people involved in Socialist Oraaniser issued a series of 'Phoenix Pamphlets' in the 1970s.

The Phoenix was the symbol of militant Irish Republicanism at its best, the symbol of the Fenians.

For us, to repeat, the Red Phoenix is a symbol of the socialist renewal we strive for.

ecutive until he somehow got thrown out in a vote of the membership) to say things like, "He has really gone off the rails this time" , and "As far as 1 am concerned Ron Todd is a has-been and will become extinct like the dinosaurs."

All of which no doubt made the Boyo feel a little better about things, coming as it did from Britain's only Laboursupporting daily.

Strangely, Just about the only detence of Todd to be found anywhere in the press came from Paul Johnson in Thursday's Mail - and a pretty backhanded defence it is too:

What Todd, in his friendly way, has spotted is that Labour may end up with smart image and a slick agenda, but with no body and no soul. The truth is that Kinnock's new position haltway between socialism and capitalism contains too many contradictions. It is clearly a con. And what Todd wants to know — what all of us need to know — is who is being conned.

But then, the Mail is a Tory rag and Johnson is a half-crazed born-again Thatcherite. So we needn't take any notice of what he says, eh Neil?

----- pull-quotes -----

syndicalists. Participating in the general activity of human society

of Labour, which was formed to represent the trade unions in parlia- ment. Every time the left makes real

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 375

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →