Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Have but You Wont

Socialist Organiser no. 374, 5 October 1988 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,673 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

The miners' defiant message America; just as Thatcher unleashed a prolonged orgy of cuts, anti-union laws and welfare state dismantlement. How could they use local government power to thwart Thatcher and help raise up a force her?

Two views emerged and then in the Rank File Mobilising Committee.

The first view said that local government should be used refuse to implement Tory cuts. They should take advantage of implement cuts. to mobilise the local communities against the act that the Tories were implacable, ing. Such that the leftwingers, taking local government 'power' good as their their model guide George defence borough.

The local government left The other approach was the one followed by the local government left in power - not to fight the Tories, but to procrastinate; not to fight the Tory cuts, but to pass them on to the working class electorate by raising money from them through HE WIFE higher rates to offset cuts, not to play the part of fighters, but that of people concerned first of all, and at whatever cost to the working class, with their own well-being, including their own future careers.

Instead of the local government left controlling a series of anti-Tory fortresses dotted about the country, holding out against Thatcherism, mobilising the electorate to oppose its practice and its ideas, the local government "left' played ball with Thatcher. It made lots of noise against the cuts, but still it passed them on.

Ultimately some of the coun cillors - notably in Lambeth and Liverpool - blundered into a confrontation with the government -years too late, after they had, over years, demobilised the possible working class local opposition to Thatcher.

More than anything else this experience has shaped the Labour Party today. If it had not happened like that, Kinnock's ascendancy would not be what it is today in the Labour Party — and maybe Thatcher's ascendency in Britain would not be so pronounced either. It is unlikely that the Labour left alone could have defeated Thatcher while the broad trade union class struggle was declining. But we could have lessened the defeat and offset the decline. Instead the local government left created a new school of wheeling-dealing, naked careerism and indifference to long-term socialist goals.

Socialist Organiser, which had taken all the key initiatives when the left was rising, refused to go along with the rate-raising local government left. We accurately pointed out what the choices were after Thatcher came to power in 1979. We were not mistaken. We pointed to the road of class struggle, of using local government to fight the Tories. We explained that Labour controlled local government would either be Thatcher's tool or a weapon pointed at her.

These were the alternatives. The ignominious collapse of the local government lett proves it. The collapse didn't come about as a result of unfavourable circumstances in a fight seriously fought. It came at the end of a long period of evasion and rate rises — ie passing on cuts and procrastination whose outcome was only too easy to predict.

The worst kind of defeat One thing is central to the story briefly outlined above. The point has already been made, but it must now be discussed in detail. It is this: the working class suffered no big defeats in an all out stand-up fight with the ruling class.

The defeat we suffered, and its consequences are still working their debilitating, poisoning way through the labour movement and the left. The defeat was a defeat without a battle, the worst of all defeats.

The heroic miners strike came very late, when the tide had been flowing very strong for Thatcher for nearly two years.

If when Thatcher and the ruling class she fights for went on the offensive we had mobilised and fought back, with the best of our strength, spirit and resources and - this defeat is the sort of defeat that saps the will and the morale and the self-confidence.

This is the sort of defeat that leads those who experience it not to ask: "What did we do wrong?" but "What is wrong with us". Trotsky long ago anatomised this sort of experience when he had to analyse the peaceful surrender of the mighty German labour movement, without a fight, to the murdering Nazis.

This type of defeat did not come only to the industrial big batalions. The defeat of the local government left was of that sort too. They didn't lose an all-out class battle. They lost out in a series of predictably - we predicted it and fought against it - foredoomed maneouvres. By way of which they hoped to avoid an all out clash with Thatcher. It was, for the Ken Livingstones, a "Grand Old Duke of York" game — the Duke who marched his men all the way up to the top of the hill and then "marched them down again". Except that the Grand Old Duke of York of Labour local government maneouvered under the powerful guns of the central state power controlled by Mrs Thatcher. He had no hope of survival.

It is this character of the defeats we suffered in the first half of the '80s which explain the way the left has melted away.

The electoral defeats of '83 and '87 are part of it of course - but they are more a consequence of the basic defeat than the cause of the semi-collapse of the left. It is because we were defeated the way we were in industry and local government alike that the seemingly vigorous left of 1980 has disbanded, split, divided and lost its nerve the way it has.

And on one level it is right and proper for the left which suffered this ignominious defeat to ask: "What's wrong with us". Unfortunately the conclusion of most 1980 leftists, about the reformist, don't-take-risks, look-for-a-lesserevil strategy is not that they made a wrong furn when they chose to go for evasion and procrastination against Thatcher rather than class struggle.

Their conclusion is that they were wrong even to dream and talk about 'naive' and 'utopian' and were the things the left dreamed and talked about in 1980 and '81. Just as they made the wrong decision about the rate rise strategv of easion, they now make the correlated conclusion: it was our goals and extremism' that was wrong. They don't understand that the methods they chose were radically at odds with the earth shaking intransigent goals and postures they indulged in.

Today, the left is not in the best condition. Even if we assume, as we probally should, that the vote for Benn and Heffer underestimates the strength of the left, it is a hell of a decline from the left's peak 7 years ago.

So what ao we do? What is SO's role now? What do we say the Left should do?

Today SO continues a battle for class strugele politics as the only road to socialism, that is of a free democratic working class society this country - the healthy, vigorous left of the future will be built politically upon an analysis and discussion and assimilation of the lessons of this great cycle of class stuggle including the negative lessons, part of which have been outlined above.

The hard left needs to arm itself with Marxism. Marixism isn't dead reduced to the idiotic *shamefaced-anarcho-syndicalism for 10 year olds" purveyed by the SWP, or to the craven right wing falsetto Thatcherism of the CP and 'Marxism Today'. But Marxism too suffers from the decades of international working class defeat, from the adulteration of 60 years state-power-holding Stalinism which has bits of pigeon Marxist phraseology as an oppressive state religion. What is and is not Marxism also needs to be hammered out 11 diologue and discussion free from religiosity and dogmatism.

The hard left needs to put the period of sectarianism behind it. Unfortunately the triumphant march of Kinnock and what he represents in the labour movement Will strengthen sectarianism and push politically immature people towards organisations such as the SWP. Sectarianism is one part of the price we pay for opportunism such as that of the Labour local unise itself opportunism sometimes part of the price we pay • in a vicious circle - for sectarianism. Some of the local government left fakers and opportunists - Ted Knight for example even came from a sectarian political background.

This is what the left needs to do. SO will try to continue to do what we have done in our first ten years - advocate the working class side in the class struggle; express our implacable opposition to the Tories and the right wing of the labour movement, and our no less implacable opposition to the totalitarian Stalinist forgery of socialism, and against those in the labour movement who champion and would replicate it.

For 10 years we have maintained an open paper which produces as a matter of course rebuffs and rejoinders to our editorial line and to our articles in the paper. We will continue to do so.

Only a fool would believe that the serious Marxist left has an easy time ahead. No, we haven't. It is most likely a very hard road ahead and there will be some who will find it too hard. Yet there is no other road.

We believe we live in a wage-slave society, in a world divided between the wage-slave system and the totalitarian state econom of the Stalinist states. If this is tiu...... follows that nothing will ever be right until we overthow that system in both its Eastern and Western versions.

We remain, despite all the problems and . setbacks, confident that the working class in the East and in the West will overthrow the systems of oppresion and make a ourselves, we will do what we can to achieve the great socialist goal: the liberation of humanity from class society.

Scan page 10

IEs HEABı5

----- pull-quotes -----

new world without class, race or sex oppression. In any case, for

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 374

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →