Block votes and block heads
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-10-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
The trade union block vote has always been an easy target for those in the business of knocking the labour movement.
The spectacle of General Secretaries brandishing cards supposedly representing the views of hundreds of thousands of their members, can indeed by pretty ludicrous - especially when you know full well that the 'members' have never been properly consulted. It's probably no accident that one of the best remembered sketches from 'Alas Smith and Jones' is the one where union bosses decide Whether to order tea or coffee by card vote (*1.3m for coffee... etc.
n theory, at least the block vote is an expression of the historic link between the Labour Party and the unions and a recognition that, through their affiliations, the unions largely fund the party. In the early '80s this principle was extended to the election of the leader and the deputy leader, with the electoral college giving 30% of the vote each to the constituency parties and the MPs, and 40% to the unions.
This year, in the first leadership contest since Neil Kinnock defeated Roy Hattersley in 1983 the vast majority of the union votes were duly delivered to the door of the Kinnock/Hattersley 'dream ticket' Most unions did at least through the motions of consulting their members. Some (like NUPE and the AEU) did it by postal ballot; others (CoHSE, SOGAT, UCATT) went for a branch or workplace ballot. The FBU and MSF left it up to the branches whether to hold a ballot or decide by show of hands. Circulation of candidates' election material was very patchy with only CoHSE, MSF and the FBU making any serious effort to either circulate the branches with material from all candidates, or include statements in the union's journal. The AEU leadership did, however, ensure that the members knew what was required of them: all ballot papers included a recommendation to vote for Kinnock and Hattersley.
The NUR vote was decided at the unions Annual General Meeting. There was no consultation of any sort with the branches and nothing about the issue appeared in the union "Transport Gazette' . The AGM went for Kinnock and Hattersley, with Benn and Heffer getting 22 votes out of 77.
The GMB claims to have held something called a 'branch consultation exercise resulting in 83% in favour of the existing leadership as against 15.5% for a joint Kinnock/Prescott ticket. How such a precise result emerged is something of a mystery which no one except that intellectual giant of the labour movement John Edmunds seems to understand. Certainly, none of the GMB members consulted by Sleeper, were aware of any systematic 'consultation' beyond a circular asking branches for their 'opinions' The TGWU leadership knows all about the problems that can arise from "consultation' exercises. Back in 1981 they held one of these mysterious rituals when Tony Benn stood against Denis Healey for the deputy leadership. At first the result was said to be a narrow majority for Benn. Then the T&G's well organised right wing caucus got onto their friends in the media and told them that, in fact, the 'consultation' had favoured Healey. In the end, Moss Evans had to admit that no one really knew for sure and the decision was left up to the Labour Party delegation which plumped for Benn after a lot of wrangling.
In order to avoid any confusion (not to mention adverse publicity) this time, no formal consultation (let alone a proper vote) of any kind was held and the decision was left entirely in the hands of the delegation - which everyone knew was going to back Kinnock and Hattersley.
All of which, of course, resulted in the expected landslide of the dream ticket at Blackpool last week.
t is, though, worth noting that in the unions that at least made an effort to circulate material from all the candidates, the dream ticket came slightly unstuck: in NUPE Prescott defeated Hattersley by 63% to 31%: in MSF Benn gained a respectable 37% (to Kinnock's 63%) and Prescott defeated Hattersley by 45% to 36% with 18% going to Heffer.
The truth is, of course, that none of the union leaders were terribly interested in genuine 'consultation' with their members - and still less in a real debate on the issue within the branches and workplaces. The "left' leaders (with the exception of Arthur Scargill, but that's another story) wanted to re-affirm their loyalty to Kinnock in the hope of keeping him somewhere near to the straight and narrow when it comes to the policy reviews and issues like disarmament, the anti-union laws and nationalisation. Right wingers like the AEU's Bill Jordan and the and AE leaderships plus the 'hard right' from other unions, notably the TGWU) obviously had no option but to back the Kinnock/Hattersley ticket, which they believe is irreversibly moving their way. But if the move isn't fast enough or decisive enough (especially on the defence issue) they still haven't ruled out dumping Kinnock and throwing their weight behind John Smith for leader in the near future. A arcane and far removed. Il of which may sound very from the realities of day to day shop floor trade unionism. But, unfortunately, it's of crucial importance to the future of the British labour movement. When, many years ago, some of us started talking about an 'open valve' relationship between the unions and the Labour Party a lot of people on the left objected - the unions were fundamentally *the fighting organisations of our class' while the Labour Party was irredeemably tied to capitalism and, at best, of secondary importance to workers, they sagely pronounced.
Events at Blackpool (not to mention the forthcoming policy reviews) should demonstrate once and for all the necessity of taking the fight for rank and file democracy and genuine socialism into both arenas. Not an easy task, agree. But only a blockhead can now deny it's necessary.
----- pull-quotes -----
INSIDE THE UNIONS By Sleeper
secretive 'Mainstream' organisation (that brings together the EETPU