10 years that shaped the left
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser was founded ten years ag Since then, the left has seen many changes. Thatcherism has gone from strength to strength, while the Left has suffered defeats. John O'Mahony looks at the history of Socialist Organiser and the role it has on the Left.
Socialist Organiser is S ten years old. The first issue came out in October 1978, as the monthly paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory(SCLV). We went fortnightly in 1980, and weekly in 1981. The story of Socialist Organiser(SO) in these ten years is an important part of the story of the Left: it reflects and disects the whole story of the Left in this decade, which has seen such changes in the fortunes of the labour movement.
When the Left was rising on the offensive, SO was at the heart of that Left. SO was the paper of the SCLV in 1978-79; we initiated the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Democracy in 1980; helped organise Tony Benn's campaign for Deputy leader of the Party in 1981, when he won 83% of CLPs.
The SCLV conference of July 1978 brought together 200 labour movement activists from all over Britain. Many of them, like Ken Livingstone, Ted Knight etc, would occupy central positions in local government in subsequent years. We pledged to fight for a Labour victory and a Tory defeat - but to fight on socialist policies. We pleged ourselves to continue the fight Organiser for socialism after Labour had won an electoral victory over the Tories. We were convinced by experience that a re-elected Callaghan governemnt would have no socialist or working class answers to the crisis of British capitalism.
We'd seen Callaghan and Healy in 1977 and after dance to the dictates of the International Monetary Fund and pioneer — albeit timidly and half-heartedly - the sort of policies which later, in their fullbloodied version, came to be called Ultra-leftism We knew the Tories had to t stopped, but that Labour's old fashioned right wing was not viable alternative. So we organise to fight the Tories, recognising thi while Labour was the only viab option that the working class ha against them, Labour itself had 1 be transformed. We knew that th job was very urgent.
That was a time when sem anarchist ultra-leftism was still very powerful force on the Left. W fought against that ultra-leftisn The Socialist Workers Party mad its general propaganda for socialis and did strike support work. But had no immediate polticalsanswer to anything, except - 'Join th SWP'. That was its answer t everything!
NEW LOOK For a while in 1978, it seemed that they were going to stand candidates against Labour in the election. In the event they didn't; they chickened out. Instead they mumbled a grudging and half hearted call to •Vote Labour', while doing nothing to transform the Labour Party except trying to persuade individual socialists to abandon the fight against the right wing in the mass party of the working class and join them in sectarian isolation and irrelevance.
Most bizarre of all was 'Socialist" Unity. This was a mini-electoral alliance, held together only by the project of standing candidates in the general election. Its core was the International Marxist Group, which had perhaps 700 members, and a cluster of smaller groups such as "Big Flame' and 'Marxist Worker' This, they said, was the alternative to the Tories and the Labour Party!
But no, to be fair to them, they never sounded as if they believed that Socialist Unity was more than just an irresponsible stunt, whose purpose was to compete with the SWP. When they did better than the SWP in a by-election in 1977, there was no stopping them. So, led by the people who now publish Socialist Action, and by others who are today probably a majority of the committed supporters of Briefstupid side show focussed essentially on the SWP, just as the Thatcherites poised themselves to drive the party of the labour movement from office on a programme of drumming the labour movement into the ground. They stood a handful of candidates in the June 1979 election, all of which got no more than a hundred or two votes.
And beyond the more-or-less rational 'ultra-left' was the Workers Revolutionary Party, which had recently sold itself as a propagandist and spy (on dissident Arabs Jews) for Colonel Ghaddari nd Libya, and the vile Iraqi dictatorship. The WRP stood a few dozen Help bring Print boss plans to candidates. This was sick, but it was no joke. The WRP candidate in Newham North East got more votes than Arthur Latham, a leftish Labour MP, needed to keep his seat, which he lost...
The outrage that ultra leftists felt against the outgoing Labour government was shared by those who set up the SCLV. But we knew outrage wasn't enough. We knew Labour - Labour as it was — was the only alternative to the Tories. We knew that socialists could not at will by-pass the Labour Party, which had been built over many decades by the organised working class. We knew that at the heart of the ultra-leftists' posturing, strident 'revolutionary' and 'positively socialist' as it seemed, there was deep pessimism and defeatism -and on certain levels, indifference: Since emple the groupie they has tionary Communist Party - about the labour movement being able to fight off the gathering Tory offensive. For, whether they knew it or not, to write off the Labour Party then was to say that the Tories would win governmental power and that their offensive would thereby gain an immense boost in strength and power to inflict damage on the labour movement.
A socialist cor T-lu.
The SCLV sought a different road. We combined the fight against the Tories with a fight to organise the left to resist a new right wing Labour government, and the fight to renew, renovate the labour movement - what Tony Benn was later to call the refounding of the Labour Party'. Our position was: not an inch to the Tories in the country, and not an inch to the right wing inside the labour movement.
In October 1978, the SCL V launched SO, w advocate socialist policies - and organise for them.
In the build up to the 1979 election, we put out election leaflets explaining the socialist position on the key political questions. These were circulated by local parties. It ammounted to a socialist election campaign within the official election campaign.
When we began, Labour was still in power, and Thatcher just a nasty rumbling threat on the sidelines. Even after the Tories won the general election, the labour movement still seemed to possess most of its old strength and vigour, and all of its determination not to let itself be pushed around by the bosses and the Tory party.
After the election, the Labour Party immediately blew wide open. Thousands of militants said of the recent bitter experience of right wing Labour government, Never again!" They set out to remake the Labour Party, to equip it with policies that would be a real socialist answer to Thatcher. A majority of the CLPs took this attitude. We went on to elect Michael Foot as leader; won the electoral college for electing Labour leaders - depriving the Parliamentarians of their long-established monopoly. Tony Benn won almost 50% of the votes for Deputy leader in 1981, and 83% of the CLP vote. The labour movement did indeed seem to be remaking itself. SO took an initiative in 1980 in creating the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Democracy, a body which for a year or so united the left in a way that it has not been united since.
Within a short time after the 1979 election, opinion polls showed that Thatcher was deeply unpopular. She remained deeply unpopular until the Falklands War of 1982. A high level of working class militancy continued. The massive industrial slump had yet to bear down on industrial militancy, depressing and undermining it. When the Tories embarked on the first of a series of anti-trade union laws, many militants began to talk of organising a general strike, of doing to Thatcher what we'd done to the Heath government in 1973-74, when the labour movement made it impossible for Heath to rule and forced him into a general election, which the Tories lost.
A missed opportunity Reading the articles of that period now, you find yourself wondering if we were in the grip of a delerium! General Strike! In fact we were the opposite of delerious.
We were sober and true to reality when we argued for the labour movement to put itself on the alert and go all out to beat Thatcher before Thatcher could grind us Today, Thatcher seems an immensely powerful figure, almost invincible. That's because she has won a cumulative series of battles with the labour movement, and because we have lost them.
At the turn of the decade, however, it not only seemed different - it was different. If the labour movement had had leaders fit for the name, men and women with guts and committment, leaders willing to fight and win on our side of the class struggle as Thatcher and her cronies have fought for theirs - if we had had that, things would have gone differently. The general pre-*82 unpopularity of Thatcher could have been linked with industrial action, against, for example, anti-union laws, in a great anti-Tory crusade.
With leaders worthy of the name, millions of British workers — people who during the seventies were among the most militant workers anywhere — need not have allowed themselves peacefully to be thrown out of the factories and onto the lengthening dole queues. • With proper TUC leadership, industrial battles like the steel strike, and, of course, later the miners' strike, could have been won. The fighting sections of the class wouldn't have, one after the other, been left to fight on alone to defeat.
No, we were not delerious in 1980 and afterwards when we called for working class action to drive the Tories from office. That could have been done, before the Tories achieved the ascendancy they now have in British national life. That it wasn't done is one of the greatest crimes of misleadership in the long. history of the international working class.I The bitter truth is that the Tories never defeated the working class in a head-on battle. They won by stealth and deception, using the economic slump as one weapon and the cowardice of most trade union leaders as the other.
The place of the Labour Party left this saga of tragically avoidable defeat was a central one.* It so happened that when Thatcher moved into Downing Street, the Labour left was moving towards taking over the town halls -Lambeth, Sheffield, the GLC etc. What did they do there? These were people who had pondered on the recent record of the WilsonCallaghan governemnt and concluded, "Never again'. There must, they said, be a better way than this.
They began to take power in the town halls just as Thatcher was using her power in government to get down to radically reshaping Britain to make it more like the Red in Tooth and Claw capitalism in
Scan page 9
YOU MAY had, nevertheless, been beaten, then that would be clear and clean. We could analyse why, ask what we did wrong, what forces — a slump and growing unemployment for example - which we couldn't control, worked against us.
But this defeat: a slow wasting away of the strength of the labour movement; the succession of retreats following after retreats; the leaders from Len Murray to Norman Willis to Neil Kinnock who appear to have acted and to be acting under an inner compulsion to bow the knee to Thatcher and the Tories with neither, capitalist exploitation or the kind of state tyranny you have in the Stalinist states.
The left should unite around a basic programme of commitment to the working class and the promotion of the struggles of the working class, and hard commitment to the fight to replace the present wageslave system with a cooperative, democratic socialist system as the central goal of our politics.
The left should learn the lessons of its own avoidable defeats. In the last 30 years we have been through an immense cycle of class struggle in
----- pull-quotes -----
Socialist Vo ser Organiser Shopworkers vote to boycott apartheid STOP orested JUNE 12th
Socialist the new HOUG
Socialist: strike to defend Organiser