A world apart
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Many have found the women athletes at Seoul inspiring but others have reacted in the spiteful traditions of male chauvinism. Of Florence Griffith Joyner, who can beat all but a few dozen men over 100 metres, Brazilian runner Joachim Cruz said "She's a man', likening her sister, champion heptathelete Jackie Joyner Kersee to a gorilla!
The accusation of 'unfeminine' or 'manlike' has always been thrown at women who use their muscles. Some have had to endure accusations that they actually are men in disguise. This resulted in the introduction in 1966 of sex-testing only for women.
This wasn't just a quick look at the lower regions but what Mary Packer described-as a humiliating internal examination to see if perhaps she had a couple of testicles hidden up her vagina. Later, a chromosome test was instituted, less humiliating but just as pointless and devastating to the athlete who 'fails'. But modern sports wear make it impossible for a man to pass as a woman without drastic surgery - so what are the sex tests for? An mose please need by presence absence chromosome — or, rather, by chemicals produced as a result of having a Y chromosome. Recent research suggests that one gene only is responsible for prouducing a testicle-determining factor which instructs the gonads to develop into testes. In its absence, they turn into ovaries. Other male characteristics are developed because a person has testes and not simply because 'he' has a Y.
Now, there are women with Y. Some probally have a fault in the TDF gene while others have the rare testicularfeminising syndrome. They have small testes inside their bodies, they produce male hormones but their cells are incapable of responding to these. Their bodies àre indistinguishable from those of other women but they are infertile. Sex-testing is mainly based not on testing for the presence of a Y but for the presence of two X chromosomes.
Heavily armed police move in to break up a gathering at the funeral of a murdered black South African. This could be any shot from a news programme today.
But this is South Africa, 1963, the year of the 90 Day Detention Act and the ANC's turn to armed struggle. At the funeral, defying house arrest, are Diana Roth and her daughter, Molly. They're white South Africans, but they can't live with the regime.
The character of Roth in A World Apart' is based on Ruth First, a Communist activist killed by a letter bomb in 1982. The screen play was written by her daughter Shawn Slovo.
The film deals with their difficult relationship as Roth becomes more and more involved in politics. Molly is just emerging from childhood, and is forced too soon to deal with a whole host of frightening changes. Her father disappears, her mother is distant and somehow under threat, her schoolfellows jeer and mock at her for her unpatriotic, black-sympathetic parents.
Molly badly wants reassurance, but her mother is too caught up in her own world to see her child's needs. In the pressure to do what she thinks is right, Roth plays the distant, impatient parent when her daughter asks her questions.
Like Molly, we're not too sure what Diana Roth is up to, but this only makes us feel Molly's fears all the more. Molly wants to know what's going on, where Daddy's gone, and why everything is changing so fast. Her mother can't give her answers, so we identify with the child's bewilderment.
Slovo's script is structured so that we focus on Molly first but shift to Diana as the government clamps down on her activities and begins to persecute her. While at first Diana seems unsympathetic, this changes as we focus on her struggle in prison. Diana herself is shown as Barbara Hershey and Jodhi May uncertain and at times weak and frightened. Deprived of her husband's support and uncertain of his whereabouts, she wonders whether she can bear to carry on alone.
Diana's dilemma is a commmon one for activists - how to balance the real needs of family against the necessity to engage in political struggle. Roth is driven politically, and her family just have to understand and suffer along with her. She sees no other choice.
The direction the film takes shows that Slovo has forgiven and better still, understood what her mother was fighting for. In the film Molly herself grows up to see beyond her own problems, and to want to understand the cause her mother believes in.
Films which show personal relationships against a historical or political background often suffer because personal issues seem like a distraction from the more interesting backeround. That doesn't happen in 'A World Apart'. Jodhi May, who plays Molly, is absolutely riveting, and we grow to feel for Diana as the film progresses. Like Molly we find her a little forbidding at first but the more we see the more there is to admire.
It isn't really a political film. The South African state is shown as genuinely terrifying, with its arbitrary violence and punitive laws. But the film doesn't give a sense of the movement of black South Africans. There are demonstrations, but no strikes. The film doesn't give an indication of how South Africans can beat the regime. We see defiance and personal courage but little organisation. Perhaps the most harrowing thing about 'A World Apart' is how long black South Africans have been struggling without yet being free.
----- pull-quotes -----
ESCIENCE Seoul sex scandal M achievements of the